6 ms·
So the world is filled with gold-diggers? No. Not true. You'll find it shocking that in some parts of the world people are happily married without any jewelry
by astrodust 14y ago
So the world is filled with gold-diggers? No. Not true.
You'll find it shocking that in some parts of the world people are happily married without any jewelry at all.
- Goronmon 14y agoI find it shocking that there are people that think that a woman wanting financial security makes that woman a 'gold-digger'.
- astrodust 14y agoThere is an enormous difference between wanting financial security and wanting someone to buy them a giant diamond ring as a token of it.
- maratd 14y agoNo, there isn't. If the girl is even slightly intelligent, she will want proof of that financial security and a diamond ring is adequate proof that she can verify on her own.
- Nursie 14y agoIf she's even slightly intelligent they will have discussed finances well ahead of the wedding, probably lived together for some time and know the situation very well. A shiny rock is not a proxy for communication.
- astrodust 14y agoIf the girl is even slightly intelligent she'll be able to make an assessment without needing a glittery ring. Maybe you think that flashing your wealth, not unlike a peacock fanning out their feathers, will get you a mate. It probably will, but it will probably be the kind of mate that is attracted to money.
- maratd 14y agoAll mates are attracted to money, some are simply more attracted than others. > If the girl is even slightly intelligent she'll be able to make an assessment without needing a glittery ring. Because she's clairvoyant? An expensive car can be rented or borrowed, a house can be inherited, bank statements easily faked. Men do these sorts of things. Frequently. But a ring she has been pining on and on about? A ring she can easily get appraised? No. You can't fake that. You will need to fork over the cash and when all of your money is going toward regular expenses and all of a sudden you have to fork over 10K in cold hard cash, that's a strain and a fine test of a man's ability to withstand financial shock. Wait til you have a baby. Now that's a real financial shock.
- transitionality 14y agoA diamond is just as easily faked as a bank statement.
- learc83 14y agoThe OP said, >A ring she can easily get appraised? right before he talked about how hard it is to fake. You can't fake a diamond that will fool an appraiser just as easily as a bank statement. It's much easier to covertly verify the value of diamond than the validity of a bank statement.
- transitionality 14y agoBoth can be faked equally easily, given equivalent verification mechanisms. Without the help of professional services, a layman can be easily fooled in either context. However, if the layman is going to get the diamond appraised by a professional, then the same standard should be applied to the other task. One can likewise use professional services to accurately determine a person's net worth. My point remains.
- learc83 14y ago
- opminion 14y agoThe implication, in this context, is that the man and the woman would have very unequal shares of financial responsibility (or expectations). That's why she would be perceived as a gold digger.
- kamaal 14y ago>>I find it shocking that there are people that think that a woman wanting financial security makes that woman a 'gold-digger'. Is it? And why exactly is it the man's responsibility to provide financial security for the woman? And I always thought women wanted equal rights. Its seems they only want a life long vacation at some body else's expense.
- desas 14y ago> And why exactly is it the man's responsibility to provide financial security for the woman? I'm sure for most women it's not that it is the man's responsibility to provide financial security, but that the man is going to work with you to be financially secure rather than against. If you've spent your twenties working hard and saving, you probably don't want to marry someone who's spent their twenties running up a credit card bill. You very likely will spend your life together arguing. Not that a diamond ring is necessarily the best way to demonstrate financial responsibility.
- learc83 14y ago>So the world is filled with gold-diggers? No. Not true. Wanting a mate who is financially secure doesn't make a woman a gold digger. It's no different than the vast majority of men who want a physically attractive mate. >You'll find it shocking that in some parts of the world people are happily married without any jewelry at all. Yes, different cultures have different standards (and there are outliers within cultures). In some places a herd of goats functions as a status symbol, in the US a diamond serves this function. That doesn't mean that every woman here absolutely requires a man who can buy her a diamond, but the majority do.
- astrodust 14y agoI think your viewpoint is skewed extremely strongly towards the peculiar tendencies expressed in Western society and America in particular. Not everyone has two SUVs, two kids in private schools, and a vacation home.
- roel_v 14y agoHe explicitly doesn't, his whole point was to say that the ways of expressing affluence differ between regions and culture.
- astrodust 14y agoThat point was made, then completely dismissed when stating that the "majority" of women demand a man that can provide a diamond.
- transitionality 14y agoThis is mostly thanks to De Beers expanding the scope of their advertising campaign internationally.
- learc83 14y agoI said this, >That doesn't mean that every woman here absolutely requires a man who can buy her a diamond, but the majority do. right after talking about the US--meaning I was discussing women here in the US, where it is demonstrably true that the majority of women demand diamonds.
- dylangs1030 14y agoSeeking financial security != gold digging. It's not sexist or derogatory. Financial security and status are evolutionary concepts that predate the diamond district. Diamonds are just one manifestation of a deeper, hardwired instinct to seek fit and capable mates. This isn't a cynical concept, it's backed by studies of the entire animal kingdom, not just humans.
- astrodust 14y agoThere are better ways to demonstrate your capability as a provider and evidence of financial security than buying diamond rings. For example, demonstrate you can care for a dog goes a long way. Owning and maintaining a house even further. A friend of mine got married. He could've bought his wife an extravagant engagement ring, but he put it to her in different terms, along the lines of: "Would you like an expensive ring, or what about something symbolic and we'll put the rest into a down-payment on a better house?" They didn't squander tens of thousands on a wedding, nor went on a lavish honeymoon. They started out with money in the bank and a hefty down-payment made on a new house, not credit-card debt.
- hackinthebochs 14y agoWhy do people insist on citing outliers as if that somehow negates the trend? It really derails and otherwise productive discussion. Yes, for every general rule there are always outliers. It's so obvious that it serves no useful purpose to state it explicitly.
- darkarmani 14y agoHe wasn't negating the trend. He was saying there are better ways to satisfy the evolutionary pressure than buying diamonds.
- astrodust 14y agoThe perception that an expensive diamond is required is flawed. I'm trying to illustrate that it's an institution that's crumbling. I really doubt that a significant percentage of those under ten will even bother with a diamond ring when at the age where they'll be getting engaged. By then they'll either be so saddled with student debt as to make the purchase impractical, or they'll be working two minimum wage jobs just to get by.