4 ms·
Just to clarify - my assertion is that CAM doesn't work because if it works, and we have evidence to show that it works, it's not CAM it's part of the body of e
by Nursie 14y ago
Just to clarify - my assertion is that CAM doesn't work because if it works, and we have evidence to show that it works, it's not CAM it's part of the body of evidence-based medicine.
If we don't have scientific evidence that something works then pretty much by definition we can't say it works because we don't have the proof. It's sort-of tautological.
The other comment "I don't understand how it works because it doesn't" was specifically in reference to Homeopathy, which has been shown over and over again to be no better than placebo (i.e. doesn't work). The example was to show that there's no point in investigating how something works, and it's silly to chastise people for not understanding how something works, unless we can first show that something works and that there is even something to investigate.
Apply this to paleo - I have no reason to suspect it works or not. Before investigating this miraculous diet, lets do a proper study to see if it actually is of benefit to the general population, or just to a subset, or if actually the benefits reported are by a tiny number of self-selected people and not really significant at all.
When we actually know (rather than suspect from anecdote) that it does something, then is the time to look at how.