3 ms·
I'd support an unbiased and scientific study, but I don't think this is likely to be one, nor would anything the CDC/NIH funds be likely to be. The only fundin
by rdl 14y ago
I'd support an unbiased and scientific study, but I don't think this is likely to be one, nor would anything the CDC/NIH funds be likely to be.
The only funding source I could imagine being impartial would be either a large organization with balanced pro and anti gun agenda (say, the US Military -- it has a pro-gun agenda due to interests of members and mission, but is very safety conscious and runs the world's largest school system as well.) Or maybe taking equal amounts of money from a pro gun group and an anti gun group and giving it to a fairly independent researcher with no ongoing ties to the organizations.
- piasen 14y agoI love the idea of taking equal amounts of money from pro and anti gun groups :) The 'look' on the page is a work-in-progress, as a scientist I have no experience with crowdfunding and am trying to find the right 'balance' between making my page as dry as an academic research proposal, and something catchy enough that would interest the non-academic. Howver, even if you suspect I am biased, it would be extremely bad for my career to do biased or bad research (all the data we will use is secondary, and we will be sharing a great deal of it it on this site too -- so anyone with good statistical skills can double-check my findings). At the end of the day, my research will have to stand up to scrutiny both in peer-reviewed journals and other scientists who want to 'double check' my results.
- rdl 14y agoConvinced me; I just contributed $10.
- rdl 14y agoYou should probably contact Jim Pitkow (part of Ron Conway's gun violence thing); they would probably contribute funding, since "lack of good studies" was one of their major findings. The questions I'd really like to see answered are exploring specific current regulations for effectiveness as well as proposed regulations. i.e. I'd like to see if suppressors have ever been meaningfully used in crime, or if striking them from NFA would have limited crime-increase effects. And if some of the other fairly irrational regulations (parts of US origin requirements under 922(r) for imported non-sporting firearms) make any difference to crime. Or California's .50bmg ban.
- rdl 14y agoAlthough arguably a crowdfunded study has a lot better odds of being impartial than most other ongoing funding sources, so maybe this has a chance.