5 ms·
Honestly, I find the notion of "man as provider" to be perverse, but if I buy into your worldview for a moment... 1) Your wife can measure how much you can pro
by erikpukinskis 14y ago
Honestly, I find the notion of "man as provider" to be perverse, but if I buy into your worldview for a moment...
1) Your wife can measure how much you can provide just as well by having you actually provide valuable things. Like a house.
2) Your wife can measure your unselfishness by having you buy something that is actually valuable to her but useless to you. Like daycations with her friends. There's no sense in buying something which is valuable to neither party.
3) The need to demonstrate your social standing to other people is the result of low self-esteem. Maybe your wife needs therapy, not a diamond.
- mech4bg 14y agoA diamond ring is a signal that is _always_ showing, unlike something like a house. It's a signal to the world that displays someone's wealth, commitment, etc. This doesn't make it right, but there are numerous human psychology reasons why this tradition endures and so many people take part in it. Writing off people who want or provide a diamond ring as mentally ill (as many people in this thread seem to be doing) is silly.
- quadyeast 14y agoThat is why in Los Angeles there are many who drive very expensive cars but live in tiny apts.
- erikpukinskis 14y agoI didn't say they are mentally ill, I said they have low self esteem and therapy might help them.
- mech4bg 14y agoThat's the implication when you say they need therapy.
- jlgreco 14y agoAbsolute nonsense. Therapy is very useful to many people who are not mentally ill. I would venture to say that most people who see therapists are not mentally ill. If you think "mental illness" when somebody says "therapist", you probably need to do some reevaluation.
- mech4bg 14y agoOut of genuine interest (it's hard to convey tone via comments sometimes), can you expand on this comment a bit? What do you consider mental illness to be? And what is therapy in your view? The term 'mentally ill' in my view has been stigmatized quite a bit, and being 'unwell' mentally does not mean you are crazy, but that you have issues you feel you need to deal with. Isn't that the point of seeing a therapist? An interesting blog on this topic here: http://www.theage.com.au/executive-style/culture/blogs/all-men-are-liars/the-new-normal-20130227-2f5hf.html http://www.theage.com.au/executive-style/culture/blogs/all-m...
- jlgreco 14y agoReasons that you could see a thearapist, that would not traditionally be considered mental illness in casual conversation, can include: coping with occupational stress, coping with grief, preparing for anticipated grief, coming to terms with mortality, (often for children) learning what mortality is, coping with changes in lifestyle (including divorce, marriage, birth of a child, birth of a special needs child, inability to have a child, moves to unfamiliar locations, moves to unfamiliar cultures, loss of religion, loss of a job, release from prison, release from the service), (as mentioned by erikpukinskis) feelings of inadequacy or low self-esteem, ... Just about anything people may have talked to priests about in the past they can now talk to therapists about. Now, if you want to define mental illness such that it covers all of these things, and all the other reasons to see a therapist, that is fine. Words are just what you make of them; you can, of course, define them as you see fit. However, if you redefine mental illness in such a way then I can see really no justification for using the negative connotations that mental illness normally holds to facilitate mock outrage ("Writing off people who want or provide a diamond ring as mentally ill (as many people in this thread seem to be doing) is silly.") Instead of criticizing erikpukinskis for "writing off those people as mentally ill", perhaps you should instead explain why you do not agree with his suggestion that low self-esteem could be a factor.
- drivebyacct2 14y agoMan this thread is killing me. Apparently I need to start wearing my salary and Mint.com balance on a name-sticker on my shirt to attract more mates. And then when I get one, make them wear a sticker indicating that they are mine, because without that, surely they would just be scooped up by the next person looking to own another person.
- anonymous 14y agoWelcome to the "brutal truth" of applying economic theory and armchair psychology to human interaction. I sometimes hypothesise that the people peddling these notions do it because they really do see life as an economic system and consequently, no arguing with them would change their opinion, because they're obviously right. Meaning, I wonder if this is a simple case of "I expect others to experience things the same way I experience them". However, I can't imagine someone really thinking that way. But that's maybe because I don't. Enjoy your stay. Good luck and have fun!
- mattstreet 14y agoCommitment, really? How does it signal commitment? Are men that give big diamond rings less likely to cheat or get divorced?
- hollerith 14y agoIt signals they're willing and able to spend a lot on their future wives, which is part of what most people consider commitment.
- clobber 14y ago> Writing off people who want or provide a diamond ring as mentally ill (as many people in this thread seem to be doing) is silly No, wasting money on a valueless shiny rock is silly. But let's just keep advocating people 'keep up the tradition' instead.
- rayiner 14y ago> Honestly, I find the notion of "man as provider" to be perverse, but if I buy into your worldview for a moment... Why? It is, to this day, even in the U.S., the dominant arrangement between men and women, especially in the context of relationships that result in children. > The need to demonstrate your social standing to other people is the result of low self-esteem. That are very pragmatic reasons to invest in signals of social standing. It minimizes the cultural friction between yourself and the people who can help you get ahead, who are overwhelmingly people of high social standing themselves.
- erikpukinskis 14y ago>Why? Because I advocate relationships where contributions are granulated and distributed according to participant interest, not participant gender. Monolithic roles like "provider" (and the concomitant role of "consumer/sex object") of are inherently coercive. Because they're monolithic and tied to gender. I think that kind of coercion is perverse. > That are very pragmatic reasons to invest in signals of social standing I don't think those signals are meaningfully connected to anything real, they're just signals of standing. They are power begetting power, and I think willfully engaging that system is perverse.
- rayiner 14y ago> Because I advocate relationships where contributions are granulated and distributed according to participant interest, not participant gender. Okay how do you distribute child-bearing according to participant interest? How do you distribute child-rearing according to participant interest, bearing in mind that an infant just wants to suck on a breast and doesn't care about your views on gender roles.
- erikpukinskis 14y ago> Okay how do you distribute child-bearing according to participant interest? Adoption. > How do you distribute child-rearing according to participant interest, bearing in mind that an infant just wants to suck on a breast and doesn't care about your views on gender roles. There are some limits to what can be shared. I advocate going right up to that line. A woman who wants to raise a baby at some point has to make tough choices about formula, breast pumping, bonding, and her other priorities in life. There is a qualitative difference between the handful of hard limits imposed by biology, and the many limits imposed by compulsory monolithic gender roles.