11 ms·
Orin Kerr: Why I Am Representing Auernheimer Pro Bono on Appeal
- gruseom 14y agoQuestion for the local counsel: how much harder is Kerr's job made by entering only at the appeal stage, as opposed to if he had been representing Auernheimer from the beginning? e.g. are there issues/arguments he won't be able to bring up now that he could have earlier?
- Lazare 14y agoI can give you the general answer to that: At the trial stage, you can argue matters of fact. Stuff like "my client was at home in bed when the events occurred" or "those teeth marks don't evem match his dog!" Since we are now at the appeal stage, barring something huge, all the facts the trial court decided were true have to be assumed true. So he can't now argue that Weev didn't actually access AT&Ts servers. All he can discuss now is whether the court correctly applied the law to the facts it determined at trial, and that means... ...that it won't hamper Kerr at all. The facts here aren't disputed; everyone agrees on what Weev did, how AT&Ts servers were configured, where Weev was, where the servers were, how AT&T responded to the breach. The dispute is entirely down to how the court applied the law (or indeed, whether it was even in the right court), and that's stuff which is best addressed (in some ways, only addressable) at the appeal level. TL;DR: It doesn't make Kerr's job harder at all; in fact he can only do his job at the appeal stage, as his concerns are very much with the trial courts decision, not with the facts the court based that decision on.
- redthrowaway 14y agoSo if the Appeals court can only decide if the law was applied correctly, does that mean it would have to go to the Supreme Court in order to determine if the law is constitutional?
- DannyBee 14y agoAppeals courts can determine whether a law is constitutional. However, all courts strongly prefer not to if they can.
- Lazare 14y agoNo, any court can - in theory - declare a law or its application unconstitutional, but the lower courts are very reluctant to do so, and even appeals courts prefer to only do so in bright line cases. And I don't think this is; even if the court has grave reservations about the law, they'll likely punt and hope the Supreme Court figures it out.
- mcherm 14y agoNo, any court can decide if the law is applied correctly or decide that a law is unconstitutional -- in fact, the lowest level of court can overturn any law. They are, however, required to apply the law correctly, including follow precedent set by any courts superior to them. Normally appeals courts only handle the question of whether the lower court applied the law correctly, and assume that the lower court interpreted the facts right. This is because normally (there are a few VERY rare exceptions) it is not legally permitted to appeal on the grounds that the court or the jury got the facts wrong... only on the grounds that the law was applied incorrectly.
- rayiner 14y agoMy only addition would be that things like what Weev's state of mind was when he did these things are matters of fact that will be assumed true on appeal. So in addition to "he didn't actually access the servers" you also can't argue "he didn't really intend to do this or that."
- macchina 14y agoI don't think it matters because Kerr is just arguing that the district court interpreted and applied the law incorrectly. An appeals court has full power in these areas. It would only be a problem if they wanted to introduce facts or procedural/evidentiary arguments not presented to the trial judge, or if they want to overturn the trial court's decision on procedural/evidentiary/factual matters.
- bradleyjg 14y agoSome arguments have to be made at every level or can be lost (i.e. 'preserved for appeal'). It looks like in this case the issues Kerr wants to appeal have not been lost. In any event the appellate stage is a more natural fit for an academic than the trial stage.
- DannyBee 14y agoNormally, you need to preserve arguments for appeal if they are related to evidence. It's unclear which, if any, arguments have not been preserved. However, at the same time in federal court, appeals courts generally have broad discretion to consider legal arguments not raised below, particularly if they are just about the law, not about some particular piece of evidence. All this said, Kerr is only consulting/helping out AFAIK. He is not the arguing attorney (I hope). He's not really a litigator (he has about 3 years of experience in it, most of it from very early days of his career). I am doubtful that his expertise would have really mattered at the trial stage. You can either convince a judge of something, or you can't.
- rdl 14y agoI wonder if Marcia Hofmann is doing this individually (and pro bono) or as EFF.
- macchina 14y agoThis is fantastic news. Hopefully this gets overturned and narrows the scope of the CFAA to where the government can't put people in prison for exposing security flaws on unrestricted areas of the web.
- Lazare 14y agoGood to hear. I have quite a lot of respect for Kerr; he's one of the foremost experts in this area (the intersection of the 4th ammendment with computers and networks), and I think Weev's case is a serious injustice. As an aside, I actually think it's clear that Weev's case is a vastly larger injustice than Aaron Swartz's case. Swartz clearly violated the law in an act of willing and knowing civil disobedience. The law restricts people from unauthorized access to a network; Swartz and the MIT network admins played a game of cat and mouse as they kept banning him, and he kept finding new ways of gaining access to the network. There's no way to argue Swartz didn't realize that he was gaining unauthorized access to a network. At one point he was hiding his face from security cameras; there's no way to spin that as "oh, he thought he was doing something perfectly allowable!" And once caught, he was offered a reasonable plea deal. In contrast, Weev...fairly clearly did not gain unauthorized access to a network. It was a publicly available website, and no one ever tried to stop him. His actions were at worse borderline, and yet he ended up with a sentence MUCH higher than Swartz. I have a lot of sympathy for Swartz (not least because of his tragic suicide), but at the end of the day he knowingly and wilfully violated the law in an act of civil disobedience, and was offered a plea deal of less than a year. Weev probably did not violate the law, and was sentenced to years in prison. Weev needs and deserves help. I had to cheer a bit when I saw Kerr was going to be helping him.
- sigzero 14y agoDidn't he use an unpublished link? That would be "unauthorized" to me.
- cheald 14y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Security_through_obscurity http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Security_through_obscurity
- rayiner 14y agoThe fact that a security mechanism is poor shouldn't mean that it doesn't create a legally enforceable boundary. If I tape my door shut instead of buying a proper lock, that doesn't give you the right to walk in.
- chetanahuja 14y agoWildly extrapolating from current trends : (Old, out of touch, heavy handed government officials, increasing complexity of technology landscape, anonymous, bitcoin, various governments creating secret "cyber-war" units, stuxnet etc..) we're heading to a breakdown and reconfiguration of the entire power balance between the "lawyer-types" who run the government now and the hacker types who are mostly relegated to the sidelines of the society for now. I remember seeing footage of a congressional sessions (just after SOPA was sidelined) where the phrase "let's call in the nerds" was used repeatedly. Then there's crap like this http://www.volokh.com/2013/03/13/i-dont-really-understand-why-you-want-to-be-protective-of-the-hackers/ http://www.volokh.com/2013/03/13/i-dont-really-understand-wh... This is not a sustainable power structure and it's going to change. Let's hope the transition is peaceful and gradual for everybody's sake.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- kyboren 14y agoYou think this is new? DoD delegated "Information Warfare" (what would now be called 'cyberwar') duties to NSA in 1997. In fact, the reconfiguration of the power structure is explicitly touched upon in NSA's own journal Cryptolog, in the Spring 1997 issue (Vol. XXIII, No. 1) -- http://cryptome.org/2013/03/cryptologs/cryptolog_136.pdf http://cryptome.org/2013/03/cryptologs/cryptolog_136.pdf.
- danso 14y agoMr. Kerr is a standup guy. Not everyone agreed with his measured defense of prosecutorial conduct in Aaron Swartz's case (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5053754 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5053754) but he has always been firm in opposing the misuse of the CFAA on principled and constitutional grounds. That he's defending someone that even the Reddit crowd despised (for personal reasons) is a confirmation of Kerr's respect for principles.
- fnordfnordfnord 14y ago>...even the Reddit crowd despised That's a terrible standard. There are some pretty awful things said by Redditors, especially in Weev's recent thread. I think Kerr's defense of Weev is less for Weev's personal sake than it is for the sake of Kerr's vocation. Either way I'm glad he is stepping up.
- _delirium 14y agoYes, that's what makes me quite trusting of his claimed motivation. Weev is one of the less sympathetic defendants you can find in this case in general, and is not aligned with Kerr's own politics or personality either (Kerr is generally a moderately conservative guy, in favor of law-and-order but with strong safeguards for liberty). That leads me to suspect that Kerr is especially worried about the precedents here, much more than he's worried about Weev's own fate.
- danso 14y agoI guess what I mean is that as a purported figure of Internet freedom and federal overreach, weev is not a great poster boy. Usually, when you're in the position of picking battles to fight, as Kerr is, you want everything in your favor, and hell, why not a defendant that you have no problem being associated with. Kerr's insistence on turning back a flawed law apparently outweighs whatever distaste he might have for weev on a personal or political level. So, good on Mr. Kerr.
- javert 14y agoI hadn't been following this case, but this was interesting. Why has the federal government turned into such a bully? This feels like a threat to all honest citizens.
- mikesena 14y agoThis is ridiculous. I'm all for the representation, but I'm against the trolling nature of HN and alike. Look at the comments posted the other day. You hated this kid. And still hate him. Only because he claimed to be bigger than he thought he was, which is true. But, an injustice was still done. Yes, the guy is a tool. A big tool. And he's lucky to have this opportunity. But grow some balls HN. Either flame him again, or apologise, because now saying "Yes he was mistreated" is just flawed.
- georgemcbay 14y agoI never commented on previous weev stories but I think it is completely rational to believe both that he's a giant asshole and also that he was mistreated by receiving a huge prison term for something that I can barely see as a crime, let alone a serious one. Where's the flaw in thinking both of these things?
- jhales 14y agoI was at the sentencing and the prosecution argued that spoofing the user-agent constituted fraud... https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/user-agent-switcher/ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/user-agent-sw... My friend also informed me: " HTTP has an error code, 401, for unauthorized access. AT&T responded with code 200 meaning OK." The more one finds out about this case the more incredible it is.
- lessnonymous 14y agoThis, to me, is the totality of the case: AT&T said accessing that data was OK. If it wasn't they should have returned a 401 or challenged for further authentication. Incrementing a phone number by one doesn't make it illegal to call it. If the person at the end then says "who are you" and you lie, then that's fraud. But if they just tell you something, there's no way anyone can claim that you obtained that information unlawfully.
- nookiemonster 14y agoIncrement is the wrong word. They implemented the Luhn algorithm, which is not the same as i++
- antiterra 14y agoIncrement in the general sense just means to increase the amount. A more specific meaning is to increase using regular steps, that is, to select the next number in a sequence. The use of the word is not confined to i++ or i=i+1 or ++i. Luhn is just a check digit, so you could define an increment function that adds one to the base number and then calculates the last digit. Or, you could just iterate over every possible check digit from 0-9.
- AnthonyMouse 14y agoHere's the problem with all of this: If you send a sufficiently vulnerable server a specially crafted request, you can get it to come back with "200 OK" and a list of everybody's credit card numbers. Conversely, if you're an employee of Foo, Inc. and you sign in to a secure server with your personal account and try to do something privileged, it's going to come back with "401 Unauthorized" and not give you anything even though you are actually authorized, and if you then sign in with your employee account it will allow you to do that thing. As a general rule what the machine says has a very strong relationship with whether or not you're authorized to do something. The issue is that if you're not authorized then a properly functioning machine just won't let you do it, which means that it seems impossible for anyone to violate this law against a server that is working properly. The only way anyone can be capable of breaking this law is if the server is not working properly and allows them to gain access without authorization. Which is why "unauthorized access" is such a vague and hopeless disaster. Going by the normal mechanism for determining whether you have authorized access, namely whether the server allows you to do something, would mean that no one could ever commit the crime, because either you never actually gain unauthorized access since you're prevented by a server with sufficient security, or you succeed in convincing the server to let you do something which under normal circumstances implies that you're authorized. Seemingly the only way anyone would ever be convicted is based on a pile of circumstantial nonsense about how the defendant should have known they weren't authorized to do something that the server allowed them to do, even though normally you are authorized to do anything the server allows you to do. So it becomes a de facto law against "doing bad things with a computer" -- not a specific prohibition against anything in particular, just something you stick to anybody who you don't like, because hey, if you did something "bad" then it wouldn't be authorized, right?
- calhoun137 14y agoMany people can't imagine how what weev did is a crime according to the law, and comments in HN threads about legal issues seem to be based on the assumption that the legal system is a consistent set of rules, sort of like the axioms of mathematics, in which a certain question or problem is posed and by a correct application of the rules of the legal system it is possible to come to a definite conclusion about what the law says. However, there is an amazing paper which shows that in virtually every case, a "correct" application of law actually leads to different conclusions which contradict each other. This excellent paper is by Karl N. Llewellyn and is called "Remarks on the Theory of Appellate Decisions and the Ruled or Canons about how Statutes are to be Construed"[1] I once read almost the whole thing, and the following quote from the first page sums up his main point pretty nicely. "The major defect in [the legal system] is a mistaken idea which many lawyers have about it—to wit, the idea that the cases themselves in and of themselves, plus the correct rules on how to handle cases, provide one single correct answer to a disputed issue of law. In fact the available correct answers are two, three, or ten. The question is: Which of the available correct answers will the court select—and why? For, since there is always more than one available correct answer, the court always has to select." IIRC, he discusses the role of precedent as an important aspect of deciding how to apply the law, but also the ability of a judge to decide to overturn a precedent for a wide variety of reasons. He also discusses the role played by the intention of law makers when passing law, which is ultimately a subjective judgment made by a person, and which is not spelled out in the actual written law itself. The paper is considered something of a classic, and I would encourage everyone to take a look at it. [1] http://mtweb.mtsu.edu/cewillis/Hermeneutics/Llewellyn%20on%20Canons%20of%20Interpretation.pdf http://mtweb.mtsu.edu/cewillis/Hermeneutics/Llewellyn%20on%2...
- smsm42 14y ago>>>> Importantly, however, only e-mail addresses were obtained. No names or passwords were obtained, and no accounts were actually accessed. Why is it important? If, as Orin Kerr claims, emails were public information, so were names and passwords, if stored under the same scheme. So if he accessed names and passwords, it would be also authorized access by the same logic. But it seems to me somehow Orin Kerr feels the weakness in this argument. Since he doesn't really expects people to believe that if you find a hole in a site that allows downloading account passwords via exploiting some vulnerability in HTTP server sending it some specially crafted data - he feels that it is necessary to emphasize that passwords weren't accessed. But many people consider their personal email no less private than their password - so if it wasn't OK to take the password (and by emphasizing that no passwords were taken Orin Kerr seems to implicitly admit it would be important if the passwords were taken) then it also wasn't OK to take the emails. On the question of felony though he may have a point. Felony is a grave crime that renders the criminal second-class citizen long after the prison term has been served. I think for non-violent crime that did not result in actual grave harm it is too much, and while I remain unsympathetic to Auernheimer's person, I think if Orin Kerr succeeds in somehow reducing it to lesser grade (or cause a change in the law that leads to that) it would be great.
- smsm42 14y agoInterestingly enough, whoever downvoted it didn't bother to counter-argument. Because yeah, why bother?
- jessaustin 14y agoI upvoted your top comment but I'm definitely downvoting this whinging about downvoting. That shit has to stop, or HN will become truly unreadable.
- smsm42 14y agoI'm not whining about downvoting, I'm whining about people not willing to participate in proper discussion but still voting. What's the point in the whole system then?
- nookiemonster 14y agoHey, here's a cool story about Weev: He's totally the kind of guy society should tolerate. http://bedizen.livejournal.com/258763.html http://bedizen.livejournal.com/258763.html
- flyinRyan 14y agoGo back to 4chan or reddit please. The law isn't your personal playground to arrest people you don't like. Accessing a public URL isn't a crime. Nor is being an asshole (of which you should be very glad!).
- josephlord 14y agoSo the authorities should charge him with harrassment, privacy invasion, extortion, copyright infringement (of the photo(s)) whatever is applicable for the things that are described in that article (or anything else) that he has done. Do not sentence him to 41months for the fact that AT&T breached its customers privacy and Weev let the press know or for accessing unprotected URLs.