3 ms·
Both religious and C/AM people usually have an approachable simple, clear way of presenting their (irrational) thesis to an average person. Just like salesmen,
by rdtsc 14y ago
Both religious and C/AM people usually have an approachable simple, clear way of presenting their (irrational) thesis to an average person. Just like salesmen, they appeal to trust, basic needs, use the right words like (clean, pure, natural) for their approach and the right words for the opposite approach (chemical, poisonous, toxic). For homeopathy, stupid little slogans for disease models work "fight fire with fire", "fight like with like" and so on. Makes sense right...
> The transmission seems to be helped by exploiting trusted relationships among network nodes,
I understand your reaction against GP's opinion that he noticed more women in his circles are susceptible to this. I don't know what to tell you, I have the same observation. I would characterize not as "women are wired for irrationality" but maybe women are wired better for communication and for building trusting relationships.
Again, maybe I am making shit up here, this is just my silly observation. But I have noticed that women (in my circle) more so once they establish their trust in respect to other women they we more willing to accept advice such as "so and so told me homeopathy work and I trust".
Also to hammer more on the dangerous topic. I think there is self-fulfilling circular dependency between the idea that women are wired to be irrational and girl acting that way because the society already has that belief.
- Udo 14y ago> I understand your reaction against GP's opinion that he noticed more women in his circles are susceptible to this. Yeah, I am the GP though. I cede that I'm always very skeptical about this "X are just wired for Y" stuff. Historically, this has always been used to discriminate against groups of people, and also historically these assertions have so far always turned out false. This is why I'm assuming a cultural background to this problem, not a physiological one. Just because something happens a lot doesn't mean the reasons are not cultural. > I think there is self-fulfilling circular dependency between the idea that women are wired to be irrational and girl acting that way because the society already has that belief. I agree absolutely.