6 ms·
Obama to announce $2 billion plan to get US cars off gasoline
- jeffehobbs 14y agoThis is great news and a worthy cause. Our dependence on oil and gasoline create a raft of other problems. Sooner the better.
- jack9 14y agoHow short is our memory? To paraphrase Slashdot comment#43193173 His fisrt term he put $80 Billion towards this. You won't remember great hits like Solendra, A123, and Fisker. The list of companies getting the money from that original program read like a whos-who of campaign donors. Many of the companies went bankrupt quickly after getting the federal money and none of them produced anything usable. The track record is this will be a slush fund to reward his friends and accomplish nothing useful. Corrupt politics and corporate cronyism at its finest.
- frozenport 14y agoI certainly support research, but isn't there a sequester looming? I would be happier if Obama took steps to raise taxes. At the place I work we lost an employee due to grant shortages.
- mkr-hn 14y agoThe President doesn't set taxes. That's the job of congress, which is designed to make changing things hard. Obama can call for this and that, but all it takes is one senator to shut the whole process down.
- sultezdukes 14y agoI'd be happier if Obama would take steps to lower taxes.
- pandaman 14y agoIf you are unhappy with your taxes being too low you can always write a check to the IRS for whatever sum you believe you are underpaying.
- larrywright 14y agoI'm not sure why you're being downvoted, your point is legitimate.
- enraged_camel 14y agoHe's being downvoted because his comment is extremely asinine. One person paying more than their share won't do anything, even if they are a billionaire.
- spikels 14y agoIt would be pretty cool if those who both could and wanted to contribute just did - like how open source software works. In practice taxes end up being pretty arbitrary and have unintended consequences. Lots of people actually agree with increased spending such as this and could easily fund these efforts. Those who don't agree could keep their money. Win-win!
- pandaman 14y agoFrom what I understand (and I may be wrong because people who are advocating rising taxes are not very good at explaining their position), the idea is not to increase government income/spending per se. The idea is to redistribute wealth and the government's income is irrelevant (hence the GP's saying it "won't do anything" despite the obvious increase of this income). For all we know a tax increase may decrease the total money collected by the government as the wealthy flee into more favorable tax regimes. This is all right from the point of wealth redistribution (it happens anyways as the local wealth decreases even through different means) but would be unacceptable from the income/spending point of view.
- chanced 14y ago>> I certainly support research, but isn't there a sequester looming Looming? No. It has already taken affect. >> I would be happier if Obama took steps to raise taxes. Do tell, what steps would you have him take? The Republicans have sworn to not raise taxes at all. They control the house and have unleashed a record smashing set of filibusters (and no, not the Rand Paul style) in the senate. Thanks to gerrymandering, they can (and must) hold stedfast to ideologues. There's also the corporate interests to look after. >> At the place I work we lost an employee due to grant shortages. Classic. You want taxes to be raised so your employment can be safeguarded. Meanwhile the grants, and jobs in turn, are a waste of time and energy.
- frozenport 14y agoI get paid less then half what I would make working in industry. My hope is that I can continue my work developing new materials.
- ams6110 14y agoWeaning the nation off fossil fuels entirely for its transportation needs may not be practical or realistic. Reality never stopped a good government money grab before, why should it now? Sarcasm aside, the idea is of course ridiculous. If/when viable alternatives to petroleum fuels are available, the transition will happen. Companies like Tesla and every major automobile manufacturer have R&D going on in this area right now. Grabbing $2 billion via a new tax on oil production will do nothing to further that, however. Look at results of similar "stimulus" spending a few years ago.
- toomuchtodo 14y agoI guess DARPA is pretty ridiculous too, right? What have they ever come up with, what with their tax money grab and all? In all seriousness, you're not helping. At all. Clearly R&D is doing well, but battery and other component prices are too high, while oil consumption has huge externalities that no one is ever forced to pay for. So yes, we're going to tax oil and pour the money into electrification of transportation. Get over it.
- waterlesscloud 14y ago"Get over it." This is helping? This is how you play into the politics of division. It's also how you make enemies and not get what you want as a result. Don't play the combative divisiveness game. It's for suckers. It serves the politicians, it doesn't serve you.
- hideo 14y agoofftopic: "Don't play the combative divisiveness game. It's for suckers. It serves the politicians, it doesn't serve you." I wish someone would say this every time people start yelling at each other over political decision.
- toomuchtodo 14y agoI want to live in a world where conversations can be had, where we can all sit down as a species and say, "Yes, this is what we want" or "no, we're going to pass on this." Unfortunately, there will always be people you will be unable to win over, unable to change their mind, even if the proper direction is a known. What then? We continue to argue? Forever tied in discussions without any forward progress? The downsides of petroleum are clear. Its polluting, its limited, and we fight regional (check that, global) conflicts over it. Electricity is cheap, it's price is dropping quickly as more capacity comes online (solar, wind, natural gas where fracking is occurring), and its able to be moved across wide geographic areas extremely quickly. There is no reason oil shouldn't be taxed and those funds driven directly into renewables and electrified mobility. Now, if you want to argue with me on facts, I am all ears. But until someone can prove we're not running out of oil, prove that we don't need a military to patrol the regions we extract that oil from, and prove that our economy can continue to function with a cartel controlling the literal fuel of the world economies, get the hell out of the way.
- rayiner 14y ago$2 billion won't buy jack shit in the way of R&D on a problem like this.
- Daniel_Newby 14y ago$2 billion represents about 10,000 man-years of effort by scientists and engineers. That's a lot if it is focussed well.
- dmix 14y ago60-70% of that will go to bureaucratic overhead before it gets to the engineers and scientists.
- overloaded 14y ago[citation needed]
- just2n 14y agoDoes the past 100 years count?
- potatolicious 14y agoThat's cynical snark, not a citation.
- just2n 14y agoAw, I was hoping you wouldn't notice! :)
- loup-vaillant 14y agoEven so, do you know of any method which would have less overhead?
- dj2stein9 14y ago$700 Billion for banks. $2 Billion to convert all cars to electric. Something smells fishy here.
- mesozoic 14y ago$700 billion to invade and control foreign countries, "offense" spending. $2 billion to reduce our reliance on oil sounds legit. I bet the military spends more than $2 billion annually on oil themselves.
- ihsw 14y agoInvading and controlling foreign countries costs far more than $700B, we've been doing it for over half a century and it's a few dozen trillion dollars so far.
- mackem 14y agoWhat could possibly go wrong? Oh I know, like the last time government pumped massive amounts of money into biofuels and there was a massive food crisis in the 3rd world due to rocketing food prices which was caused by the government buying up massive amounts of corn for ethanol fuel.
- hga 14y agoIndeed; there's absolutely nothing new here for those of us who lived through the '70s, e.g.: http://www.csmonitor.com/1980/0701/070114.html http://www.csmonitor.com/1980/0701/070114.html
- thatswrong0 14y agoI guess I just don't seem the point. Car manufacturers already see that this is the way to go, which is why we are seeing more electric cars / hybrids from car companies. If the government really wanted to get cars off gasoline, why not raise the gas tax and stop the corn subsidies first? Higher (visible) prices for gasoline would push people toward smaller more energy efficient cars and public transit and it would make people pay for the externalities. Oh yeah.. that's politically unpalatable.