3 ms·
This headline is both misleading and totally false. The author should have consulted a patent attorney before touching his keyboard. The new law does not chan
by otterley 14y ago
This headline is both misleading and totally false. The author should have consulted a patent attorney before touching his keyboard.
The new law does not change the basic requirements for a patent that the invention be novel, useful, and non-obvious. If prior art exists, the novelty requirement is not satisfied, and a patent either should not be issued, or should be deemed invalid in subsequent litigation.
What the new law does do is -- assuming no prior art exists -- potentially change the effective date at which an invention was "born." Previously, two competing inventors trying to obtain a patent at around the same time would seek to prove to the USPTO when the invention was born based on evidence of their work (research notes, implementation notes, etc.). This leads to a lot of difficult work and judgment, and frequent litigation among two competing parties.
Under the new law, however, the birthdate of an invention is when the patent application is filed. Simple as that.
As for the prior art concern, I can imagine folks saying, "well, if the new date is the date of filing, what about that other inventor who actually invented it first?" Here's the thing: it doesn't matter. If the other inventor did, in fact, invent it first, and publicized it, both parties would be out of luck. The first inventor would be ineligible to receive a patent because he publicized his work before filing, and the second inventor would be ineligible to receive a patent because of the prior art.