3 ms·
Wow, way to spectacularly miss the point! 1) No intelligent person is suggesting that a computer will directly map to a human brain. We're not trying to reprod
by swombat 18y ago
Wow, way to spectacularly miss the point!
1) No intelligent person is suggesting that a computer will directly map to a human brain. We're not trying to reproduce a brain in silicon. However, a sufficiently powerful computer might be able to model the workings of a brain - or even might not need to if we find another path to intelligence.
2) If anything, the complexity and existence of the human brain is an indication that such a system can be built efficiently. After all, the brain exists, therefore it should be possible to at least build something of comparable complexity and power, at some point in the future. Maybe it won't be as rapid as Moore's law predicts, but there's no reason to think that we won't eventually be able to reproduce what nature has been able to do through blind selection.
3) There's no reason why a singularity can only come via wholly artificial intelligence. Intelligence augmentation could easily achieve the same objective (and is perhaps even more likely - after all, it's happening today already, albeit on a smaller scale).
Did they even bother to read up on Singularity stuff before writing this article?
- rjprins 18y agoAgreed! The author obviously has not thought a lot about AI before and misses the idea of abstract models/functions as implemented by brains. And she is wrong on the "dark, hot underbelly of Moore's law", power consumption relative to computational power has most certainly gone down in an exponential fashion.
- robg 18y agoYour criticisms are fair, but: 1) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blue_Brain http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blue_Brain 2) How long do you think we'll need? "At some point in the future" is an awfully long time scale, especially relative to how long it took natural selection to create the human brain. 3) I don't think they'd deny that augmentation is already happening. But that piecemeal progress is still a long way from The Singularity.
- swombat 18y ago1) is exactly what I suggested - a virtual model of the brain. I don't see any "but" there... 2) I'm no AI expert, so my opinion of this is pretty irrelevant, but I would be extremely surprised if we didn't have some form of human-level intelligence within the next 100 years, and I would not be surprised if we had it in the next 20 years. 3) Piecemeal progress that feeds back on itself is the essence of the whole Singularity hypothesis. Better brains come up with even better ways to enhance themselves, which makes them even better, etc. Technological progress can grow exponentially in ways not subject to the Malthusian limits.