2 ms·
I agree with this; I don't see why the New York Times should get any special privileges because it's a "journalistic organization". But that just means everybod
by CamperBob2 14y ago
I agree with this; I don't see why the New York Times should get any special privileges because it's a "journalistic organization". But that just means everybody should have to abide by the same rules; it doesn't mean the rules should allow corporations to do things with company money that many if not most of their employees and shareholders would not agree with, just because those things happen to be "speech".
But the New York Times and Citizens United are both corporate entities. Few would question the NYT's right to publish editorials that promote specific political opinions and candidates, correct? What can you say about the NYT that you can't say about CU?
If they want to express opinions as a large group, they can all sign the same letter or petition. Using company money to do things that only some of the company's owners or employees would assent to is not "free speech"; it's misuse of company money. That used to be called "embezzlement", not free speech.
Your argument has a trivial workaround, which would have been put into widespread practice if the Citizens United decision had gone the other way. Every corporation in America would have added a line to its charter similar to whatever line in the NYT charter causes it to be considered an editorial publisher. If necessary, a similar line would have been added to every employment agreement signed by every corporate employee upon being hired.
- pdonis 14y agoWhat can you say about the NYT that you can't say about CU? Actually, if anything, CU would be less open to the issue I'm raising, of corporate money being expended for purposes that many or most of its shareholders do not agree with. CU was organized for the express purpose of political speech; NYT and most corporations are not. And most corporations are not even organized for the express purpose of publishing speech in general, as NYT is. That means most corporations shouldn't be able to make the same kinds of assumptions about what speech their shareholders would assent to, that the NYT can. Every corporation in America would have added a line to its charter similar to whatever line in the NYT charter causes it to be considered an editorial publisher. If necessary, a similar line would have been added to every employment agreement signed by every corporate employee upon being hired. Yes, you're right, in a practical sense this is what would happen. But that just underscores how broken corporate governance is now. The legal fiction of a "corporation" is abused in all manner of ways. IMO it would be better to restrict what "corporations", particularly publicly traded ones, can do with corporate money, and how broad their charters can be. But that's really a legislative fix, not a judicial one.
- CamperBob2 14y agoThe legal fiction of a "corporation" is abused in all manner of ways. True, but I don't see how to fix it without serious unintended consequences in other areas.
- pdonis 14y agoAre there particular consequences you have in mind?
- CamperBob2 14y agoYes, you still haven't explained how to suppress Monsanto's political speech while preserving that of the New York Times. The idea that a corporation must be organized for an "express purpose," declared in advance, that will determine that corporation's rights relative to others, is troublesome to put it mildly. A government that enforces things like that WILL enforce things that you and I don't like as well.
- pdonis 14y agoyou still haven't explained how to suppress Monsanto's political speech while preserving that of the New York Times. Maybe I didn't make myself clear enough. I'm not talking about suppressing corporations' political speech specifically. I'm talking generally about corporations not being able to use company money for purposes not agreed to by a majority of shareholders. A corporation like NYT (or CU, for that matter), which is organized specifically for the purpose of publishing speech, is in a different position in that regard from a corporation which is organized to sell people crop seeds. The idea that a corporation must be organized for an "express purpose," declared in advance, that will determine that corporation's rights relative to others, is troublesome to put it mildly. A government that enforces things like that WILL enforce things that you and I don't like as well. The government is what gives corporations their legal privileges in the first place. Without the government, a corporation is just a bunch of people. It's government that allows corporations to shield their shareholders and officers from personal liability, take advantage of tax deductions for business expenses, etc. I should make clear, btw, that I am not advocating removing all the aspects of corporations as legal persons. There are a lot of aspects of that that are very useful; for example, allowing corporations to enter into contracts and other legal agreements. I just don't think that automatically means that corporations must have all the aspects of legal persons, which is the underlying assumption behind the claim that corporations somehow automatically have free speech and other rights simply because they're legal persons.