3 ms·
> Online retailers can only use "authorised images" to advertise GoPro products? That is more than a little sketchy. They cannot use their own original photogra
by laumars 14y ago
> Online retailers can only use "authorised images" to advertise GoPro products? That is more than a little sketchy. They cannot use their own original photographs that they have taken and own the copyright to?
I maybe mistaken here, but I'm fairly sure reporting / reviews are classed as 'fair use'.
If this was ever to go to court, then I'm certain the judge would just throw the case out. However GoPro would never push it that far, their aim is just to take the review offline for the immediate 2 weeks in the hope that when it goes back online, most people would have moved on. Ironically though, GoPro have attracted significantly more attention to the article by trying to bury the review.
I say "ironically", but "deservedly" equally works. I hope this serves as a warning to other companies wishing to abuse DMCA take downs (though I doubt it will).
- rayiner 14y agoDiscussing this is hard because it's not even clear what the legal theory is behind the notice. You cannot claim copyright over someone else's picture of your product. As for trademark--you can only sue for trademark infringement if your mark is used as a mark in commerce. A trademark holder doesn't own the mark itself, just the right to use the mark to label its products. The only thing I can think of that would even be plausible is if the review site used official images of the product in its review without authorization. But the notice doesn't even begin to hint at that theory.
- ajross 14y agoI think the first bit isn't strictly true. You can claim copyright over images of your product to the extent that the product image is copyrightable. You can't publish photographic prints of copyrighted artwork, for example. And I think there's case law about photographs of publicly-visible architecture as well, but someone will have to confirm that. I'd tend to agree that this doesn't extend to straightforward images used to identify the product in a consumer review, but I'm not so sure it's as cut an dry a case as you think.
- rayiner 14y ago> I think the first bit isn't strictly true. You can claim copyright over images of your product to the extent that the product image is copyrightable. You can't publish photographic prints of copyrighted artwork, for example. And I think there's case law about photographs of publicly-visible architecture as well, but someone will have to confirm that. Right, if the photograph amounts to a reproduction of something that is itself copyrightable then it is copying and could be infringement. But a camera isn't copyrightable.
- mistercow 14y agoAlso, you can't file a DMCA notification for trademark infringement. DMCA is for copyright. If you list trademarks as "infringing material", you're not sending a valid notification under the law.
- rdl 14y agoIs there any potential punishment for GoPro for sending a baseless demand like that, other than crucifixion in the court of public opinion?
- rayiner 14y agoYou could sue them for damages/costs for knowingly sending a false DMCA take-down notice. "Knowingly" is unfortunately a high bar--they could plead "stupidity."
- sliverstorm 14y agoIronically though, GoPro have attracted significantly more attention to the article by trying to bury the review. Elsewhere in this comment page, someone notes that the review is actually strongly favors the GoPro. Maybe this is some kind of incredibly perverse strategy...?
- emiliobumachar 14y agoIf it's that, it's flawed. A lot of people will read just the title, not even click through, and assume GoPro has an inferior product and needs those tactics to hide it. On the other hand, their brand recognition may go up...
- travem 14y agoIf you look at the takedown notice there is an ellipsis by the list of URLs. There may have been several pages "infringing" according to GoPro but by excluding those and only sharing the review URL is more likely to go "viral"