2 ms·
"Scholars continue to argue over whether an increase in population made the shift towards agriculture necessary, or a shift towards agriculture caused an increa
by vanderZwan 14y ago
"Scholars continue to argue over whether an increase in population made the shift towards agriculture necessary, or a shift towards agriculture caused an increase in population that made a return to a hunter-gatherer society impossible5. In either case, once the neolithic revolution had begun there was no turning back."
This is an entirely different discussion than what the article is about, but why are "scholars" assuming those two factors are the only ones to consider? (assuming they actually are, and this assumption isn't years behind the real debate going on among the scientists)
There's evidence suggesting that the first time humans cooperated in groups larger than the default tribe size, it was caused by something completely different: religion[1]. Göbekli Tepe - the oldest known temple in the world - predates agriculture[2]. It wouldn't surprise me at all if religion was the main (if indirect) social driving force behind a lot of these prehistoric changes in lifestyles that resulted in modern human society.
[1] http://www.newscientist.com/article/mg21328562.100-the-god-issue-religion-is-the-key-to-civilisation.html?full=true http://www.newscientist.com/article/mg21328562.100-the-god-i...
[2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/G%C3%B6bekli_Tepe http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/G%C3%B6bekli_Tepe
- zeteo 14y agoI've been thinking a lot about this and I believe you're correct. Agriculture appeared in the Near East around 12k years ago, and civilization only around 6k years ago (if we date it by the Uruk period). If agriculture made cities possible, why did people live in tiny villages for another 6k years after discovering it?