6 ms·
Money in the bank is not your money anymore. By the time of credit cards, banks moved from being a custodian of money, to a service provider that can cut anyone
by belorn 14y ago
Money in the bank is not your money anymore. By the time of credit cards, banks moved from being a custodian of money, to a service provider that can cut anyone off from their service.
Sure, this time it was not the banks itself but rather the government that did this, but they could only do this because banks and government has stopped seeing money in the bank as belonging to the person who put it there. They would have never gone to a farmer and taken 10% of their grain. They would have never gone and taken physical property in peoples home. That would had been an complete impossibility. I even strongly doubt that any safety deposit boxes will be effect by this.
I understand the idea that this is a blow against companies that are using Cyprus as an tax haven. Its fully understandable. But I really dislike this current system of treating money in the bank as belonging to the bank. This story is just a clear example of this behavior expanding further.
- InclinedPlane 14y agoThere's no such thing as an intrinsic value for "money", even in gold. If you keep your money in the form of dollars (or Euros) shoved into a mattress the value can go away through inflation. If you keep your money in the form of gold bars the value can also go away through inflation, but perhaps less so.
- rtwtlkj 14y agoI thought gold went up with inflation.
- dmiladinov 14y agoThe only way for gold to inflate is for someone to dig up more gold, thereby increasing its supply.
- Gormo 14y agoInflation is when the money supply increases in relation to the real wealth that it represents, not when the money supply increases in absolute terms.
- mcantelon 14y agoGold's value in fiat currency goes up with the fiat currency's inflation.
- jpollock 14y agoGold can be inflated the same way as any other currency. Since people don't typically trade in physical gold, but in certificates used to represent the gold, it is possible to print more certificates than you have gold. While this is a fraud, it is an increase in the money supply.
- fnordfnordfnord 14y agoYes, paper gold isn't gold. Or at least it won't be when you need it to be.
- wintersFright 14y agoPhysical gold bars are not money but a phyiscal, tradeable asset. It cannot be inflated except via mining - but even then there are roughly known quantities of metal in the ground that are then liberated. What can be inflated however is paper gold where more paper gold exists and is traded than physically exists - some estimate a 100 - 1 paper to physical ratio. True that gold has no intrisic value, it's value is derived from other people valuing it and willing to trade services for it - and they have done so for thousands of years, where as a typical fiat currency (USD) does not have such a timespan. "Paper money eventually returns to its intrinsic value – zero." (Voltaire, 1694-1778) btw - as i understand it wasn't a 10% tax, it was a mandatory debt for equity trade- meaning the depositors now own some part of the bank.
- InclinedPlane 14y agoGold can inflate quite easily, and does all the time, independent of its scarcity. It's possible for the price of anything and everything to go up, on an absolute scale. And if that happens accross the board then you've effectively inflated even some hypothetical absolute currency. Money has no value, it is in fact nothing more than tradeable debt. It has as much value as the market is willing to allow. To imagine this in an extreme case imagine if the entire worldwid economy collapsed and food bacame very much rarer. Now you'd expect to have to pay vastly more gold for food. Inflation. My point is that no part of the economy is static, all of it is dynamic. All of it. The value of everything, labor, goods, food, even money is dynamically dictated by the action of the economy.
- ars 14y agoThe intrinsic value of gold is also 0. The intrinsic value of EVERYTHING is 0. Things only have value because people want them, not because they have some intrinsic value.
- awakeasleep 14y agoThis sure seems like it would be a violation of a person's right to be secure from seizure of property in the USA. Does anyone with a legal background have any insight they want to share? I am having trouble wrapping my brain around the idea that money I have in the bank could be seized to pay for someone else's fuckup. I know inflation can sort of do that on a society-wide scale, but seizure of post-tax income from a private bank account? That's mind-boggling.
- snowwrestler 14y agoIn the U.S., a new tax like this would require an act of Congress. If it passed it would most likely be found Constitutional--there are basically no limits on the power of the Congress to levy a tax. But, it would take truly dire straits for Congress to even consider such an obviously unpopular idea. And those dire straits would have a much harder time arriving in the U.S. than the EU. Cypress (and Greece, and Italy, etc) is in such big trouble because they cannot print their own currency. The U.S. can always bail out its banks because it can create as many dollars as it needs. In fact this is what happened a few years ago, and why the U.S. financial system is currently in better shape than the EU. The flaws in the EU concept have been laid bare by this financial crisis. When you have financial consolidation without political consolidation, you get unelected bureaucrats deciding to take 10% of the bank accounts in one member nation, and there's nothing that population can do about it. In the U.S., the threat of getting voted out office is a powerful restraint on the governent's eagerness to levy shocking new taxes.
- Silhouette 14y agoWhen you have financial consolidation without political consolidation, you get unelected bureaucrats deciding to take 10% of the bank accounts in one member nation, and there's nothing that population can do about it. Part of the reason I think they're crazy to do this is that the above is obviously not true. There may be nothing the population can legally do about it, but we're living in a time when governments are in genuine danger of going bankrupt, funny money isn't worth the paper it's printed on, and people are literally worrying about essentials like putting food on the table and keeping a roof over their kids' heads. Sooner or later, if we continue down this path, something is going to give, spectacularly. Unfortunately, when that happens, it will probably come with a horrific body count and potentially even civil or all-out international war. That's the really terrifying thing about this whole mess: it is disrupting the basic fabric of society, the implicit trust we all place in our political and legal and financial systems so we can enjoy our modern, civilised lifestyles. We take a lot of things about that civil society for granted that we would miss dearly if they were gone. We can only hope that whoever thought this blatant cash grab was a good idea will come to their senses in time to contain the fallout if they go through with it.
- ahomescu1 14y agoThey would have never gone to a farmer and taken 10% of their grain. Except this actually used to happen a lot in European countries in the Middle Ages. Farmers would still pay taxes to the king, and they'd have to pay in goods if not in gold.
- burntsushi 14y ago> Except Pretty sure the OP was talking about the present times...
- ameister14 14y agoHave people changed significantly since then? Plus, he was saying that prior to banks being how they are now, things were different. That prior period encompasses the middle ages.
- burntsushi 14y ago> Have people changed significantly since then? I don't know. Your question is sufficiently general that a plausible answer could be given to support either "yes" or "no" answers. It is very dependent on what you mean by "change". And therein lay my answer: I don't know what you mean by "change". The poster in this case was touching on a point that going out and taking a farmer's property (or generally anyone for that matter) explicitly was very unlikely to happen, but taking it from a bank is considered something else entirely. I think that's fairly reasonable in the first world. Could a scenario arise in the future where that isn't reasonable? Sure. But, that's kind of beside the point here I think. If you extend your reasoning to the extreme, you could pretty much say to anything, "Well, humans have done it before so what's stopping them from doing it again?" The answer is nothing, but it's a red herring: it ignores the possibility that the chance of some Event X has gone down with the passage of time. Perhaps it has gone down so much, that it is no longer reasonable to address it if one want to maintain a modicum of concision.
- ameister14 14y ago
- yuhong 14y agoYea, there is a reason why Glass-Steagall was enacted.