5 ms·
Yes. Garnish his wages. Consider something like $10,000 over 10 years. Enough to notice, but it's not going to make a software engineer homeless. (I think t
by jrockway 14y ago
Yes. Garnish his wages.
Consider something like $10,000 over 10 years. Enough to notice, but it's not going to make a software engineer homeless. (I think that's too much in this case, but consider non-violent criminals in general.)
- Cieplak 14y agoAnd in this manner, he could still keep a job and perhaps add value to society. Sending him to prison is a net loss for everyone, because of the cost to society of keeping him locked in a cage, and the difficulty of him finding employment following the prison sentence, in which case he might continue to drain on society. Prisons should serve to prevent violent people from inflicting harm upon others, and not strictly as a method of punishment.
- jamesaguilar 14y agoTo be fair, this is a threat of violence against his employer if they do not comply. Also, another way to look at it is forced taking, which is also violent.
- jrockway 14y agoYes, but most employers err on the side of caution, reducing the likelihood of violence. There will never be no violence until every individual on Earth always acts in society's best interest without any persuasion whatsoever. I think we can all agree that's not going to happen ever, so in order to maintain order, we do need to threaten violence in the right circumstances.
- jamesaguilar 14y agoAgreed. Your rationale and mine align, but are in opposition to the person I originally responded to, who suggested a blanked prohibition on violent punishment against non-violent offenders.
- readme 14y ago1000 bucks a year as punishment? Why not just write him a traffic ticket. That's not nearly enough.
- lilsunnybee 14y agoDo you get 10 traffic tickets a year? How much should we fine a 12 year old script kiddie if they were to do the same thing? AT&T is to blame here for not taking even the smallest measure to secure their data.
- readme 14y agoA minor? You can't fine a minor because they don't have income. You could fine their parents. I would suggest juvenile hall, maybe 1 week. If we were to fine weev, for a crime that was otherwise punishable with jail, it should be done as a percentage of his income. 15% would be hurtful enough, I think. Tons of americans are already swimming in well-intentioned debt that's far worse than the "punishment" suggested above.