3 ms·
If I'm allowed to take a hammer and smash the phone while it's "bound by a service agreement" I should also be allowed to fiddle with the electronics. The reas
by guelo 14y ago
If I'm allowed to take a hammer and smash the phone while it's "bound by a service agreement" I should also be allowed to fiddle with the electronics.
The reason it is not illegal to smash the phone is because it is your phone. The service agreement is a contract that you entered saying you will pay a monthly fee for two years independently of what happens to the phone. The phone is used by the phone company as an incentive to get you to enter the contract.
In any case, breaking a term of a private contract is not a criminal act. If I stop paying my monthly phone bill they can potentially sue me in civil court but the FBI won't come knocking on my door. The DMCA criminal "circumvention" statute doesn't really have anything to do with the private contract.
- niggler 14y ago"The reason it is not illegal to smash the phone is because it is your phone." And because you have to either continue paying for service or pay a termination fee. In either case the provider is recouping the cost.
- ahlatimer 14y ago> And because you have to either continue paying for service or pay a termination fee. Isn't that still the case if I switch carriers?
- benologist 14y agoIf you terminate your agreement then you "aren't bound by a service agreement or other obligation".
- benaiah 14y agoWe're not talking about terminating an agreement. He would have to continue paying his old contract, because he said he would. Now, however, he would be able to take on a new contract with a different company, whether immediately or later on, preventing him from forever being stuck with the same carrier for that phone. It's not like a mortgage, where the bank technically still owns part of your home. It's a package deal. When you buy the phone, subsidized or not, it's yours. The US legislature has made it illegal for you to unlock the phone, despite that fact.