9 ms·
My letter to Jim Franklin about why I'm leaving SendGrid
- michaelwww 14y agoStephen Fry: It's now very common to hear people say 'I'm rather offended by that.' As if that gives them certain rights; it's actually nothing more...it's simply a whine. 'I find that offensive,' it has no meaning, it has no purpose, it has no reason to be respected as a phrase. 'I'm offended by that,' well so fucking what? Ricky Gervais: Just because someone is offended doesn't mean they're right.
- erikpukinskis 14y agoI don't give a shit about people being offended. If the only thing happening is someone being "offended" then there's no harm, no foul. Go along with your day. Now, in cases where people are being harmed, then I care. This is such a case.
- rsanders 14y agoWhat was the harm, exactly? She overheard a stupid joke far less crude than one might hear on any television show during prime time. It was no worse than the one she posted on her own Twitter.
- erikpukinskis 14y agoWomen in our industry are forced to listen to constant jokes that range from the one she heard to far worse. This little joke would probably not be a problem if if were isolated. But because they happen all the time, from all directions, each little joke has the potential to be a harmful barb. And the fact that she posted a joke to her Twitter doesn't change anything. There is massive pressure on women to be sexist too, to prove to men that they're cool and can be trusted, and to fit in. Women (also have to find ways to normalize sexist behavior so they don't go crazy. The fact that a women capitulates to this pressure on one day doesn't make her fair game for any and all sexist abuses on another.
- ramblerman 14y agoPerhaps white knights like yourself are the real sexists here. You buy into, along with Richards, the notion that all women are victorian prudes and can't deal with off-beat humor. These men didn't direct their lowbrow humor at adria. In fact they didn't even direct it at women. They compared their dongles and joked about forking the 'male' speaker.
- dalke 14y agoThe issue has nothing to do with being a prude. The law says that certain workplace practices are illegal. The law clearly says that some forms of workplace humor, including sexist jokes, racist jokes, jokes about religion, and more, might be part of an workplace culture that is illegally discriminatory, and may be reported without fear of reprisal from the employer. Yes, the law says that reporting potential cases of workplace harassment is a protected action, and cannot be used to fire someone. The law does not require that sexist humor be directed towards the same gender as the person who reported the incident, just like it doesn't require that racist humor be about the same race as the person who reported the incident. The law doesn't even require that the person who reported the incident be the one who was subject to the harassment. The law even protects people who make a truthful report that is later determined to not be discriminatory. The same laws do not apply to watching prime-time television shows, so the earlier comment of rsanders does not apply. One difference is that it's easy to turn the television off, while it's hard to quit a job and find a new one. Someone on cable television can tell racist jokes until the cows come home. Telling racist jokes at work, no matter how funny the jokes are, can create a hostile work environment, in violation of the law. The same with sexist jokes. That's because the law has special protections for race, religion, sex, marital status, veteran status, and others. You might think that details of laws are as useless as the White Knight's "anklets to guard his horse against shark bites", but the law is the law. Reporting possible cases of workplace harassment is protected under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act and may not be used as the basis for firing someone. Your personal beliefs on who the sexists are may be entirely correct, though I doubt it. But your personal beliefs are almost diametrically opposite what the law says, while the events we're all talking about are definitely well-defined and protected in current law and legal practice.
- escaped_hn 14y agoThe guy who got fired with the 3 kids was the only one harmed in this entire debacle.
- 7beersonthewall 14y agoStupid...
- abcbaby 14y agooverhearing someone say a crude/childish joke to a friend constitutes "abuse" now? ...ok
- tomflack 14y ago> Richards should be absolutely commended for what she did, documenting and publicizing the abuse against her. It’s extremely hard to do, and it’s incredibly valuable to the community. From what I understand, she wasn't subject to abuse until after the tweet went live. She overheard some slightly lewd jokes not directed at her and decided to use a public forum to shame the jokers instead of more appropriate means.
- erikpukinskis 14y agoIn the context of a professional environment with fairly constant misogyny, I think it does constitute abuse. She's just trying to attend a conference and she's forced to stop focusing on the tech, stop focusing on doing her job, and instead focus on the people behind her and whether she's safe in the space. The hypervigilance that pervasive sexism in the tech community demands from women is extremely harmful. It makes these spaces very unpleasant for most women. And so all women are excluded except the handful with very thick skin who think these things are "no big deal".
- citruspi 14y ago> she's forced to stop focusing on the tech, stop focusing on doing her job, and instead focus on the people behind her Assuming that this was true - she was so overwhelmed by jokes about a dongle that she could not concentrate on the conference - she could have easily turned around and told them that the conversation made her uncomfortable. She did not have to, and should not have, publicly shamed them for a private joke. > whether she's safe in the space Where does this come from? It was a joke about a dongle. Anatomy. Even if it was sexual, which is questionable, she was not threatened. They never threatened her. They never gave her lewd looks. They were never a threat to her or other people at the conference.
- erikpukinskis 14y ago> She did not have to, and should not have, publicly shamed them for a private joke Why shouldn't she have? It's harmful to the community. Until we, as a group, create a culture of publicly standing up to these things, and supporting those who do, they won't change. > she was not threatened Sexist jokes come in a wide range of shapes and sizes. In our culture, women are usually blamed for violence against them. They are held responsible for the company they keep, and the situations they get themselves into. But the truth is, there is NO reliable way to tell whether a man, or a situation is truly safe for you. Friends, people you're dating, colleagues, private parties, worksplaces all can go from "seems save" to "violent" in the blink of an eye. As such, women are forced to develop a set of vague signals that they must be constantly vigilant of. One of those signals is how men use and respond to sexist jokes. By telling sexist jokes, you are engaging many womens' Safety Detection System.
- nemothekid 14y agoNot sure I can agree with this letter. 1.) From what I can gather she wasn't the direct target of abuse, so to frame that was is disingenuous. I understand that making "dongle" jokes at a conference is inappropriate, but its nothing more than inappropriate. 2.) How she handled it was completely wrong and unprofessional. Again like Amanda Blum[1] states, she has frequently sidestepped the right channels and has taken issues into her own hands. This has caused considerable trouble for PyCon, SendGrid and PlayHaven. SendGrid, should not be DDoS for several hours over a dick joke. People lost money. More than anything that is the take away here. I doubt Adria would have lost her job if she took it twitter after coming to the conclusion that the men won't be apologetic and PyCon wouldn't do anything about it. [1]https://amandablumwords.wordpress.com/2013/03/21/3/ https://amandablumwords.wordpress.com/2013/03/21/3/
- dalke 14y agoI don't see where the letter says or implies there was direct abuse. It just says abuse. I interpret it as meaning that the author believes that indirect abuse, including hearing sexist jokes while in the workplace, should also be "absolutely unacceptable." That is not a novel or even rare viewpoint. For examples that I easily found: "Sexual abuse includes: Telling sexual jokes that make the victim uncomfortable" - http://haventhedalles.org/sexual-abuse.html http://haventhedalles.org/sexual-abuse.html "Sexual abuse ... [can even take the form of] telling sexual jokes at the victim’s expense." - http://www.flaknelaw.com/minnesota-family-law/domestic-violence/are-you-a-victim/ http://www.flaknelaw.com/minnesota-family-law/domestic-viole... "[Patterns of] Sexual Abuse .. Makes sexual jokes about women" - http://www.wcsafeharbors.com/domestic_violence_patterns.html http://www.wcsafeharbors.com/domestic_violence_patterns.html This is why documents like http://www3.uakron.edu/lawrev/robert1.html http://www3.uakron.edu/lawrev/robert1.html include things like: > Professor Catherine MacKinnon advises companies to warn employees against posting suggestive photographs, telling sexual jokes or making innuendoes, or romancing subordinates. ... Finally, she says that the company should prohibit everyone in the company from retaliating against a worker who files a sexual harassment complaint. Do also note that this firing treads close to the anti-retaliation laws. Quoting from the EEOC at http://www.eeoc.gov/laws/types/facts-retal.cfm http://www.eeoc.gov/laws/types/facts-retal.cfm : > An employer may not fire, demote, harass or otherwise "retaliate" against an individual for filing a charge of discrimination, participating in a discrimination proceeding, or otherwise opposing discrimination. I am not saying that this firing is in violation of the law and EEOC rules, because I'm not a lawyer and I don't know the case history. But my naive reading of the EEOC Compliance manual, at http://www.eeoc.gov/policy/docs/retal.html#IIpartB http://www.eeoc.gov/policy/docs/retal.html#IIpartB: > Public criticism of alleged discrimination may be a reasonable form of opposition. Courts have protected an employee's right to inform an employer's customers about the employer's alleged discrimination, as well as the right to engage in peaceful picketing to oppose allegedly discriminatory employment practices. suggests that posting those pictures is likely a protected action. If so, then while you may think it's "unprofessional", it's not a valid reason for firing someone. (The laws are made even more complicated by a balancing act between what a "reasonable person" would expect, the understanding that an employee don't know all of the details of the law, and more factors. Like, Richards's job requires going to conferences, hence PyCon is part of the workplace, but SendGrid doesn't have control over what happens at the conference, so discrimination claims filed to SendGrid are useless.) I'm pretty sure you don't know how the EEOC would handle this case either, since your #2 does not reflect at least my limited understanding of the relevant laws. Protected opposition can include doing things that are "unprofessional" and things that cost others money (the EEOC's example is a production slow-down). Also, you brought up an account of how "she has frequently sidestepped the right channels", but unless they were related to her job, I suspect that they cannot be used to fire someone. Specifically, Colorado law C.R.S 24-34-402.5 ("Unlawful prohibition of legal activities as a condition of employment") (1) It shall be a discriminatory or unfair employment practice for an employer to terminate the employment of any employee due to that employee's engaging in any lawful activity off the premises of the employer during nonworking hours unless such a restriction: (a) Relates to a bona fide occupational requirement or is reasonably and rationally related to the employment activities and responsibilities of a particular employee or a particular group of employees, rather than to all employees of the employer; or (b) Is necessary to avoid a conflict of interest with any responsibilities to the employer or the appearance of such a conflict of interest. (SendGrid appears to be a Colorado company, but other states have similar laws. See also the note 'This section applies to lawful, off-duty conduct, even if it is work-related. Insofar as the section refers to "any lawful activity", it can be presumed that the general assembly meant all activity without limitation. Accordingly, damages could be awarded to person who was terminated for making a complaint off the premises of the employer during nonworking hours about the safety of a work site. Watson v. Pub. Serv. Co., 207 P.3d 860 (Colo. App. 2008).') Thus, it really does read that if Richards is fired because of any of the reasons you gave in #2, then it's likely an unfair and illegal employment practice, and Richards can sue and win.
- bigalo93 14y agoDocumenting a problem is completely different from public humiliation. This company did the right thing. You say Adria received abuse, but out of all I have read, including her own blog post, she was not abused. She was the aggressor. These men didn't even know she was offended. If she would have asked them to be more polite, I am confident they would have done the right thing. You, I must say, are causing an issue with a company in the right. So maybe they are better off without you, Heh?
- 7beersonthewall 14y agoRight on... She went to Twitter. She opened the can of worms instead of saying something directly to them. She should have expected what she got.
- monkeyspaw 14y agoYou can't seriously suggest that she deserved the misogynistic abuse heaped on after the fact, can you?
- jrdn 14y agoNo, she didn't. The Internet hate machine went out of control as it has a tendency to do. The fact that gaooened afterwards, however, doesn't make her initial reaction to name and shame these guys more acceptable.
- dalke 14y agoTitle VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 was put into place precisely because people in a discriminated group would speak out, only to be told that their manner of speaking out was not "acceptable." "Speaking out" under Title VII includes picketing, writing letters to customers about the discrimination, and engaging in work slow-downs. These are not acceptable actions to some, but they are legally protected actions and a company cannot fire an employee who carried out one of these actions. Since what she wrote specifically refers to sexual harassment ("Sexual harassment is a form of sex discrimination that violates Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964". "[It] constitutes sexual harassment when submission to or rejection of this conduct explicitly or implicitly affects an individual's employment, unreasonably interferes with an individual's work performance or creates an intimidating, hostile or offensive work environment", "The harasser can be ... a non-employee." - EEOC's "Facts about Sexual Harassment"), it's almost certainly a protected action under Title VII. If so, then while it may not be acceptable to you and various others, it's illegal for her company to fire her because of that action. Assuming I understand the law correctly. To show I'm not just making this up, I'll quote from the judgement in Sumner v. United States Postal Service, 899 F.2d 203 (2d Cir. 1990): In addition to protecting the filing of formal charges of discrimination, Sec. 704(a)'s opposition clause protects as well informal protests of discriminatory employment practices, including making complaints to management, writing critical letters to customers, protesting against discrimination by industry or by society in general, and expressing support of co-workers who have filed formal charges. See Grant v. Hazelett Strip-Casting Corp., 880 F.2d 1564, 1569 (2d Cir.1989), and Schlei & Grossman, Employment Discrimination Law, 548-49 (1983)." See the part about "protesting against discrimination by industry"? Doesn't that describe this situation almost exactly? Now, if she broke a law, or violated some employee policy in a way that has nothing to do with Title VII nor is some other illegal practice (eg, it's illegal to suddenly fire her for doing personal blogging during company time if her supervisors had long known about that practice and had never given a caution or warning that it was a fireable offense) then that's a different issue. But no one has suggested anything of this sort. So, while you might be offended by what she did, that doesn't mean she "should have expected what she got" if that includes that she got fired from her job.
- IvyMike 14y agoThis whole situation has been a clusterfuck, with overreactions by almost everyone involved. This strikes me as yet another overreaction.
- 7beersonthewall 14y agoDitto...
- erikpukinskis 14y agoThat's cool, you're entitled to your opinion. But you writing that adds nothing to the conversation. I think the fact that the vast majority of women are not comfortable going to tech conferences and working at many tech companies is actually a big deal, and the rare cases where someone actually DOES something in response to it is actually a pretty landmark event that deserves significant attention. If you feel differently, at least try to articulate why.
- dopamean 14y agoI'm not disagreeing with you but where do you get this stuff about the vast majority of women being uncomfortable going to tech conferences? Is that anecdotal? Is there a study you can cite? Also, just because someone is offended doesn't give them the right to respond however they want. They still need to be responsible.
- erikpukinskis 14y agoTech conferences are overwhelmingly male. Just look around.
- dopamean 14y agoYes. That is obvious. But how does that translate to the claim you made that the vast majority of women are uncomfortable going to tech conferences?
- IvyMike 14y ago
- sheraz 14y ago...And so continues the chain of overreactions... The emotional development of all involved, including these shallow protests, have the funk of adolescence and immaturity. I keep waiting for the principal to walk down the hall and break up the tantrum and shouting match. Erik, grow up. Adira, grow up. Guys in the back, grow up. Let me continue the High School metaphor for a moment: Guys in the back, you are two man-boys who never matured or learned any etiquette, and your dick joke was (unfortunately) overheard by the wrong person. Adira, you are the nosy busy-body that would rat out anyone who you perceive to break the rules. Erik your symbolic protest reminds me of the permanently "friend-zoned" guy who tries to show that not all men are pigs. That is the level of drama here. Its playing out like a lost episode of Saved by the Bell. I keep waiting for Screech to bring some levity to the situation. Because that is not going to happen, I will leave you with this: Q. How many feminists does it take to screw in a lightbulb? A. One. AND THAT IS NOT FUNNY! Edit: better word choice
- Gigablah 14y agoCareful now, that joke might get you fired.
- tn13 14y agoCant agree with this letter. It is stupid to call the dongle jokes cracked between two friends as "abuse". This seems to be an over reaction. Stop fighting the strawman err strawperson guys.
- Nightrider 14y agoSince SendGrid won't stand behind their employees who make a stand, I'm no longer interested in doing business with them. With what I read of the letter (I didn't read it all the way through) I agree with it.
- escaped_hn 14y agoI fail to see how she was "abused" at Pycon.
- dalke 14y agoDo you think abuse is limited to physical abuse? Verbal abuse is still a type of abuse. Though as Wikipedia points out, "[d]espite being the most common form of abuse, verbal abuse is generally not taken as seriously as other types, because there is no visible proof..." I believe the logic is pretty straight-forward. Sexist opinions in the tech industry (and/or culture in general) have lead to a hostile workplace for a woman whose job includes going to many tech conferences and who often hears sexist jokes and other (unstated) sexist statements. These are a form of verbal sexual harassment, which is a type of verbal abuse. To continue from the same Wikipedia citation for "Verbal abuse", "In reality, however, verbal abuse can be more detrimental to a person's health than physical abuse."
- nbouscal 14y agoThe jokes were not sexist. I've had to type that sentence so many times the keys are starting to wear in. The jokes were not sexist. They were not about women, directed towards women, or discriminatory towards women. They didn't have anything to do with women at all. Calling a dongle joke sexist is extremely detrimental because it distracts from real instances of sexism that do occur within this community. We need to talk about the real issues, and this incident is not one of them.
- dalke 14y agoJokes do not need to be directed towards women in order to be sexist. Sexist jokes directed towards men can also be sexist and contribute towards a hostile workplace. Nor do the jokes need to be directed towards the person or even the gender of the person making the complaint. That's well established by the courts. Quoting from the EEOC: > Sexual harassment can occur in a variety of circumstances, including but not limited to the following: * The victim as well as the harasser may be a woman or a man. The victim does not have to be of the opposite sex. * The harasser can be the victim's supervisor, an agent of the employer, a supervisor in another area, a co-worker, or a non-employee. * The victim does not have to be the person harassed but could be anyone affected by the offensive conduct. * Unlawful sexual harassment may occur without economic injury to or discharge of the victim. * The harasser's conduct must be unwelcome. You may say that going after this situation is "extremely detrimental" to the overall cause, but you've switched different topic. escaped_hn asked where the abuse claim came from, not if the abuse claim was justifiable. Let's see how this an organization's Harassment policy might handle this. I quote now from http://www.maine.gov/ag/about/harrassment_policy.html http://www.maine.gov/ag/about/harrassment_policy.html : > Further examples of sexual harassment include: behavior that is verbal and sexual in nature - such as comments about a person's looks, personal inquiries, sexual jokes, use of derogatory sexual stereotypes, uttering sexually suggestive sounds, writing sexual notes, use of State computer equipment to send, receive and/or download material of a sexual nature; non-verbal sexual behavior- such as looking someone up and down, staring or leering at someone's body, deliberate blocking of a person's path, displaying sexual visuals, making sexual gestures; or physical - such as pinching, grabbing, sexual assault or any physical contact of a sexual nature. > As a matter of State policy, any behavior of a sexual nature in the workplace is considered unprofessional regardless of whether it constitutes illegal sexual harassment. ... As part of their supervisory responsibilities, supervisors are required to actively prevent or stop inappropriate, unprofessional conduct in the workplace regardless of whether the conduct rises to the level of illegal harassment. If they become aware of any such conduct occurring through personal observation or information from another party, they must consult with the Office's EEO Coordinator and take immediate and appropriate corrective action, including discipline, to end the conduct. Corrective action is required regardless of whether a complaint is made or the conduct appears to be unwelcome. Even if the person providing information requests that no action be taken, the supervisor must contact the EEO Coordinator. Managers and supervisors who fail to fulfill their obligations under this policy will be subject to disciplinary action, up to and including discharge. This unambiguously says that a supervisor at the Maine AG's office must report any joke of a sexual nature, even if there's no complaint, no indication of if it's unwelcome, no indication that it's discriminatory, no thought that it's sexist, and even if there's a request that no action be taken. So even if you don't think this is a sexist joke, the undeniable fact that it is a joke of a sexual nature means that it is and unprofessional and reportable behavior for some workplaces.