5 ms·
The "average user" is also not a real user. There aren't actual average users - they're a conceptual aggregate of a broad-range of users who may use entirely di
by XorNot 14y ago
The "average user" is also not a real user. There aren't actual average users - they're a conceptual aggregate of a broad-range of users who may use entirely different sets of features, which share only a few common overlaps.
You can not damage the "average user" at all, but manage to break the workflow of most of your real users but eliminating parts of the set of features they depend on.
i.e. remove 100 different features only used by 1% of your users, and it's actually quite likely you've removed features 100% of your users use.
- agwa 14y agoThat's a really good way of putting it.
- Erwin 14y agoHowever the workflow issues you break are sometimes something like this: http://xkcd.com/1172/ http://xkcd.com/1172/ -- that may be a problem with software you paid $1 for 3 years ago and expected forever to work exactly as you need it.
- nitrogen 14y agoWhy shouldn't one expect to have one's purchased goods remain available indefinitely, no matter the price? This comic is not meant to be a justification for removing actual features.
- mfjordvald 14y agoHow did you mentally go from "expected forever to work exactly as you need it." to "Why shouldn't one expect to have one's purchased goods remain available indefinitely"? There's a huge difference between being available and not ever changing. You're arguing against a point never made.
- nitrogen 14y agoIf I paid for a piece of software three years ago, I expect that piece of software that I obtained three years ago to work forever.
- JoshTriplett 14y ago> i.e. remove 100 different features only used by 1% of your users, and it's actually quite likely you've removed features 100% of your users use. Perhaps true, but your estimates are off by many orders of magnitude. Wikipedia puts the Firefox userbase at 450 million. How many people do you think need to turn off SSL? Hundreds? Thousands? That's about 0.0002%. How many need to turn off or manually tweak the size of disk cache? Over 9000? That's still only 0.002%. And oddly enough, it'll overlap heavily with the last 0.002%, and the next 0.002%.
- nitrogen 14y agoI think it's easy for early adopters to feel like developers owe us because we're the ones whose advocacy got them those 450mil users.
- tomkarlo 14y agoAdvocacy is fine, but in the end it was the product itself that got the 450M users. You can't grassroots something that's not actually good.
- nitrogen 14y agoRight, the developers and the early adopters deserve deference; I'm saying that it's easy for an early adopter to believe that the other 450mil users do not. After all, they're using it anyway despite it being friendly to the early adopters.
- singleuse 14y agoIt doesn't mean the product was actually good, it simply means it lacked a better alternative.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- tomkarlo 14y ago