3 ms·
I wonder if they've thought this through. No really promising startup would go through all this just for a 1/n chance of $50k. This is structurally different
by pg 19y ago
I wonder if they've thought this through. No really promising startup would go through all this just for a 1/n chance of $50k.
This is structurally different from raising investment. An investor tries to fund (as far as they can tell) all the good startups that approach them. Here there is only one prize. Which means the better the applicants, the more likely you're wasting your time applying.
- pbnaidu 19y agoI would like to add one more thing... The startup/company should already be using their web services. I am not sure if they consider a good idea that potentially could use their web services.
- Tichy 19y agoI am not sure I understand: seems to me all work you have to invest initially is to fill in a one page form? Making it among the finalists, even if you don't win the grand price, you get some exposure, get to present to VCs, and hopefully have some fun. Where is the downside, except for having to make your idea public?
- eusman 19y agoGrand Prize $50,000 Cash Prizes for 4 Second-Prize Finalists $5,000 in AWS Credits A professionally developed video, filmed at their place of business, and posted on Amazon's website Exposure and promotion on Amazon.com and AWS websites Promotion in contest press release and other press activities Airfare and hotel accommodations in Seattle to meet and present to Amazon and Judges Panel Featured at the AWS Start-Up Challenge Awards Dinner in Seattle, WA with Amazon executives, industry leaders and VCs http://www.amazon.com/gp/browse.html?node=377635011 http://www.amazon.com/gp/browse.html?node=377635011
- pg 19y agoThe form might only take a day; the real time suck is for the finalists.
- rwebb 19y ago"An investor tries to fund (as far as they can tell) all the good startups that approach them." Is this your strategy with YC? There has to be some limit (x) on the number (n) of companies you can take on, making YC a x/n for 5000 + 5000founders, no?
- deleted 19y ago[deleted]
- eusman 19y agoI don't know how to ask this and not sound ironic...I hope it doesn't. Do you believe they would ignore a good startup and not invest in it even if they didn't win a prize?
- pg 19y agoI was only talking about the prize aspect of it. The rest is impossible to evaluate. All they say is that they'll make an offer of investment. That could either be good or worthless, depending on the amount, the valuation, and other terms. FWIW, my guess is that they'd err on the side of ignoring good startups. Amazon has not so far been in the investment business, and I don't think that is their goal here. Their goal is to promote AWS to startups. They're raising the prospect of investment because they know that's something many startups are interested in.
- altay 19y agoAmazon has invested in at least one startup: http://www.techcrunch.com/2007/02/25/amazon-invests-in-shelfari/ http://www.techcrunch.com/2007/02/25/amazon-invests-in-shelf... Whether or not it's a good startup is another question.
- DocSavage 19y agoAs you say, there's little work involved until you become a finalist. And if you become a finalist, I would think the minimum $5k + publicity is a good tradeoff for the trip to Seattle. A couple of other contests (Adobe, Facebook) were ridiculous because entering the contest, not even winning it, required signing away significant control of your web app and letting the sponsors make derivative web apps.
- ahsonwardak 19y agoGreat point. It reminds of a lot of scholarship applications. It sounds good, until you realize your chances. In some cases for scholarship money, you're better off trying to create your own wealth through a job or business idea.