6 ms·
I agree with you completely here. However, I think that it's worth arguing from that weak position. I've had a hard time articulating why I think that a) weev'
by eridius 14y ago
I agree with you completely here.
However, I think that it's worth arguing from that weak position. I've had a hard time articulating why I think that a) weev's online actions aren't illegal, and yet b) why weev should still be punished. But arguing from that weak position and getting the CFAA charge dropped would actually resolve this issue. My problem with what weev did, and why I think he should be published, is because of his malicious intent. So getting the CFAA charge dropped would be a win for everyone, but leaving the fraud charge in place would still appropriately punish weev (although I think 41 months is too high).
- rayiner 14y agoI totally agree on the substance of what you said. Just noting that these sorts of cases are much easier when the client is pure as the virgin snow.
- sneak 14y agoHis malicious intent was to damage ATT's reputation, not to cause harm to individuals via their email addresses. That was discussed, and then not done. Damaging ATT's reputation via demonstrating how insecure and careless they are, while malicious, is not criminal.
- rosser 14y ago...while malicious, is not criminal. I think this case, along with Swartz's case, and the Alfred Anaya case that was on the HN front page last night [1] all serve to demonstrate that at this point, a criminal act is whatever a Federal prosecutor decides is a criminal act. In the Anaya case, the "crime" of which he was convicted wasn't even illegal under Federal law, and yet he's serving 24 years. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5413127 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5413127
- rayiner 14y agoYou have to be joking. You're linking to an article about a guy who installs secret compartments in vehicles for narcotics traffickers. Even after he finds a floor stuffed with $800,000 in cash, he continues to help them, repairing the compartment in one car and agreeing to install a compartment in another. What is so hard to understand about the concept that something may or may not be a crime depending on context? Standing in front of a door? Not illegal in general. Standing in front of a door to keep police from being able to chase a bank robber? That's aiding and abetting and is and should be illegal.
- rosser 14y agoI'm not saying Anaya wasn't an idiot — even willfully so — or that he shouldn't have been charged under California statute on traps and their being used to transport narcotics. The issue in his case isn't that he wasn't guilty of a crime; it's that he wasn't guilty of a Federal crime — both because there is no such Federal crime, and because he could perfectly well have been prosecuted, convicted, and sentenced under perfectly applicable State law. Contrariwise, do you seriously believe that he deserves more than twice the sentence that the people who actually trafficked the drugs got? Do you actually think that your notional door-blocking person should have his case usurped by the Feds and get a stiffer sentence than the bank robber he aided and abetted? (Edited)
- rayiner 14y agoBuilding hidden compartments for people in SoCal is stupid. Building them after you see 800k stuffed in a car is not just the sign of an idiot, it's the sign of someone consciously choosing to profit from facilitating criminal activity. And it can be totally valid to punish one person who helps out many criminals more harshly than one single criminal. It's also the case that sentences are handed down not just based on what the defendant did, but what the prosecutor could prove, and its quite possible that it Anaya left more evidence that could be used against him than a seasoned criminal.
- fnordfnordfnord 14y ago>it's the sign of someone consciously choosing to profit from facilitating criminal activity. And it can be totally valid to punish one person who helps out many criminals more harshly than one single criminal. It is now a matter of public record that HSBC, Wachovia, JP Morgan, and others have laundered huge sums of 'drug money' in operations ongoing for many years. So, for those individuals and companies who continue to do business with the banks involved, are they "consciously choosing to profit from facilitating criminal activity"? Can a businessman refuse service to someone they suspect are involved in criminal activity? Does a businessman have a duty to refuse service to someone they suspect are involved in criminal activity?
- bradleyjg 14y agoMalicious intent only satisfies one half of the definition of a crime -- the mens rea component. You also need an actus reus -- a guilty act. That's where this case falls down.
- rayiner 14y agoYou don't need a guilty act. You need an act. A crime can be taking an otherwise legal act with malicious intent.