5 ms·
Nice sympathy piece full of heartstring-tugging stories of rural Americana. But... Want to send a letter to Talkeetna, Alaska, from New York? It will cost you
by ams6110 14y ago
Nice sympathy piece full of heartstring-tugging stories of rural Americana. But...
Want to send a letter to Talkeetna, Alaska, from New York? It will cost you fifty dollars by UPS.
That's because it's thousands of miles away and freaking in the middle of NOWHERE. Why, rationally, should it cost the same as sending a letter across town?
- nbouscal 14y agoBecause people should be able to send things through the mail affordably regardless of where they live. That is a value that we used to hold as a country. Admittedly, that was back when at least a few of us actually viewed ourselves cohesively and cared about people other than ourselves.
- yummyfajitas 14y agoWhy should mail delivery cost the same everywhere, unlike everything else? Why shouldn't people in Alaska subsidize my manhattan rent? What (besides status quo bias) makes mail special?
- skore 14y agoThere are things that make sense to socialize, others - not so much. Conjuring up a weird one that makes little sense isn't a proper argument, it's a straw man. Being able to send mail is a basic skill required to participate in society - tons of democratic rights (voting by mail if you're disabled comes to mind) can be exercised through mail. Furthermore, being able to receive mail is just as important. We are a society that still has a lot of its fundamentals build on the exchange of physical documents. Sure, it is starting to be more economical in some instances to do that electronically, but that doesn't change the fundamental fact behind the idea. There was a time when fresh water and, later, electricity were an outlandish commodity to have always ready in your household. At some point, society has made the decision that they should be a basic human right (although that depends on where you live - in some parts, there is a weird quasi-privatization going on that I find absurd). Finally, it makes sense. If you have a thousand letters and 90% of them cost 10 cents to deliver while the other 10% cost 100 cents to deliver, that means the total cost are 19000 cents. An average of 19 cents per letter. The question is: Would the people who would have to pay 10 cents actually care about paying 9 cents extra? Do they care that much that it outweighs the burden that is put on the 100-cent people? Put differently: Is the happiness and relief that the 100-cent people feel worth more than the minor grudge that the 10-cent people feel? I think that is the case. It improves society to do economically sensible things like we do them. And that is why some commodities are "socialized" and others are not.
- yummyfajitas 14y agoIf receiving mail is a basic skill, then so is having a mailing address. Thus, Alaskans should subsidiz my rent. As for your arguments about subjective feelIngs, if the minor grudge people feel when they are forced to pay for video games is smaller than the enjoyment gamers gain, should the government force non-gamers to subsidize gamers? If not, why not?
- nawitus 14y agoDo you agree that some things should be subsidized/socialized?
- yummyfajitas 14y agoYes - public goods. Even some private goods where irrational behavior might lead to them being under provisioned. I am generally an economic utilitarian. I just can't see any utility gain from subsidizing rural folks.
- nawitus 14y agoNote that this subsidizion can be a private, capitalist decision too. At least the package and mail carriers in my country do not charge by the mile, they charge by weight, so this is probably a non-issue.
- skore 14y ago> I just can't see any utility gain from subsidizing rural folks. Ah, so it's "government subsidy" and you have a hard time imagining how that is good for society. Understood, you really are trolling.
- mkr-hn 14y agoI like not having to grow my own food. And I think rural people appreciate all the technology and media, enabled by population density, that we send their way. It's a nice symbiotic relationship. This will probably continue to be the case until someone figures out how to make vertical farming competitive.
- benaiah 14y agoHey! I lived in Talkeetna! ...and you're completely right. It is in the middle of freaking nowhere. Back on topic, I think you're right (despite the fact that it would make letters much more expensive where I live). There's no reason why someone in New York sending a letter to their friend in Albany should have to subsidize my 6-year-old self sending a letter to Idaho. That said, if they allowed competition, I would have far less of a problem, as the New York->Albany people could just go with another option. I'm not sure the post office could survive competition, but I don't really care - IMO, it's fundamentally economically unsound to prohibit competition in the marketplace (with a reasonable view of what the marketplace actually is).
- mgkimsal 14y agoAnd then when some areas have their postal companies close up shop altogether... they're screwed? Having some basic level of services available in rural areas can help encourage growth and small businesses in those areas. Removing them will certainly hurt chances of starting or expanding - fewer employees, fewer customers, etc.
- skylan_q 14y agoThat's because it's thousands of miles away and freaking in the middle of NOWHERE. Why, rationally, should it cost the same as sending a letter across town? That was the point of it; to socialize the cost of mail delivery. Now why would we want to be doing that in this day and age? I don't know...
- nbouscal 14y agoWhat does this day and age have to do with it? Things still need to get from one place to another. It is still a laudable goal to have the cost of that process be socialized; that aspect has not changed. Yes, many things have gone digital, but that does not change the underlying nature of the mail, nor does it invalidate the way we should be thinking about it as a society.
- tsotha 14y ago>It is still a laudable goal to have the cost of that process be socialized; that aspect has not changed. Why? I don't see any reason I should be subsidizing other peoples' chosen lifestyles. They have the option of moving to a more populated area.
- mgkimsal 14y agoBecause you're getting subsidized as well. When there are natural disasters in larger areas, money from poorer areas is used to help clean up. The cost of the roads to and from your more populated area is split/shared with road costs in less populated areas. And so on...
- tsotha 14y agoSure, if you want to talk about single line items. But if you look at the total rural people are heavily subsided by the rest of us. It's not just mail. It's mail. It's roads. It's electricity. It's airports. Hospitals. Internet service...
- dinkumthinkum 14y ago