3 ms·
Lets be clear, if you don't like animal abuse don't eat animals. Murder is worse than abuse. These videos in essence are propaganda tools and I see little val
by aaron695 14y ago
Lets be clear, if you don't like animal abuse don't eat animals.
Murder is worse than abuse.
These videos in essence are propaganda tools and I see little value in the so called animal rights movement that promotes clean killing as an ethical good.
But at the end of the day there should be free speech no matter whether it's right or wrong or for good or evil.
- username111 14y agoThere is a huge difference between clean kill slaughter and animal abuse then slaughter if we are going to agree that animals can feel (which they most certainly can).
- jlcx 14y agoI don't think that the "animal rights" movement "promotes clean killing as an ethical good". Sometimes these videos are released with the intent of persuading people to stop consuming meat (and perhaps even eggs and dairy). But even if the videos are only intended to change certain abusive practices within the meat industry, I think many people would agree that abuse followed by killing is worse than killing alone.
- lilsunnybee 14y agoThe composition of beliefs in the animal rights movement varies quite a bit. There are some that believe all killing of animals is wrong. But there are a greater number that believe the suffering inflicted by cruelty and careless farming methods is the only evil here. Some organizations are entirely devoted only to stopping cruel practices. Some of these people might be against eating meat entirely too, but only because they believe factory farming and cruelty is an inevitability for the mass production of meat. Movements are inevitably made up of many different kinds of people with varying motives. There are always going to be radicals (like many with PETA), but the majority often have reasonable arguments and concerns.
- glesica 14y agoSo if you eat meat you can't be against pit bull-fighting? That seems like a pretty bad philosophy to me. Extrapolate it further, we shouldn't, then, be more appalled by a gruesome murder (of a human) than a gunshot to the back of the head. Since that is untrue for virtually everyone, you either have to claim that nearly every human on earth is a logically inconsistent dunce, or perhaps there is, in fact, a violence gradient of some sort.
- aaron695 14y ago> So if you eat meat you can't be against pit bull-fighting? Correct? Well you can but you'd be a bigot thinking you're beliefs are better than someone else's. >Extrapolate it further, we shouldn't, then, be more appalled by a gruesome murder (of a human) than a gunshot to the back of the head. Correct. Again a no brainer. There is however evidence that a person who commits a gruesome crime might be more likely to re-offend. This should be taken into account for sentencing/rehabilitation. But no, you should not be more 'appalled' > Since that is untrue for virtually everyone, you either have to claim that nearly every human on earth is a logically inconsistent dunce, or perhaps there is, in fact, a violence gradient of some sort. ??? Do I even need to answer that? 80% of India is Hindu. 80% of America is Christian. You think people aren't logically inconsistent?
- glesica 14y agoAt some point you have to ask yourself if it's more likely that everyone else in the entire world is crazy, or that you might be mistaken. People are not shocked by horrible crimes because of the likelihood of re-offense. They are shocked by horrible crimes because there are things worse than simple murder, at least to most people. The idea that every murder is completely equal in every way is just plain silly. Torturing someone to death is worse than shooting them in the back of the head. Rape-and-murder is worse than murder. These are things that most people can see pretty clearly. Here's why: just ask yourself which you would prefer to have happen to you (assume that you won't be able to escape your fate no matter what happens). I'd take the bullet every single time, and there's a reason for that.
- k88 14y ago