3 ms·
Harvard Admissions Drop to 7% on Record Applicants
- awad 18y agoThe numbers will continue to decline, the student body is growing larger and larger every year. My year is the largest freshman class ever...until next year. The pressure put on students these days is insane. It's a non stop competition since conception.
- tokenadult 18y agoMy year is the largest freshman class ever...until next year. Actually, I think the number of dorm spaces for freshmen puts a hard limit on the number of new students at Harvard each year. Let me make sure I'm understanding you correctly: are you saying you were admitted in the most recent announced new class, the class that entered in fall 2008 (Harvard class of '12)? Or maybe you mean something else. My prediction is that the number of applicants will still go up next year, but the number of admitted students will be set so that the number of ENROLLED students in 2010 is as near as possible to the number last year and this year.
- awad 18y agoI meant overall class size (for the entire country). As far as I am aware, the class of 2012 is the largest in history thus far.
- tokenadult 18y agoOh, okay, now I'm clear about what you meant. Thanks. I've written up a little FAQ on college application demographics; please let me know what you think. Population trends in the United States are not the only issue influencing the competitiveness of college admission here. The children already born show us what the expected number of high school students are in various years, but the number of high school students in the United States, which is expected to begin declining in a few years, isn't the whole story. http://www.nytimes.com/2008/03/09/education/09admissions.html?pagewanted=2&_r=1&hp http://www.nytimes.com/2008/03/09/education/09admissions.htm... First of all, if more students who begin high school go on to college, there will be more applicants to college even with a declining number of high school students. And that is the trend in the United States and worldwide. Second, colleges in the United States accept applications from all over the world, so it is quite possible that demographic trends in the United States will not be the main influence on how many students apply to college. The cohorts of high-school-age students are still increasing in size in some countries (NOT most of Europe). Third, even if the number of applicants to colleges overall stays the same, or even declines, the number of applicants to the most competitive colleges may still increase. The trend around the world is a "flight to quality" of students trying to get into the best college they can in increasing numbers, and increasing their consensus about which colleges to put at the top of their application lists. I do not expect college admission to be any easier for my youngest child than for my oldest child, even though she is part of a smaller birth cohort in the United States. And now I would add to this that at the very most selective colleges that have just announced new financial aid plans, next year's (and the following year's) crush of applicants will be larger than ever. When colleges that are already acknowledged to be great colleges start reducing their net cost down to what the majority of families in the United States can afford, those colleges will receive more applications from all parts of the United States, and very likely from all over the world. The Economist magazine published a brief article about these trends in April 2008. http://www.economist.com/world/na/displaystory.cfm?story_id=11058525&CFID=4596233&CFTOKEN=12382953 http://www.economist.com/world/na/displaystory.cfm?story_id=...
- awad 18y agoThose are all very good points, especially the last two. The rush for quality can only go up. And now, it's within anyone's means, provided they are accepted.
- jacobolus 18y ago> The pressure put on students these days is insane. I'd argue it's mostly self-imposed. > It's a non stop competition since conception. "Non-stop competition" against what? Most of the students in the harder courses care more about helping each-other understand difficult material than about competing.
- endtime 18y ago>I'd argue it's mostly self-imposed. Could you explain why you think that? Is there evidence that shows that students who don't work as hard have an equal chance of getting into top schools? >"Non-stop competition" against what? Most of the students in the harder courses care more about helping each-other understand difficult material than about competing. I've had that experience at Stanford, though I've heard it's not like that at some places (e.g. Berkeley, and I was told so by someone who did his undergrad there). But he's talking about competition to get in, not competition once there.
- jacobolus 18y agoI think there's some difference between "work hard" and "think of school as a competitive endeavor".
- awad 18y ago>"Non-stop competition" against what? Most of the students in the harder courses care more about helping each-other understand difficult material than about competing. I was referring to the competition to get into the coveted few spots available at the top schools in the country. Granted, it's always been competitive, but it only gets more competitive with larger and larger class sizes
- jacobolus 18y agoAh, fair enough. A few things: First, such competition is on such a massive scale that local competition against classmates, &c., is harmful. Indeed, I think even thinking about college admissions as zero-sum is counterproductive. I also still think most of such pressure and competition are self imposed, and frankly often a misdirection of effort and attention: students who care about learning for its own sake and spend effort on what they're curious about and have enough free time to pursue those interests (clearly some who have a language barrier, and must take part time jobs to feed younger siblings, etc. are at a disadvantage here) will manage to get into a decent college somewhere (there are so many fantastic ones!). Then again, I'm rather less motivated by grades/prestige/promises of future salary/etc. than most students around here.
- deleted 18y ago[deleted]
- Anon84 18y agoOnly 7%? Last I heard, after their endowment went down 30% they pretty much had a hire/tenure freeze on faculty/staff.
- endtime 18y agoSimilar numbers for Stanford: http://news-service.stanford.edu/news/2009/january28/admission-012809.html http://news-service.stanford.edu/news/2009/january28/admissi... Apparently, Stanford got 20% more applicants this year than last year. If it were an increase in grad school apps, it might have an explanation in the economy, but I'm not sure what could explain such an increase in undergrad apps.
- Brushfire 18y agoI dont have any stats, but since I have been applying to grad schools this year (and accepted, woo!), I can tell you that for most schools the numbers have been way up across the board. Since most of the admissions stuff is happening at this very moment, good numbers wont actually be available for a few more months.
- endtime 18y agoCongrats on getting accepted. I remember getting my first acceptance (UCSD); it was a great feeling.
- quizbiz 18y agoJust got accepted into Emory today. I'm sorry but I want to yell it to the world. I hear back from the last college I applied to tomorrow. I have to keep telling myself to expect a rejection. It's the one ivy league I applied to. Gulp. This whole process has been odd and strange. It has put a very friendly group of students at odds sometimes. And by no means is it over yet. It only intensifies with the work load. As seniors, we constantly expect things to cool off, but they never ever do. I suppose this is welcome to the real world. I have done well in this system of admissions thus far but I do not feel deserving, I feel lucky. I feel shit damn lucky. Qualified friends of mine are getting rejected or wait listed left and right. This system is flawed. I feel as if it has destroyed the best in me. Tore me down. And for what? The college admissions process and high school as a prep-school need serious fixing and nobody is talking about it. And by talking I mean doing things. I wrote about this today: http://blipfoto.com/view.php?id=275574&month=3&year=2009 http://blipfoto.com/view.php?id=275574&month=3&year=...
- brandnewlow 18y agoIt is luck. It's a big dice roll. If you're admitted to a place that you're excited about, then declare victory and hustle on to learning and making great things there. Leave all this silliness behind as soon as you can.
- jmatt 18y agoCongratulations on getting in. I graduated about 15 years ago. I'll give you a quick summary of the top people in my class. I went to an "average" midwest public high school with about 2000 students freshman year and 450 students graduating senior year. If it is at all reassuring the one person I knew in high school who went to Harvard is now unemployed. He's also a schmuck and I wouldn't be surprised if he ended up in politics in the near future... no surprise. Out of the other top ten in high school that I still keep in contact with three went to state schools on full rides and one went to a second tier ivy league school. They are a chiropractor, a vet and and two doctors. This is also no surprise if you saw them in AP Biology. I think I was the only one in the top 25 to go into Engineering (actually Computer Science). Everyone thought the best way to succeed was to be a doctor, which was largely due to growing up in my home town. The doctors appeared to be doing far better than most engineers or executives at engineering companies. The most financially successful (as far as I know) is the girl who ended up at google working in the Marketing department pre IPO (I'll take luck over skill any day). As for the admissions process, it's just the beginning of the journey. So don't get to wrapped up in it. From my experience: In a six months no one will ask you where else you were accepted... In six years no one will ask what your college GPA was... and in twelve years no one will ask where you went to college. Or at least they won't care much.. only in idle conversation. So use it as an opportunity and enjoy it while you can.
- teuobk 18y agoIt's been a couple years since I pulled the numbers, but here's a chart of the undergraduate admission rates for Harvard, MIT, and Stanford for class years 2004-2011: http://www.keacher.com/files/undergrad-admissions.png http://www.keacher.com/files/undergrad-admissions.png As you can see, the trend is nothing new. The only question is: where will it end? Updated: I added the data for the two most recent years: http://www.keacher.com/files/dir3/undergrad-admissions-rev2.png http://www.keacher.com/files/dir3/undergrad-admissions-rev2....
- awad 18y agoI don't think in the foreseeable future. tokenadult brings up some very good points regarding the rising number of applications. Even if domestic student class sizes were to remain flat (which they won't, as class sizes are getting larger by the year), many foreign students (esp from India and China) of the current generation are now for the first time able to apply to college in the United States.
- redrobot5050 18y agoAnd the follow up might be that more people applying to Harvard (and other good schools) even if they're not really qualified for the schools (but they think they are). America's entitlement problem (and the "we're all winners attitude" some schools teach early on) could lead to a serious education disparity. Public universities, like the one I'm currently attending for my master's, has something like a 90% acceptance rate (and a high wash out rate, as freshmen sometimes learns that college isn't all kegstands and tail gates) whereas Harvard only takes the 93rd percentile...
- brandnewlow 18y agoElite schools are judged, in part, by how many applicants they receive each year. Knowing this, the top schools have done two things: 1. Aggressively market themselves to students earlier and earlier. Many of the top schools begin mailing material to students with desireable profiles as early as freshman year. When I left admissions in '06, people were starting direct mail campaigns to sophomores and we were all wringing our hands over the icky-ness of it. 2. Make it as easy as possible to apply. For all the griping they do, applying to college is crazy easy compared to the process even just 10 years ago. All the top schools take the common application now. And top schools will often waive the application fee if you ask them nicely and tell them you can't afford it. The impact? Kids are applying to more and more schools each year. I don't cry for the kids who get rejected from Harvard. 60% of them applied to at least 7-8 other schools if not 12-13. When all you have to do is check a box, why not apply to 15 schools? This works out great for the schools. Their yields go down, but they get their hands on more applicants than ever.
- tokenadult 18y agothe top schools have done two things: 1. Aggressively market themselves to students earlier and earlier. Here's a link about how Harvard recruits students: http://www.businessweek.com/magazine/content/06_34/b3998441.htm http://www.businessweek.com/magazine/content/06_34/b3998441.... Harvard sends out 70,000 letters to high school students to get enough applications to warrant 2,000 offers of admission, which will result in 1,600 new students enrolling in the next class at Harvard.
- abless 18y agoI get the impression Harvard & Co. urge all high school students, whether they have a realistic chance at getting admitted or not, to apply just to decrease their admission rate. It's not very meaningful.