2 ms·
I do not want to bring up the (easy, simple) example of crypto software--too much wiggle room. I do not want to bring up the example of simple dual-use tools (k
by angersock 14y ago
I do not want to bring up the (easy, simple) example of crypto software--too much wiggle room. I do not want to bring up the example of simple dual-use tools (knifemakers and so on). I do not wish to bring up the fast-food industry, nor the energy industry, nor any other industry directly responsible for putting tools of discomfort and self-destruction in the hands of people who may use them for that purpose instead of for good.
Let's use an example which is not so forgiving and ambiguous:
Handgun manufacturers know that their weapons are designed specifically to kill or wound human beings. Do we punish or fine them for their weapons use in a criminal act? If so, why?
Do we really want to establish a legal and, worse, moral norm that any illegal act will require the prosecution of every "enabler" of that act?
Do you want to wish this on society?
- tempestn 14y agoIF a handgun maker (or distributor) sells a gun to someone who they know or have strong reason to suspect will use that gun to commit a crime, then YES, they should be held accountable. Ditto for all those other examples. Otherwise, they're fine. If they have no idea what a person will do with the gun, that's ok. In this case, according to the jury (likely influenced by a prosecution that was superior in quality to the defense, yes), Anaya DID have reason to believe that his product would be used in an illegal act, and therefore he should not have provided it. And indeed, the jury got it right there, because he himself admits that he believed, or at least strongly suspected, that the F150 trap was used for illegal activity. Again, I'm not saying that the punishment was in any way reasonable; just that the maker of any sort of tool should indeed be held accountable if they provide that tool specifically for illegal use.
- angersock 14y agoSurely, surely, there should be a bigger difference between innocence and guilt than a disclaimer "Now, you boys don't go using this for anything illegal now, you hear?". Even specific illegal use does a bad job as a metric, considering how arbitrary and unjust many laws considering technology are. What are you going to use a high-density disk for, if not storing downloaded media? Why would ordinary people want CD-Rs, if not for copyright infringement? If the tool is provided in the conspiratorial sense--"You're having trouble with that bank vault, try this drill!"--I would probably agree with you. But something like this feels very different somehow.
- tempestn 14y agoI think there are a few different issues here. First off, I agree with you that to be charged with conspiracy as Anaya was - in other words, to be equally responsible as if he had committed the crime himself, a more specific awareness should be required. However, I do believe that it should not simply be OK to provide a tool to someone in full knowledge that they will use it to commit a crime. Perhaps more granularity needs to exist in the law for these cases. (Or maybe it even does exist, but was not well applied in this case, possibly due to a poor defense. IANAL.) Finally, there is the issue of arbitrary and unjust laws concerning technology. I do not disagree with you there at all, but it is a separate issue. It doesn't make sense to say, "It's OK to help people break laws, but only the unjust ones." Instead, the unjust laws themselves should be challenged. Obviously I don't like to see anyone go to jail due to an unjust law, but that doesn't mean that other laws should be distorted to work around it.