3 ms·
> Google certainly aren't as evil as 1990's era MS... I don't agree. I think that Google is in the same level of evilness (or will be very soon). They just re
by wslh 14y ago
> Google certainly aren't as evil as 1990's era MS...
I don't agree. I think that Google is in the same level of evilness (or will be very soon).
They just released tons of code because it is not where they are making money. But they release their search engine code? The game rules are so obvious now (not only for Google) that it is incredible that we try to think about them in an ethical way. They do things, if they have a power position they shift they change the rules to maintain that power. Do you know how many times a Google Search API was deprecated?
http://blog.databigbang.com/google-search-no-api/ http://blog.databigbang.com/google-search-no-api/
Another argument that I reuse every time when people compare Microsoft to Google is that you could always reverse engineered software on your machine but on The Cloud you have lost those hacker rights. You can't reverse engineer web APIs. You can build a search engine yourself but your pagerank algorithm will not be the same. More food for thought http://blog.nektra.com/main/2012/06/01/reverse-engineering-and-the-cloud/ http://blog.nektra.com/main/2012/06/01/reverse-engineering-a...
- wslh 14y agoNowadays few people on HN downvote without arguing.
- wslh 14y agoAgain. Downvoters must lose some of its karma like in SO.
- rbanffy 14y ago> But they release their search engine code? There is nothing unethical in not opening your competitive advantages. Besides that, you don't have a hundred thousand machines to run it on. > You can build a search engine yourself but your pagerank algorithm will not be the same You can base yours on the published paper. I suppose it would be as good as Bing. > you could always reverse engineered software on your machine And be patent trolled out of existence if you ever used it.
- wslh 14y ago> And be patent trolled out of existence if you ever used it. No, reverse engineering is legal, and projects like Samba or my company full reversing (4 products) of closed source Microsoft projects hasn't be sued. More on that: we have been contacted by Microsoft if we need something special that they can test for compliant on newer operating systems. Try the same web scraping the google search engine (something more "benign" and they will show you a page saying that you can't automate the search process.
- rbanffy 14y agoThe only thing that prevents Microsoft from suing you is their belief you do not harm their business. And by scraping Google search results you are using their servers.
- wslh 14y ago> There is nothing unethical in not opening your competitive advantages. Besides that, you don't have a hundred thousand machines to run it on. You are quoting me out of context. My whole point was about the idea of Google being more benign than Microsoft in the 90s.
- mindslight 14y ago> There is nothing unethical in not opening your competitive advantages So 90's Microsoft fit your ethics? Their competitive advantages being control of de-facto standard OS, file formats, etc ? How quickly we relax after we've won the battle. I'm more scared of the worlds Google and Apple want to create than what Microsoft was doing (with the exception of the TPM).
- rbanffy 14y ago> So 90's Microsoft fit your ethics? No. Engaging in monopoly abuse and anti-competitive practices is unethical. And illegal.
- wslh 14y ago>> You can build a search engine yourself but your pagerank algorithm will not be the same > You can base yours on the published paper. I suppose it would be as good as Bing. Again out of context. The point of the criticism was: if the page rank is running on a machine where you have the control you can reverse engineer it. If in 20 years Google decide that driverless cars with ads are the future and their search engine must be closed you loose your good search results (like we lost Google Reader BTW). In the Microsoft case I can always run Windows 3.1. My company even helped virtualize Internet Explorer 6 on Microsoft Windows 7 natively! ps1: answering your reply, I just realized why Google is building driverless cars! ps2: I am not a Microsoft fan.