5 ms·
No, no, no, no, no. We are always under surveillance - my neighbours know I stay up late watching crap tv, the bookshop assistant knows I browse the comics sec
by lifeisstillgood 14y ago
No, no, no, no, no.
We are always under surveillance - my neighbours know I stay up late watching crap tv, the bookshop assistant knows I browse the comics section but don't buy, and a hundred people each day see me do weird or normal things.
I am not oppressed when they do that. Embarrassed maybe, but not dragged of for "re-education".
As long as no-one uses the surveillance to force political outcomes from me or any individual, then this is pollution, not dictatorship.
Yes we need radical privacy laws - but not ones trying to put the genie back in the lamp. There are amazing benefits from technology - the sharing of knowledge seamlessly across 7bn people is going to ,produce wonders we cannot guess.
But we must embrace this new world - a world without secrecy. For privacy is not secrecy - it is politeness of our neighbours.
The problem is not my neighbours who know, it is companies across the world who now know. Their knowledge and actions are kept secret from me - and that must be prevented. Sunlight is the best disinfectant applies to targeted ads as much as corrupt politics.
Firstly any organisation that holds informant that can be used to identify and track people must publish the identifications they hold in real time. Expect a cottage industry of telling me about everything about me. Oh and those cottage industries must publish as well. So not a profitable cottage industry.
Seen me walk out the door of mcdonalds after paying with my Loyalty card - great mail me the link so I can see.
Secondly a legal framework that makes commercial profit from my identity only allowed if I consent and preferably if I get a cut. Want to sell me ads - great pay me. Oh suddenly finding ads less profitable? Want to sell me a coffee after that burger - you could use the freely published info mcdonalds has to fling my phone a coupon - but that's my information. I charge a flat 2c for every commercial use of my info - I get 2c even if I don't want coffee.
Thirdly, get used to the idea your wife instantly knows you are sleeping with the secretary.
- eurleif 14y agoThe surveillance you describe is ephemeral. After you move, your neighbors will forget you ever existed. The bookshop assistant probably forgets you the moment you walk out the door. Internet data is not that way. It potentially lasts forever. A fear I've heard expressed is that in the future, totalitarianism will arrive, and past data will be used against people.
- lifeisstillgood 14y agoWho will be running that totalitarian regieme and can we see their Facebook pages from their early twenties? In the end how the hell will you use data against people if you do not already do all the dictator necessary things anyway - torture, secrecy, disappearances. These are the things to fight, not the data storage but the people torture. March to stop privatisation of the army, to stop torture in our names, to stop child labour. Fix those, then we have nothing to fear about our Facebook shopping trends. Edit: some might comment that eg their sexual preferences might be discoverable on Facebook and that would be a breach of their rights to privacy. Firstly we change privacy - it has always been politeness not to mention what all your friends knew. The fact that anyone interested can now piece it together does not change that. Second - the use of that data "against" you only matters if it matters outside of politeness. Alan Turing could not today be prosecuted for being gay, could not be chemically castrated nor driven to suicide. Because the legal system has been changed - so that the only thing that matters if people find out you are gay is politeness. Live in a free society - have to learn to deal with impoliteness. Don't live in a free society - deal with that not the Internet. We know how to defeat dictators, and the iPhone won't fix it for free.
- enraged_camel 14y ago>>In the end how the hell will you use data against people if you do not already do all the dictator necessary things anyway - torture, secrecy, disappearances. Drone strikes too. Let's not forget that one.
- dmoo 14y agoBut if Turing were in Uganda for example http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2013/feb/04/gay-people-uganda-love-run http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2013/feb/04/gay-people-ugand...
- dwiel 14y agoThis doesn't work if access to that information tempts those in power to do things that they wouldn't have if the the information didn't exist.
- harryf 14y agoWhat's more is big data has the potential to do great good. For example Googles flu trends - http://www.google.org/flutrends/ http://www.google.org/flutrends/ - already helps us plan and use our resources efficiently when it comes to responding to mass illness. As we plot a course to 9 billion people on the planet being able to detect trends like this will be essential. On a more personal level, it's also telling us we're all human and all make similar mistakes. It's also telling us a lot about what being human actually means. This has the potential to move us past taboos and stigmas and address deeper questions about how to make ourselves smarter, better, happier. Here an example would be porn - the funny tale of a scientist who tried and failed to find a male control group that didn't watch porn - http://arstechnica.com/science/2009/12/weird-science-fails-to-locate-a-porn-free-control-group/ http://arstechnica.com/science/2009/12/weird-science-fails-t... . Now we've learned we're all watching porn we can move on from questions of right and wrong and begin dealing with questions like is it making use happier, how do we deal with addiction, why does it make some of us addicted and so on. So plus one to more sunshine. Lets use that data to learn about ourselves
- lifeisstillgood 14y agoThank you ! Exactly. And that's one way science can fail of course :-)
- goodside 14y agoNo company can possibly be expected to know exactly who they have information about, as would be needed to publish the disclosure you're talking about. On any web server, you have countless logged HTTP requests that are effectively anonymous to the business, but if a subpoena comes in asking for all activity from a specific IP, they're forced to disclose that activity. Only once the data is in law enforcement's hands does it cease to be anonymous, so sites can rat you out without knowing your name. The same scenario applies to third-party data sales. A company pays you to serve a tiny JS tracking snippet on your site, and because they have many such sites they can resolve the traffic back to real names, but you as a webmaster cannot. You've just sold data about a person you can't identify.
- lifeisstillgood 14y agoIf they cannot identify me they don't have to publish. If they subscribe to one of those services that has a pixel sized session on every page, aggregating all my details - then they have identifiable information, publish and pay up
- Apocryphon 14y agoYou're with David Brin's side as far as the secrecy issue goes, aren't you? It's definitely intriguing response to the traditional cypherpunk response of more secrecy- if you can watch the watchers right back, then the governments and corporations in the world are as vulnerable to surveillance as John Q. Public.
- gnosis 14y agoDavid Brin's position is incredibly naive. The rich and powerful can always buy themselves privacy and security. The rest of us won't have that luxury in such a "transparent society".
- jkn 14y agoThis is a good argument but not a definitive one. For example, if "sousveillance" is pervasive, the wealth and power of the few might be balanced by the number of people watching on them.
- lifeisstillgood 14y agoI may be wrong but this and GP seem to assume that watching / surveillance will always yield some power over others. This seems untrue especially if lots of other people can see the same feeds too. So mostly it's going to be social structures and conventions affected.
- tripzilch 14y ago> We are always under surveillance - my neighbours know I stay up late watching crap tv, the bookshop assistant knows I browse the comics section but don't buy, and a hundred people each day see me do weird or normal things. But none of this data is kept around forever, centralized, searchable and subpoena-able. Sure, in a sense, we've always been smearing our private data everywhere. But what you describe is tiny pieces of data distributed over many human agents with imperfect memories, especially with respect to the irrelevant details on the actions of the many people they encounter every day. This article is talking about databases, the largest of them owned by a handful of gigantic corporations. And even the smaller ones are just as easily accessible to the state. Hence, surveillance state. It doesn't matter that it's too much data, either. Storage is cheap, it'll just stay there waiting until someone needs to query it. And analysis and machine-learning algorithms are only getting better, to make these queries increasingly more specific, accurate and informative.