2 ms·
I'd probably go with no, at least in this case and how it was done. While dens can certainly take it, I don't see any way this was designed to "help" him, or r
by rdl 14y ago
I'd probably go with no, at least in this case and how it was done.
While dens can certainly take it, I don't see any way this was designed to "help" him, or really do anything but be a cheap and mean way to earn buzz for Keith.
Keith managed to eke out a successful "Hail Mary Bebo-style outcome" from Slide, so there's some hypocrisy here, too.
It's fair to criticize someone for doing something wrong when you could probably fix it (e.g. I think Refer.ly was doing it wrong in paying small amounts of money to contributors, and I told dmor this repeatedly and made comments to that effect; I cared because it seems like an awesome team who will do awesome other things). It's not really fair to criticize someone who can't fix things (e.g. telling a 2 year old that his painting sucks because the sky is not yellow), or where there's no real way to fix things (e.g. I know a company where the CTO suffered a skiing accident and major TBI, telling the CEO that they are probably fucked is not so helpful).
- samstave 14y agoCouple thoughts; First, I can't recall myself ever seeing PG admonish or otherwise belittle in any way any YC alum company. Or any others for that matter (not that i stalk comments from PG - I have just never seen anything come out as negative) In fact, when YC invested in iCracked, and I personally said that I was confused in this and thought it was weird (among other things) - PG defended their belief in iCracked... I think that PG/YC does an amazing job of participating in the discussion about the startup scene without doing any of the following: over-hype, flame wars, arrogance, [insert-adjective] I think that Keith should look back on his recent leaving of Square and how the startup community supported him and have a little more grace. He may have started that tweet-flame with a joke - but he dug a-hole for himself as well. Its hard to be sympathetic to him when, in just a few short weeks after his personal calamity, where many supported him, he just comes out looking like a dick. VCs should be truthful, but should refrain from posting to the internet whilst drunk.