9 ms·
I looked at Persona for a project a friend of mine is doing, and I pretty much rejected from the start. Persona seems flawed in that it assumes email as identit
by mrweasel 14y ago
I looked at Persona for a project a friend of mine is doing, and I pretty much rejected from the start. Persona seems flawed in that it assumes email as identity.
I'm a developer on a e-commerce site, when we started out we assumed what Persona assumes, that email is a unique and stable identity. We found out the first day of production mode that this assumption is flawed. People changes email address all the time, it's at least as unstable as their home address, most peoples phone number is more stable.
As software developers we assumed that pretty much no one would ever change their email address, or that at least they wouldn't discard their old one. Regular people however do that. They do not care about their email address.
Is this something that the Persona team that given any thought. If so, what did you come up with?
- pyvek 14y agoPersona's about page says that you can use multiple email addresses with a single account. "Within Persona, your identity is your email address. You can use as many email addresses as you want, but you still only need one password.". - https://login.persona.org/about https://login.persona.org/about
- mrweasel 14y agoIt's not really clear if it maps to the same identity. I should test that. However I think it might still confuse customers. A normal user expect to be able to change their email address on the site where they do business and the "MAGIC". I think we would have been better of requiring a username, email and password, rather than using the email as the username. For a large number of people needing to have both username and email seems redundant and stupid, for real life customer... not so much. My issue is, a customer has X number of orders on our site. Then he/she changes email and expect that using the new email address the old orders are magically available. This seems naive but that is what you have to deal with. Again I should check to see if Persona indeed maps multiple emails to the same identity. It didn't seem like it when I tested it last, but I would not rule out that I did something wrong.
- StavrosK 14y agoIt maps multiple emails to the same identity, in that you use the same password to log in with all of them. The end site gets the email you log in to the site with (I can log in to Persona with email A but let all sites know email B every time. If I change that to email C, sites will think I'm a different user). You can let users change email addresses, and nothing bad will happen. They'll just have to log in with the other address next time.
- ams6110 14y agoOn the one hand, I think email addresses are FAR more understandable as "identity" to an average user than URLs are, which to me is the fatal flaw with OpenID. To an "ordinary" user, URLs are websites, not people. On the other hand people do change identifiers. They change usernames (jsmith gets married and now wants to be jadams) and they change emails (for the same reason, or because they change ISPs or mobile carriers or whatever). ANY authentication process you use should allow the user to change his identifier (or any other personal attribute even gender) at will. Internally you deal with this by connecting the identifier to an other token that is the real "permanent" identity for the user in your system. But it's one that's never exposed to the actual user. It sounds like your system was using the email address in the order records to identify the customer. That is what your real problem is, not that people change email addresses.
- Benferhat 14y ago> But it's one that's never exposed to the actual user. Why not expose it to the user? Because then they'll want to change it? Are you talking about browser fingerprinting? We already expose this on the user/email level, where users can link and log in with as many email addresses as they like, under one account (identifier).
- garethadams 14y agoYou tell your users what their primary key is in your database?
- Noxchi 14y agoEmail address is the backbone of web identity. Nearly every registration system uses it. If you're having trouble with it, maybe, just maybe, it's on your end?
- mrweasel 14y agoIf you honestly believe that, I would claim that you either have no customers or that your customer reside in a very limited sub-section of people. People do not believe that their email and identity is in any way linked. You and I might believe that, but don't count on your customers sharing your beliefs.
- opminion 14y agoPeople do not believe that their email and identity is in any way linked I think that you might have to explain that a bit. I think that others try to argue that people use email at least as temporary identity, in the sense that at time t, they identify themselves with at least one of their email addresses. In practice this is enough for many web sites to use the email address as login. Perhaps you are talking about some longer sort of permanence, or uniqueness?
- pjscott 14y agoSay what? My email addresses are linked to my identity because they are my email addresses. Most of them even have my name on them. Sure, I have several of them, and one of them disappeared when I graduated from college, so the mapping isn't perfect -- but they are nevertheless mine. The main exceptions to this are: 1. People who share an email address for convenience, like my grandparents. 2. Group-facade email addresses, like support@whatever.com, which may be routed to several people. 3. Email addresses that don't belong to anyone, like "noreply@whatever.com", or "autogenerated-4b243efa37e5b013a1d90b694c3bcaa3@hell.com"
- aneth4 14y agoI haven't found this to be true, and I've dealt with a lot of customers. Even Facebook uses email for login, as does google and just about every other website I use. It's an interesting and bold statement that needs some supporting eveidence and explanation.
- masivemunkey 14y agoI think you may have a unique case on your hands. I am a web developer for a big eCommerce site and we use emails to identify users (we switched from usernames to emails after a few months of testing actually). After three years of the site being up we have only had a handful of people get confused about their email changing. If a user does change their email they can log in as their old email and simply update their account to their new one. Email is a much better system than username because people constantly forget the unique username they created for that specific site. You don't really forget your email very often.
- th5 14y ago+1 to your decision. I HATE site that use usernames instead of emails... i wont even use sites that do that unless i really really have to (like my health care provider).
- imissmyjuno 14y agoThere is typically nothing stopping you from using your email as a username, though. I like the freedom of using either, to be honest.
- kerneis 14y agoExcept for the many, many websites that have stupid restrictions like: "sorry, your username should be lower-case letters only".
- beaumartinez 14y agoIt's not necessarily stupid—it could be so that your username can be included in URLs (like Twitter). "Lower-case only" is stupid though.
- martinced 14y agoThe problem is not displaying a username. The problem is using the username to login. Because users forget that. If you're stupidly using your email as your username then your email becomes public should the site you're on show, at any point, your username. Which is why sites correctly done use the email for login but display a username and never your email. Correctly done sites also forbid username from containing '@', so that you can be sure that people don't do anything retardedly stupid like using their email as username, which would be displayed publicly on the site...
- sudhirj 14y agoThat actually sounds pretty hard to believe - Amazon uses your email id as your username for one, as does iCloud. Both services have hundreds of millions of users.
- saurik 14y agoFirst, Amazon actually allows multiple separate accounts to have the same e-mail address, and will use the password to decide which one you are trying to log in to. Second, using your e-mail address as a potential username (sometimes, one of many possible, as is the case with Facebook or Google, which will let you use any of the e-mail addresses associated with your account or your username to log in) is very different from treating it as your identity, and you can tell the difference when you ask the question "what happens if I lose access to that address, change to a new one, and someone else is assigned the one I was using previously?", which happens to many people using e-mail addresses provided by third parties (such as companies, ISPs, or universities).