4 ms·
I don't want to take sides here, but I do take issue with the claim that the "forking" thing was fabricated, or was irrelevant, because the intent of the person
by eridius 14y ago
I don't want to take sides here, but I do take issue with the claim that the "forking" thing was fabricated, or was irrelevant, because the intent of the person who spoke it was not sexist or even meant as a joke. The fact is, the way language is interpreted by the listener is far more important than how it was meant by the speaker. And it should be pretty obvious that the phrase "I want to fork his repo" could be easily construed as being a crude sex joke.
- blhack 14y ago"Fork his repo" is a reference to git. There is nothing sexual about it. Here's a repo for my hackerspace's website. At the top right of the page is the word "fork". https://github.com/heatsynclabs/new-hsl https://github.com/heatsynclabs/new-hsl It's worth pointing out that Adria isn't a developer, and might not have realized that this wasn't a sex joke, he was talking about flattering somebody by forking their git repo.
- simonster 14y agoIt's also worth noting that GitHub used to show a page that says "Hardcore forking action" when you fork a repo, which seems far more objectionable than "I'd fork his repo" if you object to those sorts of things.
- callmecosmas 14y agoI mean I can see how that would be a sexual joke given a certain tone of voice.
- eridius 14y agoI know exactly what forking is. And the term "forking" has been used, intentionally, as sexual innuendo before. As simonster said, even GitHub used to say "hardcore forking action". So yes, "I want to fork his repo" is a phrase that can definitely be taken to be sexual in meaning, depending on context and tone of voice.
- eridius 14y agoThe fact that I was downvoted to oblivion on this comment speaks volumes about the mindset here on HN.
- fingerprinter 14y agoI was going to let your comment slide until I saw your followup 'downvote' comment below. > The fact is, the way language is interpreted by the listener is far more important than how it was meant by the speaker. This is absurd to the point that I call Poe's Law. Nearly ALL language can be "offensive" in some way shape or form. Someone saying they are "offended" literally means nothing. Intent matters. A lot. Now, couple intent with offense and you have something. To make up something completely on the spot, imagine it is an equation: offended = O, not offended = NO, intended offense = IO, no intended offense = NIO. NO + NIO = most civil dialogue. O + NIO = mistake. Someone should speak up and say something. O + IO = someone being a jerk, actively trying to hurt someone. NO + IO = someone trying to be a jerk, the other person realizing it and not letting them do it (among other options here). What happened here was O + NIO. No mature, rational person's first reaction in that situation is to go nuclear. A mature, rational person will A. ignore it and move on B. explain their offense C. note it, mull it over, look for future conversation to explain their side D. ignore it but use it as a teaching tool (in the abstract) if they have a platform (among other options, but those encompass most. How one chooses to react depends on many variables). Now, if someone takes the time to be mature and rational and actually explain their offense AND THEN the other side continues, well, then the equation has changed. What should have happened (best case) would be a civil dialogue explaining the offense. What should have happened (bare minimum) was anonymous reporting to pycon. What should not have happened was what happened. So, to sum it up, someone's interpretation is only one side of the equation. To say it is "far more important" is, frankly, absurd.
- eridius 14y agoThank you for replying. As I said, I didn't want to take sides. My comment was purely addressing the idea that, because the speaker did not intend the comment to be sexual in nature, that means it was a "fabrication". I do agree with you that the appropriate course of action was to speak to the two men and ask them to cut out the comments. That said, I disagree with your absolutist position. Yes, anything you say could potentially be considered offensive by someone, but that's not the point. The point is whether it could reasonably be considered offensive by a reasonable person. And yes, I'd have to say that saying "I want to fork his repo", followed up by "large dongle" phallus jokes, is a reasonable candidate to be considered offensive by someone.