6 ms·
Not for everyone. I know of two women who were both long-term vegetarians and went back to an omnivorous diet because they were always feeling wan and listless.
by vacri 14y ago
Not for everyone. I know of two women who were both long-term vegetarians and went back to an omnivorous diet because they were always feeling wan and listless. Both women were foodies (one from a 'foodie' family), and both have tertiary education in biology and biochemistry, so they were quite aware of good diets and balancing. This doesn't mean that all women will have this problem, it just means that not everyone can go meat-free and have no quality-of-life issues.
- gordaco 14y agoThis. One of the things about vegetarian diets that rarely gets mentioned is that there are people whose body really profits from meat, while others' don't so much (this is why you get a lot of anecdotes like yours, but also a lot of people for which vegetarian diets do wonders). I read somewhere that it may be related to blood type, but I'm not sure about that, and certainly IANA biologist.
- justin66 14y ago> This doesn't mean that all women will have this problem, it just means that not everyone can go meat-free and have no quality-of-life issues. What it really means is that anecdotes aren't data. Kidding! What it REALLY means is that "tertiary education in biology" causes listlessness.
- vacri 14y agoUsually when I tell that story, almost always the first response is "she just doesn't understand food/how to balance a diet". It's tedious. As for 'anecdotes aren't data' - when blanket statements are made, you only need anecdotes to show that there are exceptions. I also notice you never bothered with the mocking 'anecdotes aren't data' against the parent comment, which is all anecdote and triggered much more in the way of reply.
- justin66 14y agoThe closest the person you were responding to came to making a blanket assertion was "I assure you, it's very possible to live a well-fed life without any meat." Which is kind of trivially true, since many people live "well-fed" (whatever that means) lives without meat. If the person had made the stronger claim "all people can live a well-fed life without any meat" your objection might be more compelling. Although still wrong. > Usually when I tell that story, almost always the first response is "she just doesn't understand food/how to balance a diet". It's tedious. And, if her "listlessness" was corrected by changing her diet, that statement was kind of trivially true, in addition to being tedious, no? (By the way, this would be a better story if you knew more about why the change caused the improvement.) The claim that whatever dietary deficiency these women were (possibly) suffering as vegetarians could only be corrected by eating meat is a pretty bold one, since there aren't any known vitamins, minerals, aminos, etc. that aren't available without eating meat. Since you haven't even identified the deficiency it's not even worth arguing about. Also, food for thought, it's certainly possible the dietary change to eating a meat-based diet REMOVED something they shouldn't have been getting. If they were eating too much wheat as vegetarians and had gluten intolerance, for example.
- vacri 14y agoSo, you are saying that because the original poster said 'possibly', it's not worth an 'anecdotes aren't data', despite me also saying that my stories aren't universally representative. You're providing a textbook case of confirmation bias. since there aren't any known vitamins, minerals, aminos, etc. that aren't available without eating meat Diet is considerably more complex than "X number of atoms enter the body through the oral cavity". You're right that it's not worth arguing about, because you're yet another person who says "they just didn't do it right" - something of a No True Scotsman.
- justin66 14y ago> So, you are saying that because the original poster said 'possibly', it's not worth an 'anecdotes aren't data' What's to argue with about the OP's post? This is genuinely weird. He hates meat an awful lot, doesn't eat it, is doing fine. I didn't comment on it because, you know, who cares? > Diet is considerably more complex than "X number of atoms enter the body through the oral cavity". You're right that it's not worth arguing about, because you're yet another person who says "they just didn't do it right" - something of a No True Scotsman. Nobody doubts that a dietary deficiency can cause illness, but a dietary deficiency that can only be addressed by eating meat would be a genuinely strange thing, and you haven't even tried to identify it. This is absolutely not about the women you are interested in, it's about the science of human nutrition.