3 ms·
While I agree that the result in this case was extreme, it seems that the article does point out the distinction, which is whether the person behind the tech is
by tempestn 14y ago
While I agree that the result in this case was extreme, it seems that the article does point out the distinction, which is whether the person behind the tech is directly aware that it will be used for <bad thing>.
In this particular case, I could see how there's a strong argument that he was. I mean, when he saw the $800k, honestly, he _did_ know it was related to drugs. He made the choice to continue. Should he have been charged as a conspirator and ultimately sentenced to 24 years? Not in my opinion! But he wasn't completely blameless either.
- mercurial 14y agoI think it would be fair he gets some punishment, but 24 years without parole, while the main perpetrators get a sentence half the length? I guess that's what happens when you don't take a deal.
- betterunix 14y ago"While I agree that the result in this case was extreme, it seems that the article does point out the distinction, which is whether the person behind the tech is directly aware that it will be used for <bad thing>." Then anyone who implements a cryptosystem is in legal peril. There is no question that cryptosystems are used by criminals to commit crimes. So far, cryptographers have been able to sleep at night knowing that their work is also used to protect people from criminals and other dangers.
- Nrsolis 14y agoI dont think cryptographers have anything to be worried about here unless they are directly involved in designing a crypto-system for a person they know or could reasonably suspect would be involved in doing something illegal. This individuals biggest problem was that he had more than a casual association with people that he could have reasonably suspected were involved in something illegal. If he had stopped having anything to do with the people who had the 800k hidden, he'd be a free man now. If he had tipped off the cops that he saw a car with 800k hidden in a secret compartment, he'd very likely have won the accolades of the entire police department along with buying himself some very welcome immunity from prosecution. He chose sides and lost.
- john_b 14y agoAnd if the people who worked with the two guys who had the 800k hidden had found out he'd snitched, then what? The bottom line is that you shouldn't have to "choose sides" every time you see something suspicious. Most seemingly suspicious occurences are innocent, and calling the police on someone every time you see one is childish and naive.
- Nrsolis 14y agoHow about not dealing with sketchy people who need hidden compartments in their vehicles? Why is that not an option from the outset? I hate to say it, but I find the range of "legal" uses for a hidden compartment in a moving vehicle to be vanishingly small. I'd put them in the same range as legal reasons to wearing a full facemask/helmet in a bank.
- betterunix 14y agoI see this case as being no different from that attack on Phil Zimmerman in the 90s, except that Zimmerman is still a free man. Anaya did not "choose sides," he provided a legal service to willing customers without prying, no different from a cryptography expert who helps people deploy and use cryptosystems. This man was prosecuted to intimidate others like him -- other people who might make such modifications to cars. The goal was to ensure that such compartments do not become commonplace. Zimmerman was attacked in the 90s out of an effort to keep email encryption from becoming commonplace. If a technology makes law enforcement more difficult, the creator of that technology should expect to be prosecuted. Nobody "chose sides" in this case. Anaya is the victim of an vastly overpowered law enforcement system, one that has resulted in the United States having an order of magnitude more prisoners than any other country.
- wnight 14y agoWho's safe to design crypto for then? We've just seen the US, UK, and Canadian governments participate in the slaughter of innocent people and try to hide the evidence with cryptography. And we've seen the good guys use the same systems to hide from the governments while they leaked these facts.
- tempestn 14y agoOnly if the cryptographers provide their tools or services directly to people they believe to be using them for illegal purposes. If they simply provide them freely to everyone, it is no problem, since there are obviously perfectly legitimate uses for cryptography as well.
- ersii 14y agoExcuse me, how can you know that he knew it was from drugs? I would personally be a bit surprised at 800k US Dollars - but it's not completely unlikely that someone would have that kind of cash. Even if they're not dealing/trafficing drugs. I would also consider that A) Anaya is an master craftsman in his art, hence probably expensive (Even though he doesn't seem ridiculously expensive in the article) B) People with money do use master craftsmen, for what ever reasons they do - maybe it's the work of art - maybe it's because they don't care how much they spend or they want to look "appropriate"
- tempestn 14y agoThe question is whether a "reasonable person" would believe the money was related to illegal activity. While he may have not known so beyond any doubt, my opinion is that a reasonable person would believe so, based on the money and the actions of the truck's owners. And in fact, Anaya himself admitted that he had suspicious about its origin.
- angersock 14y agoI do not want to bring up the (easy, simple) example of crypto software--too much wiggle room. I do not want to bring up the example of simple dual-use tools (knifemakers and so on). I do not wish to bring up the fast-food industry, nor the energy industry, nor any other industry directly responsible for putting tools of discomfort and self-destruction in the hands of people who may use them for that purpose instead of for good. Let's use an example which is not so forgiving and ambiguous: Handgun manufacturers know that their weapons are designed specifically to kill or wound human beings. Do we punish or fine them for their weapons use in a criminal act? If so, why? Do we really want to establish a legal and, worse, moral norm that any illegal act will require the prosecution of every "enabler" of that act? Do you want to wish this on society?
- tempestn 14y agoIF a handgun maker (or distributor) sells a gun to someone who they know or have strong reason to suspect will use that gun to commit a crime, then YES, they should be held accountable. Ditto for all those other examples. Otherwise, they're fine. If they have no idea what a person will do with the gun, that's ok. In this case, according to the jury (likely influenced by a prosecution that was superior in quality to the defense, yes), Anaya DID have reason to believe that his product would be used in an illegal act, and therefore he should not have provided it. And indeed, the jury got it right there, because he himself admits that he believed, or at least strongly suspected, that the F150 trap was used for illegal activity. Again, I'm not saying that the punishment was in any way reasonable; just that the maker of any sort of tool should indeed be held accountable if they provide that tool specifically for illegal use.
- angersock 14y agoSurely, surely, there should be a bigger difference between innocence and guilt than a disclaimer "Now, you boys don't go using this for anything illegal now, you hear?". Even specific illegal use does a bad job as a metric, considering how arbitrary and unjust many laws considering technology are. What are you going to use a high-density disk for, if not storing downloaded media? Why would ordinary people want CD-Rs, if not for copyright infringement? If the tool is provided in the conspiratorial sense--"You're having trouble with that bank vault, try this drill!"--I would probably agree with you. But something like this feels very different somehow.