4 ms·
You have to keep doing the dance forever. This is what it means to live in a republic.
by snowwrestler 14y ago
You have to keep doing the dance forever. This is what it means to live in a republic.
- tomku 14y agoIt's disturbing how many people here on HN don't seem to realize this. This isn't some kind of cosmic struggle between good and evil where a hero will arise and vanquish the opposing side entirely - it's two (or more) sides with different opinions about what should be done. The people on the other side on any given issue are just as sure that they're right as we are that we're right. They're going to keep trying, just like we would keep trying if we suffer a setback. I find that the good-and-evil view is completely toxic to open discussion. Everyone assumes that anybody who disagrees with them must be "the enemy", and sets out to either change their mind or scare them off. One side usually succeeds. The resulting threads are neither interesting nor informative to read, even if you agree with the majority viewpoint - there's too much circlejerking and preaching to the choir. In an effort to have more productive discussions, here are a couple of loose rules that I try to hold myself to when I talk about controversial topics like politics online. I've found that trying to abide by them makes it a lot easier to have civil discussions with people who hold opposing views. 1) Someone disagreeing with me does not make them automatically stupid, malicious or evil. All three of those terms should be proven to apply only when necessary, not assumed - and the bar of proof should be high. Assume good faith and intelligent opposition unless I have incontrovertible proof otherwise. 2) I am not some kind of oracle of wisdom. On average, my opinions are roughly as likely to be completely wrong as anyone else's. On any given issue, almost nobody is going to be completely right. The few people who are completely right aren't necessarily the ones who have convinced themselves of it beforehand. 3) I should try to hold claims that seem to support my position to an even higher standard than I hold the opposition's claims to. On any sufficiently controversial topic, there will be dishonesty and misinformation going around on all sides, much of which is spread unwittingly by people who think that they're doing the right thing. Never blindly believe someone because they're saying something that you WANT to be true. 4) Disagree with the opinion, not the person. Other people are complex creatures that hold countless opinions, many of which I probably agree with even if I disagree on other things. It's never worth it to insult or dehumanize someone because of an opinion they hold, even if I vehemently disagree about it. Sorry that this comment turned out to be rather long and perhaps a bit off-topic, but after finishing it I think it's better in one piece rather than broken up and posted all over the thread. Thanks for reading!