3 ms·
Here's something that's been bugging me, perhaps you may have an answer: How the hell do we measure a police department's effectiveness? If we reward increasi
by angersock 14y ago
Here's something that's been bugging me, perhaps you may have an answer:
How the hell do we measure a police department's effectiveness?
If we reward increasing arrest rates (because presumably we're arresting more and more of the criminals) the straightforward solution is to arrest more people, and that would seem to lead to more and more draconian law enforcement to reach quota.
If we reward declining arrest rates (because presumably there are fewer and fewer crimes being committed), then the straightforward solution is to stop making arrests and thus allow real crime to proliferate.
This just seems like a no-win solution for honest departments and civil rights.
- ChuckMcM 14y ago"How the hell do we measure a police department's effectiveness?" A good question, I would not base it on arrests though, that is like measuring developers by bug reports. Start with the purpose of a police department, law enforcement and in carrying out that duty a mitigation of unlawful activity. So in terms of achieving their goals one would start with comparing unlawful activity in their jurisdiction vs a similar jurisdiction with a different agency. Compare per capita costs (hence the tax burden) and compare customer satisfaction (the citizens). In a squishy way, do the citizens feel safe? Do they engage in activities that would not be possible if they felt danger? And How much do we spend compared to other cities with similar economic demographics ? So we reward arrests that accurately convict the perpetrator responsible in as short as time as possible. Always finding your crook, but taking on average 14 - 18 months to do so, not good. Solving 90% of your caseload in under a week is good; Having more than a 1% false positive rate is bad. Citizens trusting/partnering with the police is good, people who can't trust their police is bad. That's one of the reasons I have pushed for the 'civil treason' sort of crime for violating the public trust. In order to trust the integrity of a police officer, I need to know that the risk they would face of violating that integrity is so high they don't do it. Life in prison for a police officer that commits perjury for example. Not regular citizens, but someone entrusted with enforcing the law. Similarly for judges that take bribes. In order for democracy to work you need a justice system that is harder on itself than it is on criminals. I would be more comfortable with the surveillance request if I knew that if the officers were lying about the need for it they could be sentenced to life in prison. That makes them less likely to lie. "This just seems like a no-win solution for honest departments and civil rights." My thesis is that the root of the problem is that its a "no lose" solution. There isn't any penalty for being a bad cop, you might get a reprimand for misstating that surveillance was the law but that's it. If the penalty, the 'lose' part, was there, then the conversation changes.
- jnw2 14y agoLife in prison for a police officer who commits perjury might carry a risk of convincing the honest potential police officers who don't quite trust the system to not become police officers, while not deterring those who have no long term fear of consequences.
- Already__Taken 14y agoThat's an interesting point. Such a law would require reviewing past cases for some 10+ years to clean the system out.
- No1 14y ago"How the hell do we measure a police department's effectiveness?" The number of crimes committed in an area is often used. If the number goes down, the police are doing a good job of discouraging crime. This results in in things like absurdly dysfunctional web forms for reporting crimes. People just give up on reporting their car being broken into rather than waste an hour figuring out why their report keeps getting rejected. Thus there is less reported crime, and the police pat themselves on the back.
- Zigurd 14y agoRe " How the hell do we measure a police department's effectiveness?" I don't think it's that hard. There are a set of crimes, like burglary, mugging, and armed robbery that are at the core of the quality of life in a city. Clearance rates for those crimes, plus a survey that measures reporting rates, should give a pretty good measure of a police force. Arrest rates, unless they are in these categories, tell us very little.