6 ms·
Just to be clear, your primary reference is The American Cancer Society, which is a non-profit charity. You know it's not a scientific research organization, ri
by dalke 14y ago
Just to be clear, your primary reference is The American Cancer Society, which is a non-profit charity. You know it's not a scientific research organization, right? And one which has a rather mediocre rating, as charities go?
Why do you pick specifically that reference, which sits very carefully on the fence in order to find something good about naturopathic therapies? ("good diet" and "counseling" are, of course, quite common recommendations of any doctor)
Why not reference an actual research organization which also has patient outreach? I'm thinking specifically of The National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine, of the NIH, at http://nccam.nih.gov/health/cancer/camcancer.htm http://nccam.nih.gov/health/cancer/camcancer.htm . They've gotten into political hot water because it was started and funded to find how if CAM is useful, only to report that no, it nearly isn't useful at all.
That site NCCA describes only on the treatments which are specific to CAM, and not shared with standard medical practice.
- analog 14y agoI did a quick google search and it was one of the first references that came up. I only have to provide a citation that CAM sometimes works to disprove Nursies assertion that CAM "doesn't work".
- dalke 14y agoNursie did not assert simply that all of CAM "doesn't work". Nursie pointed out that those aspects of CAM which do work are shared with traditional medicine, and have been part of traditional medicine for a long time. They are not specific to CAM. A naturopath may suggest that you always wear a seatbelt when driving a car. That doesn't make the suggestion part of naturopathy. A naturopath may suggest that you keep the safety on when carrying a firearm. Again, that's a good suggestion, but it's not something specific to naturopathy. The examples you pointed out on the Cancer Society web page are not unique to naturopathy. I interpret them as trying to say something good about naturopathy, probably because of so many complaints about how naturopathy is being 'suppressed by Western thought', or something like that. The NIH site I pointed you to reports on the CAM practices which are specific to CAM. Very few of them "work" in any fashion, and none of them are treatments.
- analog 14y agoNo sorry you're wrong, he responded to me saying 'if it works' with "It doesn't.", and also said "I don't understand how it works because it doesn't"
- dalke 14y ago"It" refers to the part of alt.med which isn't part of med. That's the part that makes it "alt." At least, that's how I interpret it. The full context is: analog: "Paleo diet has worked, and also alt medicine", followed by Nursie: "I don't understand how it works because it doesn't!" The immediate context for 'it' is homeopathy, but I think, based on Nursie's other statements, that it should apply to all of alt.med. It doesn't apply to (to coin an abbreviation), "std.med", because it seems that Nursie finds convincing evidence that std.med does work. So the question to you is, what puts the "alt." in "alt.med"? If practice X is part of "alt.med" and is part of "std.med" then is how is X "alt"? It's possible that something started as alt.med and became part of std.med, but the practices listed on the ACS page have been part of std.med since pretty much since the dawn of evidence-based medicine, so it's not like std.med recently took those parts from alt.med. Therefore, you should interpret those quote of Nursie to mean: "[The part of alt.med which is specific to alt.med] doesn't [work]" and "I don't understand how [the alt. part of alt.med] works because [the alt. part of alt.med] doesn't [have any demonstrated effectiveness]".
- analog 14y agoOne of the examples cited by the ACS is the use of prayer. Apparently this has been shown to be effective in some cases. The use of prayer is definitely part of alt med, and has been shown to work, therefore Nursie is incorrect when he says "alt med does not work".
- dalke 14y agoNo, prayer has not been shown to work. Rather, what do you mean by "work"? If people who pray feel more relaxed, then yes, it works for some people. So does meditation. So does reading a book, or watching a movie. Or playing cards, or talking with friends. If by "effective" you mean that people who pray have a higher longevity, higher rate of being cured, etc. then no, it doesn't work. This type of prayer is usually called intercessory prayer. Take for example http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/16569567 http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/16569567 . > Intercessory prayer is widely believed to influence recovery from illness, but claims of benefits are not supported by well-controlled clinical trials. Prior studies have not addressed whether prayer itself or knowledge/certainty that prayer is being provided may influence outcome. We evaluated whether (1) receiving intercessory prayer or (2) being certain of receiving intercessory prayer was associated with uncomplicated recovery after coronary artery bypass graft (CABG) surgery. ... > CONCLUSIONS: Intercessory prayer itself had no effect on complication-free recovery from CABG, but certainty of receiving intercessory prayer was associated with a higher incidence of complications. Take for another example http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/19370557 http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/19370557 . > OBJECTIVES: To review the effects of intercessory prayer as an additional intervention for people with health problems already receiving routine health care. > AUTHORS' CONCLUSIONS: These findings are equivocal and, although some of the results of individual studies suggest a positive effect of intercessory prayer, the majority do not and the evidence does not support a recommendation either in favour or against the use of intercessory prayer. We are not convinced that further trials of this intervention should be undertaken and would prefer to see any resources available for such a trial used to investigate other questions in health care.
- Nursie 14y ago"I only have to provide a citation that CAM sometimes works to disprove Nursies assertion that CAM "doesn't work"." It helps to pick something that is actually CAM then, and not part of mainstream health advice that has been coopted by CAM. Eating well and getting lots of exercise isn't exactly revolutionary, outside-the-box, non-mainstream thinking.