3 ms·
Bruce Schneier walks past the AT&T building and sees a Shop front called customer services. There on the sidewalk is a filing cabinet labelled "your records".
by lifeisstillgood 14y ago
Bruce Schneier walks past the AT&T building and sees a
Shop front called customer services. There on the sidewalk is a filing cabinet labelled "your records". Instructions on the cabinet say please open the drawer and read your own personal records. Do not read anyone else's.
Bruce looks at his, then checks that he can look at some others - he collects 100 examples and angered by this he takes those examples and posts them on his blog as proof of a major security failing so bad it's embarrassing
Now weev it seems is an Unpleasent person who has been looking for ways to attack AT&T. - but is the strawman argument above an accurate analogy to the facts of the case?
If so I really don't see what his motives or personality have to do with anything other than his sentencing. It's the prosecution and conviction that seem wrong afaik
- rayiner 14y agoChange "100" to "tens of thousands" and "posts them on his blog" "suggests to someone else that he was going to sell them for profit" and you've got a damn good analogy.
- lifeisstillgood 14y agoAnd why are either of those crimes?
- rayiner 14y agoBecause it's not okay to access data you know you shouldn't look at and threaten to sell that data to parties that would use it to harm others. The fact that nothing is stopping you from doing so does not make it okay. The world is full of sensitive information that's basically protected on the honor system, for the same reason the world is full of unlocked doors: because we assume some assholes won't come around and abuse the situation.
- lifeisstillgood 14y agoIn this case? Really? AT&T had a duty of care to protect their Data which they signally failed to do. Then some asshole finds out and makes that situation public. He did not do so in a responsible manner but four years is a long time to get for being an asshole. If that is commonplace HN is going to be a smaller forum
- rayiner 14y agoLet's stop making things up about the facts of the case, shall we? Weev did not get 41 months for being the asshole that made AT&T's blunder public. The worst he could have gotten for the CFAA charge by itself would have been a misdemeanor with a maximum penalty of less than a year (and realistically, probably zero jail time). Weev was convicted, by a jury, of fraud in connection with personal information. The jury believed he intended to sell the e-mail addresses he collected to people who would use them for various nefarious purposes. Given that he claimed he was going to do so in IRC conversations, it's really hard for you to sit there and argue that the jury was unreasonable in reaching this conclusion, and that all they are really punishing him for is blowing the lid on AT&T. What you're doing is trying to create a particular narrative about Weev's intentions, but ignoring that the jury in this case heard and rejected this narrative.
- lifeisstillgood 14y agoReally I hate the idea of convicting people for intentions Whilst I see that there are times and crimes it is viable, it's just a vicious circle. He intended to commit a crime, but did not? And so he got jail? I admit I am taking this too far on too little reading of the case (any links to original docs would be useful) but intention is real flimsy.