4 ms·
Two things: 10,000 years is totally enough time for evolution to work on humans. See: lactose tolerance. Just as importantly, we've been evolving the living
by saalweachter 14y ago
Two things:
10,000 years is totally enough time for evolution to work on humans. See: lactose tolerance.
Just as importantly, we've been evolving the living daylights out of every domestic plant via selective breeding for just as long. Wild potatoes are poisonous, as are almonds. Maize started out with tiny grain. Apples have been bred into a bazillion varieties, with different sizes, tastes, and textures.
It's silly to say that it's more natural to eat cauliflower than corn, when neither properly existed 10,000 years ago.
- jessaustin 14y agoSee: lactose tolerance GP specifically mentioned that and dismissed it with a seemingly reasonable argument; care to respond to that? Besides, most humans are not lactose tolerant as adults. Has there been any research concerning a putative phytic acid tolerance? If so, have we identified a particular set of relevant genes? Have we studied the incidence of these genes in various populations? I sort of assume that humans can handle most compounds they eat on a regular basis, but it seems that many compounds are harmful when consumed in excessive amounts.
- saalweachter 14y agoYeah, that was a product of my poor reading; mea culpa and my apologies. But I do think it is wrong to dismiss lactose tolerance as an example of recent adaption: most adaptations start as a single mutation with a selective advantage. It is disingenuous to claim phytic acid would require "a whole new enzyme", because if an enzyme were evolved specifically to break it down, the way it'd happen is that an existing enzyme would be duplicated (and there's a healthy amount of duplication in the typical genome to start with) and a small number of mutations would specialize this copy for phytic acid. It could be a single mutation on an already duplicated gene; it could be a series of one or more random mutations followed by the final mutation which begins to exert a selective pressure. But all this is predicated on there being a selective pressure to digest phytic acid. For lactose, there is a strong selective pressure. For diet-related prion disorders (kuru), there is a strong selective pressure. Is there a strong selective pressure to digest phytic acid? Maybe there is, and the adaptation requires too many mutations to reach. Maybe there isn't, and so there is no selective pressure to drive an adaptation. If I am taking the position that grains aren't that bad, then I am also taking the position that phytic acid -- as it is found in our diets -- isn't particularly bad. Hence, my position must be that there is no strong selective pressure to begin digesting phytic acid, anymore than there is to begin producing our own vitamin C.
- nicholas73 14y agoThe difference is that the evolution for lactose digestion involves turning off an already existing gene. Digesting phytic acid involves evolving a new gene - a new enzyme maker. So you are talking about one random mutation vs. XXXX mutations. A genetic study has found that humans did evolve rapidly in the last 10,000 years, but most of the changes were one-off mutations such as these.