5 ms·
Ask HN: Naming our startup: does it matter?
I met my co-founder a month ago.
He had the vision of creating a better P2P marketplace and has gotten some starting traction (around 500-1000 signups).
I've jumped on-board because I believe in the vision, but the name has always left a sour taste in my mouth.
I've asked for people's opinions on the name, and also asked on /r/startups (http://www.reddit.com/r/startups/comments/1afhlm/ask_rstartups_whats_your_opinion_on_the_name/). I've always received either neutral or negative feedback.
Am I being too obsessive about the name of this start-up? Or is it something that is worth changing while we're early in the game?
- mindcrime 14y agoI think it matters, and I don't like Stuffak very much. Like somebody else said, it sounds like something you take when you have chest congestion or a sinus infection or something. I would warn against being too attached to names that you come up with. We all have a tendency to fall in love with our own ideas, and sometimes we need a 3rd party to tell us "that's crap". To illustrate, let me share an anecdote from my own adventure: We have 3 "real" projects that make up our product suite at the moment, and a fourth project that might or might not continue to exist as a standalone project. All are Open Source and the projects are all named after light-houses. All along we figured we'd eventually have a different name for the "branded" release, vs. the OSS project name... kinda like the way Fedora -> RHEL. Anyway... we had the idea of an "umbrella project" to refer to the entire suite. Since all our branding is based on light, illumination, light-houses, etc. Company: Fogbeam Labs Product 1: Quoddy (named after the West Quoddy Head Lighthouse in Maine) Product 2: Heceta (named after the Heceta Head Lighthouse in Oregon) Product 3: Neddick (named after the Cape Neddick "Nubble" Lighthouse in Maine) Product 4: Hatteras (named after the Cape Hatteras Lighthouse in North Carolina) So, when trying to come up with a name for the "umbrella" project, I had this bright (pun intended) idea to name it "ScrewPile" since screwpile[1] is a technical term related to lighthouses. Brilliant, right? Except... like 3 people in the entire world actually know what "screwpile" means and would "get" the connection, and - even worse - if you don't know what it means, it just looks... ugly. Almost vulgar, to be honest. It took the VP of Sales from a former employer of mine calling me out on it, in no uncertain terms, to convince me to change it. But once he really pulled the wool from over my eyes (wool I put there) it was dead obvious to me what as stupid name it was. So, we renamed it Fogcutter and so far everybody is a lot happier with that. :-) What's astonishing though, is the degree of rationalization and self-delusion I experienced before finally changing the name. Hell, I knew it was a bad name in many ways, but I was convinced "it isn't that bad" and "at least it's consistent with the other branding", blah, blah, blah. None of which mattered in the least when we have a product name that sounds like it should be the name of a porn flick or maybe a personal lubricant. :-) Stuffak might not be as bad, but my honest opinion is that you should change it. [1]: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Screw-pile_lighthouse http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Screw-pile_lighthouse
- biocho 14y agoFantastic response, thanks for your insight!
- jamesbritt 14y agoRandom thoughts: - If, when you say it, you find yourself having to spell it for people, it's a bad sign. - A name that succinctly describes a service is great for that service, but can make it hard to pivot. Conversely, a nonsense name gives you more latitude (and likely unique Google-mojo) but now you have to teach people what it means, - If a name isn't obviously interfering with what you're doing then it's probably not that big a deal while you're validating an idea, but of course if things don't take off you're going to wonder how it might have been different if you had a catchy clever name :)
- mindcrime 14y agoThe advice I've always heard is that names should have four primary attributes: 1. easy to pronounce 2. easy to spell 3. easy to remember 4. memorable To that list, I'd add: 5. Don't have obvious negative connotations (eg, sounding like a sexual perversion or a cough medicine)
- timmm 14y agoCriteria you should concern yourself with. 1. Brevity 2. That is relates to the service or product 3. Phetically accurate easy to transcribe from sound
- stevekemp 14y agoI started a service, once upon a time, and to keep a clear separation I figured I'd register a company, get a company bank account, etc. In my case the actual product was a website, and that had a name which was good. The actual company itself was less important - the only time folk would see it would be on cheques, or invoices. on that basis I figured I'd take the first name that sprang to mind, and I became "Pink Pony Productions"; a name shamelessly stolen from a throwaway line from Lisa Simpson - Episode "The Ziff Who Came to Dinner". So: Product name / Website name / Service name == Important, but company name / startup name .. less so.
- gregcohn 14y agoCritical. Change it, it's terrible. Ref: http://blog.launch.co/blog/how-to-name-your-startup-and-land-the-perfect-domain.html http://blog.launch.co/blog/how-to-name-your-startup-and-land...
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]