4 ms·
"Bitcoin-style block-chain consensus" Majority rule not consensus. Given a mere majority rule protocol, I think your virtual world idea could work.
by VLM 14y ago
"Bitcoin-style block-chain consensus"
Majority rule not consensus. Given a mere majority rule protocol, I think your virtual world idea could work.
- derefr 14y agoEh, either way, it's the same problem. Imagine you're an agent for BigBank, thinking you're running on Alice's computer. If you authenticate yourself to BigBank, BigBank gives you a session key you can use to communicate securely with them--and then you will take messages from Alice and pass them on to BigBank. But you could also be running, instead, on an emulator on Harry's computer--and Harry wants Alice's credit card info. So now Harry reaches in and steals the key BigBank gave you, then deploys a copy of you back into the mesh, hardcoded to use that session key. Alice then unwittingly uses Harry's version of you--and Harry MITMs her exchange. In ordinary Internet transactions, this is avoided because Alice just keeps an encryption key (a pinned cert) for BigBank, and speaks to them directly. If you, as an agent, are passed a request for BigBank, it's one that's already been asymmetrically encrypted for BigBank's eyes only. And that works... if the bank is running outside of the mesh. But if the bank is itself a distributed service provided by the mesh? Not so much. (I'm not sure how much of a limitation that is in practice, though, other than "sadly, we cannot run the entire internet inside the mesh.")