4 ms·
>>>> Importantly, however, only e-mail addresses were obtained. No names or passwords were obtained, and no accounts were actually accessed. Why is it importa
by smsm42 14y ago
>>>> Importantly, however, only e-mail addresses were obtained. No names or passwords were obtained, and no accounts were actually accessed.
Why is it important? If, as Orin Kerr claims, emails were public information, so were names and passwords, if stored under the same scheme. So if he accessed names and passwords, it would be also authorized access by the same logic. But it seems to me somehow Orin Kerr feels the weakness in this argument. Since he doesn't really expects people to believe that if you find a hole in a site that allows downloading account passwords via exploiting some vulnerability in HTTP server sending it some specially crafted data - he feels that it is necessary to emphasize that passwords weren't accessed. But many people consider their personal email no less private than their password - so if it wasn't OK to take the password (and by emphasizing that no passwords were taken Orin Kerr seems to implicitly admit it would be important if the passwords were taken) then it also wasn't OK to take the emails.
On the question of felony though he may have a point. Felony is a grave crime that renders the criminal second-class citizen long after the prison term has been served. I think for non-violent crime that did not result in actual grave harm it is too much, and while I remain unsympathetic to Auernheimer's person, I think if Orin Kerr succeeds in somehow reducing it to lesser grade (or cause a change in the law that leads to that) it would be great.
- smsm42 14y agoInterestingly enough, whoever downvoted it didn't bother to counter-argument. Because yeah, why bother?
- jessaustin 14y agoI upvoted your top comment but I'm definitely downvoting this whinging about downvoting. That shit has to stop, or HN will become truly unreadable.
- smsm42 14y agoI'm not whining about downvoting, I'm whining about people not willing to participate in proper discussion but still voting. What's the point in the whole system then?