3 ms·
Let's say that 10% of the people who switched to a paleo diet found that it "worked". (Without knowing what "worked" means, I'll assume it's "lose weight.") If
by dalke 14y ago
Let's say that 10% of the people who switched to a paleo diet found that it "worked". (Without knowing what "worked" means, I'll assume it's "lose weight.")
If you talk to those people for whom it worked, then great! there may be evidence there.
However, let's say that of the people who decided lose weight through other means (a low calorie diet, more exercise, gastric bypass, whatever), 10% were successful.
With this additional information, it's hard to conclude that choosing a paleo diet makes a strong difference.
In other words, looking at the success cases doesn't give a conclusion, only a possible path for followup investigation. It's unscientific to say that something "works" by only looking at the successful cases. You also need to track the failure cases (those who tried paleo but where it didn't work), and the success and failure cases for other methods.
The same for medicine. If someone tries X (aspirin, herbs, whiskey, zinc, penicillin, etc.) for the flu then gets better within a couple of days, then it doesn't mean that X actually "worked". There could be other reasons for why the person got better, like the person's own immune system. (For the record, none of those 'medicines' will work against the flu, though a few of them will help relieve some of the symptoms.)
That's why these anecdotal accounts, while true and even heart-felt, don't suffice to make a scientific conclusion.