5 ms·
Here's what dismays me about this. We killed it once. It's back again. Let's say it's bad and we want to kill it, and we succeed again. What's to say it won't
by hkmurakami 14y ago
Here's what dismays me about this. We killed it once. It's back again. Let's say it's bad and we want to kill it, and we succeed again.
What's to say it won't come back again? How long do we have to keep doing this dance? Even if it is worth killing every time, will our attention spans be long enough to keep fighting it every single time for the decades that may still come?
- zizee 14y ago"The price of liberty is eternal vigilance." -unknown.
- harshreality 14y agoThat's a slightly modified form of the "eternal vigilance" quote by http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Philpot_Curran http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Philpot_Curran
- zizee 14y agoa slightly modified form More like a TL;DR version of it :-) The full quote from John Philpot Curran is: It is the common fate of the indolent to see their rights become a prey to the active. The condition upon which God hath given liberty to man is eternal vigilance; which condition if he break, servitude is at once the consequence of his crime and the punishment of his guilt. The new (shortened) "version" is somewhat more pithy, and far more easy to distribute. So maybe someone other that Curran deserves some of the credit. I wrote "unknown" as the quote is often mis/attributed to Thomas Jefferson, but the evidence is not strong here.
- TruthElixirX 14y agoYay. You understand why this whole process is futile. This bill isn't the problem. This bill is a symptom of the problem. The problem is not going away. The problem is the U.S. federal government. It is an out of control machine of death seeking to criminalize as much behavior as possible. The U.S. has the highest incarceration rate. They have the most weapons. This kind of thing will not end until the government collapses in on itself or people have an entire paradigm shift in the way that they think of their relation to their fellow person.
- Aloha 14y agoThe people have nothing to do with it anymore. The vested moneyed interests are in control, and will be until the people wake up from their stupor and pay attention.
- TruthElixirX 14y agoBullshit. We live in a horizontal hierarchy enforced vertically. This stiff happens because the people are complacent and complicit.
- brown9-2 14y agoI actually think that it's a pretty good characteristic of the US government that unpopular proposed laws have to be re-proposed rather than rammed through without any debate or legislative process by some sort of dictatorship.
- saraid216 14y agoA complete answer to this question is really nothing less than a comprehensive study of the entire field of political science. The reality is that you have two choices: you either defer your right of governance to someone else and just stop caring, or you will never be free of this. No victory is eternal. There is no such thing as victory. In a sense, this is actually why it keeps coming up. The reality of governance is such an immense expanse of tedium that a great many people buckle under it and try to imagine themselves as heroes or rebels or old wise men. They go looking for enemies where there are none and make them up to fight, making meaning where none was needed before. In any case, the answer to your question is, "Until you're dead, and someone else will have to keep it up after that."
- dchichkov 14y agoYep. Sure. It will come back in a decade or so. And then in another decade. And I actually find that encouraging. That's democracy in action. But meanwhile, now, - let's do something positive and try to avert that bill that facilitates violations of essential liberties!
- snowwrestler 14y agoYou have to keep doing the dance forever. This is what it means to live in a republic.
- tomku 14y agoIt's disturbing how many people here on HN don't seem to realize this. This isn't some kind of cosmic struggle between good and evil where a hero will arise and vanquish the opposing side entirely - it's two (or more) sides with different opinions about what should be done. The people on the other side on any given issue are just as sure that they're right as we are that we're right. They're going to keep trying, just like we would keep trying if we suffer a setback. I find that the good-and-evil view is completely toxic to open discussion. Everyone assumes that anybody who disagrees with them must be "the enemy", and sets out to either change their mind or scare them off. One side usually succeeds. The resulting threads are neither interesting nor informative to read, even if you agree with the majority viewpoint - there's too much circlejerking and preaching to the choir. In an effort to have more productive discussions, here are a couple of loose rules that I try to hold myself to when I talk about controversial topics like politics online. I've found that trying to abide by them makes it a lot easier to have civil discussions with people who hold opposing views. 1) Someone disagreeing with me does not make them automatically stupid, malicious or evil. All three of those terms should be proven to apply only when necessary, not assumed - and the bar of proof should be high. Assume good faith and intelligent opposition unless I have incontrovertible proof otherwise. 2) I am not some kind of oracle of wisdom. On average, my opinions are roughly as likely to be completely wrong as anyone else's. On any given issue, almost nobody is going to be completely right. The few people who are completely right aren't necessarily the ones who have convinced themselves of it beforehand. 3) I should try to hold claims that seem to support my position to an even higher standard than I hold the opposition's claims to. On any sufficiently controversial topic, there will be dishonesty and misinformation going around on all sides, much of which is spread unwittingly by people who think that they're doing the right thing. Never blindly believe someone because they're saying something that you WANT to be true. 4) Disagree with the opinion, not the person. Other people are complex creatures that hold countless opinions, many of which I probably agree with even if I disagree on other things. It's never worth it to insult or dehumanize someone because of an opinion they hold, even if I vehemently disagree about it. Sorry that this comment turned out to be rather long and perhaps a bit off-topic, but after finishing it I think it's better in one piece rather than broken up and posted all over the thread. Thanks for reading!
- diminoten 14y agoHow did we "kill" CISPA? It passed with a vote count of 248-168 in the house.
- nacker 14y agoIt's a war of attrition. The corporate monopoly state will win eventually, unless we stop using the internet architecture that they own, and develop decentralized mesh networks. Please listen to this summary of the problem: http://www.corbettreport.com/episode-262-solutions-pirate-internet/ http://www.corbettreport.com/episode-262-solutions-pirate-in...