7 ms·
I really do not understand how people can stand to eat meat. I try not to be sanctimonious about it but the idea of eating animals has put me off since I grew
by ck2 14y ago
I really do not understand how people can stand to eat meat.
I try not to be sanctimonious about it but the idea of eating animals has put me off since I grew conscious as a teenager. I don't even consider myself vegetarian, I drink milk and eat products that have eggs (not eggs directly)
Just the smell of meat turns my stomach.
I assure you, it's very possible to live a well-fed life without any meat.
- beedogs 14y agoPossible, maybe. Delicious? Certainly not.
- enraged_camel 14y ago>>I really do not understand how people can stand to eat meat. You realize we're omnivores and evolved to eat both meat and vegetables, right? This is not to say that everyone MUST eat meat. But you have to understand that finding meat delicious is pretty much the default evolutionary state of human beings.
- ck2 14y agoYes but it's easy as creatures with intelligence, to realize other creatures think and feel, for us to stop that consumption. There are MANY things our animal cousins do that we do not do, because we can think. I don't have any fantasies that meat consumption will disappear entirely, I'd just like to see it go down as society evolves, just like slowly increasing the mpg requirements for cars cuts fuel use dramatically over time. If meat consumption was cut in half, maybe we'd have the time, money and resources to treat livestock much better.
- HaloZero 14y agoAnother bigger problem is cultural norms, that moment where your the only vegetarian at a table sucks because now sharing food with friends / SO become so much harder. I mean obviously less of an issue when you cook at home but still.
- lostlogin 14y agoI've been vegetarian all my life, 31 years. It's been a problem probably once or twice. People always expect it to be difficult, but it just isn't. The only part about it I don't like is the 60 something year old, usually male, who pops up about once a year to make lame jokes that usually somehow relate being vegetarian to being effeminate, homosexual or some such thing. And seem to think its hilarious bringing it into conversation as much as possible. This is by far the most annoying thing. I have travelled through a fair few countries and have never found it to be problematic - and I have been prepared to compromise being veetarian if it would have been rude not to when in foreign countries. I have never had to however.
- mturmon 14y agoYou have a point. I'm almost completely vegetarian (for ~20 years) and I try to avoid the issue, even if engaged about it, especially at mealtime. It leads to conversations where people argumentatively try to find logical contradictions in my decisions. It's tiresome, because I can tell where it's headed before they even start ("But, is your belt leather?") It seems more like they are trying to justify their own behaviors (which are even less well-grounded than mine), than to have a civil exchange of ideas. And it happens not just with older males, but "logical" nerds as well (of all ages). ("Homo sapiens have evolved to be omnivores." -- gosh, I never thought of that before!)
- paulnechifor 14y agoEveryone knows animals think and feel, but that's no reason not to deny our need to eat animals. I think animal cruelty is bad because it shows disregard and they have a propensity to do the same to people. But I think it's ridiculous to have an equivalent level of empathy for people and animals. Your over-concern with animals and enlightenment as a teenager is only made possible by the advanced state of our civilization.
- chc 14y ago> But I think it's ridiculous to have an equivalent level of empathy for people and animals. "An equivalent level of empathy"? Do you really think that a person whose empathy for human beings stops at "I shouldn't kill and eat them" would be considered highly ethical? You might not agree with vegetarians' ideology, but I don't think they are exactly setting a very high bar.
- jlgreco 14y agoIf we are accepting that animals and humans are generally treated differently (i.e., without equivalent levels of empathy), why should it be surprising that for some people that difference works out such that eating animals is okay?
- raphman 14y agoWe are treating humans differently, too. I love my children more than someone I meet on the streets. Generally, our society considers it still ethically ok to have different amounts of empathy for different people and treat them differently. However, there are some things that are absolutely not ok for humans to do: kill someone, eat them, etc. To me, treating animals differently than humans in general does not logically imply that killing them is ok.
- jlgreco 14y ago> We are treating humans differently, too. Absolutely. Anyone who suggests that vegetarians treat animals an humans the same is just being inflammatory. That clearly is not the case. > To me, treating animals differently than humans in general does not logically imply that killing them is ok. Of course, you are absolutely correct. Similarly, having empathy for animals / treating animals ethically does not logically imply that killing them is not okay. For some people it means exactly that, and for others it does not.
- beeffective 14y agoI realize other creates think and feel, but I have great appreciation for the meat I take on my own whenever I shoot a deer, elk or turkey. I gutted, skinned and butchered my first deer that I hunted because I wanted to better learn and appreciate the adventure, process and amount of food I then acquired. There is a writer/hunter who better explains what I'm trying to say, and he currently hosts The Meat Eater on Sportsman's channel (he also host the Wild Within on A&E for one season). Here is a short debate he had with a vegan, warning: it's a very level-headed and rational dialogue: http://youtu.be/J2N0Utg7KYE http://youtu.be/J2N0Utg7KYE
- mitchi 14y agoThis. I am 80 % vegetarian. I eat beans/pasta/rice and other vegetables for most of my calories. I love it and it's healthy and cheap, 2 things I like. With good diet publicity and low prices on key foods, this kind of diet should become attractive to more people...
- UntitledNo4 14y agoI call myself a flexitarian. It's even in the dictionary http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/flexitarian http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/flexitarian
- jlgreco 14y agoThere is a difference between knowing that animals think and feel, and caring that animals think and feel. I'm not trying to be funny here, I honestly don't care. Eating things that taste good is more important to me. Different people have different values, go figure.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- eurleif 14y agoSo if you found out people taste good?
- jlgreco 14y agoFrom the accounts I have read, I assume that they do. What is your point?
- eurleif 14y agoMy point is that I hope you don't find out where I live, because I don't want to be eaten. Also, that if you ever say it's wrong for anyone to murder anyone else, you'll be a hypocrite.
- jlgreco 14y agoDon't worry, I lack the desire to eat humans and would not do so even if I had the desire. Remember that thing I said about different people having different values? Well (although I suspect it may seem odd to you) I place more value in humans than I do in other animals. Kind of like how I place more value in family members than friends, and more value in friends than strangers. Although "because I want to" is sufficient justification for me to eat a non-human animal, it is not sufficient for me to eat a human. In my value system a strong necessity, not merely desire, would be required for me to do that. (Incidentally, the strength of the necessity required would be different for family, friends, and strangers...) None of this should be surprising to you, unless either you honestly thing that omnivores don't realize that animals can feel things, or honestly think that omnivores are all casual cannibals... both clearly absurd things to think.
- philwelch 14y agoMost animals would eat us, given the choice.
- ck2 14y agoMost animals will breed with their siblings left to their own. What is your argument? That we should always follow animal behavior despite our ability to think?
- philwelch 14y agoThe entire basis of morality is that we're capable of reciprocating our moral duties to each other. Animals can't reciprocate, therefore they're exempt from morality and we're exempt from giving them any moral consideration.
- Evbn 14y agoSuch as Cows? Pigs? Chickens? Ducks? Sheep? Goats? Horses? Fish?
- philwelch 14y agoSupposedly, pigs are a good way to dispose of a dead body.
- vacri 14y agoNot for everyone. I know of two women who were both long-term vegetarians and went back to an omnivorous diet because they were always feeling wan and listless. Both women were foodies (one from a 'foodie' family), and both have tertiary education in biology and biochemistry, so they were quite aware of good diets and balancing. This doesn't mean that all women will have this problem, it just means that not everyone can go meat-free and have no quality-of-life issues.
- gordaco 14y agoThis. One of the things about vegetarian diets that rarely gets mentioned is that there are people whose body really profits from meat, while others' don't so much (this is why you get a lot of anecdotes like yours, but also a lot of people for which vegetarian diets do wonders). I read somewhere that it may be related to blood type, but I'm not sure about that, and certainly IANA biologist.
- justin66 14y ago> This doesn't mean that all women will have this problem, it just means that not everyone can go meat-free and have no quality-of-life issues. What it really means is that anecdotes aren't data. Kidding! What it REALLY means is that "tertiary education in biology" causes listlessness.
- vacri 14y agoUsually when I tell that story, almost always the first response is "she just doesn't understand food/how to balance a diet". It's tedious. As for 'anecdotes aren't data' - when blanket statements are made, you only need anecdotes to show that there are exceptions. I also notice you never bothered with the mocking 'anecdotes aren't data' against the parent comment, which is all anecdote and triggered much more in the way of reply.
- justin66 14y agoThe closest the person you were responding to came to making a blanket assertion was "I assure you, it's very possible to live a well-fed life without any meat." Which is kind of trivially true, since many people live "well-fed" (whatever that means) lives without meat. If the person had made the stronger claim "all people can live a well-fed life without any meat" your objection might be more compelling. Although still wrong. > Usually when I tell that story, almost always the first response is "she just doesn't understand food/how to balance a diet". It's tedious. And, if her "listlessness" was corrected by changing her diet, that statement was kind of trivially true, in addition to being tedious, no? (By the way, this would be a better story if you knew more about why the change caused the improvement.) The claim that whatever dietary deficiency these women were (possibly) suffering as vegetarians could only be corrected by eating meat is a pretty bold one, since there aren't any known vitamins, minerals, aminos, etc. that aren't available without eating meat. Since you haven't even identified the deficiency it's not even worth arguing about. Also, food for thought, it's certainly possible the dietary change to eating a meat-based diet REMOVED something they shouldn't have been getting. If they were eating too much wheat as vegetarians and had gluten intolerance, for example.
- mark_l_watson 14y agoMy wife and I take an in-between approach to this: we eat small amounts of fish and are otherwise vegetarians. This makes in easy to get enough protein (you have to work a little to get enough protein with vegetarian or vegan diets) and we can avoid eating animals that like it when you scratch them behind their ears.
- heelhook 14y agoThat's a very common misbelief, getting protein as a vegetarian is not hard really, particularly if you have soy or quinoa in your diet, the latter being the preferable option. Cooking quinoa with kombu is delicious, super easy and can yield a wide variety of dishes.
- Evbn 14y agoQuinoa is destroying the Peruvian economy due to political problems. Soy gets unhealthy inarge quantities. Mix in some nuts and beans and seitan.
- jadyoyster 14y agoI agree that for most lifestyles getting enough protein as a vegetarian or vegan isn't hard. However, why would you suggest something exotic like quinoa instead of lentils and beans which have been used as a source of protein for millenia? I've never understood the exotic ingredient or 'superfood' fetishism in vegetarian diets.
- heelhook 14y agoExotic? Really? Hmmm, I don't really seem them as exotic, I (now) find quinoa in regular supermarkets. Obviously I wasn't proposing basing a vegetarian diet after only soy and quinoa, I was just naming a couple of examples of protein rich foods.
- rjzzleep 14y agowell, first of all meat used to be different. the us has really created one mad food culture, and has been pushing it - quite efficiently - globally. second, people tend to replace meat with soy. can you even imagine how horrible soy mass plantations are for the environment? do you even know how many organisms get cleansed when gmo crops are used? when I was in highschool, that's now over 12 years ago, there was a huge problem with land literally dying from the way it's being farmed. that problem has only got worse.
- shasta 14y agoI can understand vegetarians who boycott meat because the animals are being treated inhumanely in captivity. But in my ethics, killing an animal quickly isn't inhumane. It's not like the other cows sit around all day worried about whether Bessy's fate could befall them.
- heelhook 14y agoSo by that rationale I take it is ok to kill lonely people too? What about animals that do remember their dead relatives (e.g. elephants)?
- hmsimha 14y agoAlso, along those same lines, is your only consideration for the murder (not trying to use an incendiary word, just not sure how to phrase this more delicately) of an animal the distress it would cause others (animals/people)? So for example, if a dog's owners die, then just put down the dog? Or should euthanasia be viewed as the unsavory last resort due to an inability to care for the burgeoning population of dogs?
- grecy 14y agoYou made a mistake. What you meant to say was: > I really do not understand how people can stand to factory farmed meat. Not all meat comes from those hell-holes in the vidoes, and not all animals die in such horrible ways. Open your eyes, learn about alternatives. (For one example, I live in a place that has twice as many moose as people, and I hunt every year, filling my freezer with organic, ethically killed, sustainable, local meat)
- raphman 14y agoIt might be that the parent actually meant what they said. While I agree with you in general, your comment implies that you know better than the parent what is ethical with regard to eating meat.
- boon 14y agoThis isn't in direct response to you, but more so a resource for anyone that happens to be reading this thread. A good blog on the ethics and nutrition of meat-eating. http://letthemeatmeat.com/ http://letthemeatmeat.com/