2 ms·
To what extent is that counter-productive, though? The OP lists 5 other submissions on the topic. At a certain point isn't it just simpler to contain it all in
by untog 14y ago
To what extent is that counter-productive, though? The OP lists 5 other submissions on the topic. At a certain point isn't it just simpler to contain it all in one thread? If you don't want to read it (and I certainly don't blame you) you can just skip that thread and move on.
- tptacek 14y agoBecause the threads are, in the parlance of our times, embarrassing shitshows. It was clear to me that they needed to be torched off the site as soon as we got to the comment about the hetero guy in the gay bar. That is what the flag button is for. To scorch the shit off the site. More people need to use it. These threads are horrible and they need to go.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- mtrimpe 14y ago@untog: Your last comment is marked as [dead]. I really hope it's not because you've been hellbanned.
- untog 14y agoI accidentally double-posted. Deleted one, but evidently the wrong one. Re-posted now, hopefully it shows up.
- untog 14y agoI both agree and disagree. The threads are utter shitshows (and yes, the hetero guy in a gay bar comment was the lowest point in a very low thread) but at the same time I think that flagging the content off the site means that a lot of people are never aware of the (excuse me if this sounds dramatic) true nature of many in Hacker News. I suppose I think of it as painting over the cracks in the community here. I'd prefer everyone sees the shitshow for what it is, and then maybe has a think about what HN is, or should be.
- tptacek 14y agoThis site would be better if we could get over the idea that all issues related to technology demand comprehensive litigation in comment threads. Sometimes issues that are relevant to us can't be resolved in comment threads. And then all those comment threads do is degrade the community.
- waterlesscloud 14y agoI'm planning to link to this at a later date. :-)
- tptacek 14y agoI flag the CISPA threads too. I can write a 500 word comment on a topic and still hope the thread ends up dead.
- manicdee 14y agoWhat if leaving the embarassing shit shows hanging around is necessary to show people the extent of the problem? In much the same way that sometimes in a parent's life they need to stop doing the laundry and let their teenager head out to town with smelly, mouldy, crusty garments until the teenager learns that dirty clothes are horrible and that perhaps it might be worth helping parents with housework without the need for bribes.