3 ms·
> Scraping together a suicide team and shooting it roughly in Mars' general direction is not the answer to this problem. I think you misunderstand. While the
by saalweachter 14y ago
> Scraping together a suicide team and shooting it roughly in Mars' general direction is not the answer to this problem.
I think you misunderstand. While the linked article is brief, the one-way plan isn't to send a ship-full of people with suicide pills, but to supply them for the next 40-80 years from Earth.
Because of the hilarities of the rocket equation, it is cheaper to send rocket after rocket full of water, breathable air, food, fuel, and other supplies than it is to send enough rocket fuel for a return trip. Like, way cheaper. As the article says, the technology for a return trip just doesn't exist; the technology for a series of one-way trips does.
- Udo 14y ago> the one-way plan isn't to send a ship-full of people with suicide pills Maybe I got caught up in the ridiculousness of the article's sensational tone, but even so there is no technical reason to actually plan on never having return flights. This relates directly to your other statement: As I wrote in the parent comment, the presence of water on Mars allows for the production of rocket fuel on site. This ties in to where I mentioned extended infrastructure such as a space elevator and a Moon base, because those too will make trips back and forth economical (instead of scraping everything together for a singular "by the skin of our teeth" mission like this one). I wrote about these points for a reason ;)
- ams6110 14y agoWhile perhaps a return may some day be possible, the point is people are being recruited without that promise. So that, e.g. they realize that if they get sick, or seriously injured, or even just change their mind, there is no way to get back.
- greyfade 14y ago> As the article says, the technology for a return trip just doesn't exist; the technology for a series of one-way trips does. Implying that we won't come up with that technology by the time we get people there.
- GhotiFish 14y agoWell. No he wasn't. There's also a real possibility that the technology doesn't exist. There's an even greater possibility that it does, and we arn't capable of comprehending it.
- danielweber 14y ago> send enough rocket fuel for a return trip That hasn't been the plan for a long time. NASA's Design Reference Mission, and the one anyone who has studied Mars missions at any point in the past 20 years, is to manufacture fuel on Mars. In fact, you would probably send this equipment to Mars first so that the astronauts going to Mars would have a fully fueled return ship ready and waiting for them before they even take off from Earth.
- derekp7 14y agoThe only problem with that is we would have to get a lot better at building rockets first. Currently it seems to take a fairly large crew (and clean rooms and a lot of care) to get a successful launch off earth, and even then there are often glitches. Getting the Moon lander to launch from the moon surface was easier due to lower gravity and no atmosphere. But I can't imagine a rocket on Mars sitting there for a couple years with an automatic fueling station, and having it launch successfully after getting battered by dust storms and any other corrosives present on Mars.