7 ms·
This is troubling, right? There's sort of three options about tech facilitating <bad thing>: you hold the people behind the tech responsible, you hold the peop
by angersock 14y ago
This is troubling, right?
There's sort of three options about tech facilitating <bad thing>: you hold the people behind the tech responsible, you hold the people behind the tech blameless, or you cherry-pick when they're at fault.
I'd argue that cherry-picking is what we currently do, and that it is troublesome in its inherent double-standards: if I show teenagers how to make pipebombs and they hurt someone, that's on me, but if I write tech manuals for special forces on the same subject, that's okay. If I write software that helps ensure messages are private, that's okay, but if the same software is used to carry child porn, that's awful. If I write software for recording customer information, that's okay, but if I provide it to the government, that's not okay.
Cherry-picking is rubbish in this way, because the same tech--particularly for tools and services!--can be used for both good and harm. It may be difficult to argue for peaceful uses of stealth fighters, but barring a few cases it would seem that all tech is dual-use. We can acknowledge this fact, and pick one extreme or the other.
If we take the view that all tech providers are culpable for the use of their tech, we stifle innovation and retard the pace of development--if the morass of patent claims is bad, consider what happens if every product has to go through a strict liability filter to make sure it can't hurt anyone. We don't even stop the bad uses of tech--we can still be saddened to find that someone has found an illegal use for our tools that simply had never occurred to us.
If we go the other way, and hold tech providers blameless, we don't slow innovation. We simplify the cases against people who do commit crimes, and streamline the justice process. We give up the ability to try and stop the spread of things like traps and weapons and whatnot, and can focus on actually going after the people that use them for ill, or deciding not to waste resources on things that become impractical to enforce.
None of this matters a hill of beans, though, because we seem to be hellbent on a justice system which doesn't even bother to make clear the inscrutable laws with which it will nail you to the wall. Brilliant.
- tempestn 14y agoWhile I agree that the result in this case was extreme, it seems that the article does point out the distinction, which is whether the person behind the tech is directly aware that it will be used for <bad thing>. In this particular case, I could see how there's a strong argument that he was. I mean, when he saw the $800k, honestly, he _did_ know it was related to drugs. He made the choice to continue. Should he have been charged as a conspirator and ultimately sentenced to 24 years? Not in my opinion! But he wasn't completely blameless either.
- mercurial 14y agoI think it would be fair he gets some punishment, but 24 years without parole, while the main perpetrators get a sentence half the length? I guess that's what happens when you don't take a deal.
- betterunix 14y ago"While I agree that the result in this case was extreme, it seems that the article does point out the distinction, which is whether the person behind the tech is directly aware that it will be used for <bad thing>." Then anyone who implements a cryptosystem is in legal peril. There is no question that cryptosystems are used by criminals to commit crimes. So far, cryptographers have been able to sleep at night knowing that their work is also used to protect people from criminals and other dangers.
- Nrsolis 14y agoI dont think cryptographers have anything to be worried about here unless they are directly involved in designing a crypto-system for a person they know or could reasonably suspect would be involved in doing something illegal. This individuals biggest problem was that he had more than a casual association with people that he could have reasonably suspected were involved in something illegal. If he had stopped having anything to do with the people who had the 800k hidden, he'd be a free man now. If he had tipped off the cops that he saw a car with 800k hidden in a secret compartment, he'd very likely have won the accolades of the entire police department along with buying himself some very welcome immunity from prosecution. He chose sides and lost.
- john_b 14y agoAnd if the people who worked with the two guys who had the 800k hidden had found out he'd snitched, then what? The bottom line is that you shouldn't have to "choose sides" every time you see something suspicious. Most seemingly suspicious occurences are innocent, and calling the police on someone every time you see one is childish and naive.