7 ms·
Linux computer shop closing
- lucb1e 14y agoLast time I submitted a Google+ link I received some feedback from people who couldn't read it. For those, here is a copy: --- http://www.hettes.nl/hettes-stopt http://www.hettes.nl/hettes-stopt [Dutch] This is sad. Translation: Hettes is closing We have to announce that we, the team of Hettes, can no longer deliver laptops with Ubuntu Linux or another Linux distribution. This is not because we want to or because of time or resources, but it's because we can't buy computers (anymore) without operating system. We started our webshop a few years ago with a lot of ambition and fun, continued developing it, and helped lots of customers with satisfaction. Since the beginning of our passion and ambition for the webshop with laptops and desktops with pre-installed Ubuntu Linux we've had problems with buying systems without operating system, or simply said without Windows. We have tried to continue our work in different ways and we have had small successes. However with Windows 8 all doors are being closed permanently and we see no way to open these. The worst of the story is that the community, you, as user of Ubuntu or another distribution were very happy with the different parties that deliver/delivered laptops and desktops with Linux and we always received positive and nice feedback from you. We'd like to continue our activities and serve users and consumers with your request for laptop and desktops, but we are not given the chance to do this. Because of this reason we decided to stop our internet activities. This does not apply to existing customers of Hettes, we as team have decided to continue technical support and warranties for you because, as we said, we're not closing because we want to, but because we are being held back by the large computer manufacturers.
- cooldeal 14y ago>but it's because we can't buy computers (anymore) without operating system. So were they buying computers from OEMs like Lenovo and Dell, installing Linux and then selling them? Why not assemble desktops from components? I believe the ODMs will sell laptops without OSes to distributors if the order is large enough. >However with Windows 8 all doors are being closed permanently and we see no way to open these. What has this to do with Windows 8 at all?
- lumberjack 14y agoThat's exactly what I was thinking. Theirs' seems like an unusual approach yet one that has it's advantages. I guess they would buy in bulk and leverage that so that they could get special preference regarding the OS? And they avoid having to build their own brand reputation, too. They can still buy from an ODM like Clevo and sell them under their own branding.
- justincormack 14y agoWindows 8 = UEFI Secure Boot. eg see https://lwn.net/Articles/503803/ https://lwn.net/Articles/503803/ it is going to be much more difficult to run Linux. Because of the dominance of Windows it may be harder to get motherboards without this, so there will be much less choice and you will need more technical knowledge to sell Linux stuff, eg maybe flash your own firmware.
- cooldeal 14y agoAll Windows 8 certified machines need the Secure Boot to be able to be turned off. I seriously doubt turning off an option in the BIOS/UEFI setup screen is going to hobble them. http://www.top-password.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2012/12/toshiba-secure-boot.jpg http://www.top-password.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2012/12/... > you will need more technical knowledge to sell Linux stuff, I would really really hope that a company installing and configuring Linux would have the technical chops to turn off a bios setting.
- sp332 14y agoAll Windows 8 certified machines This only applies to x86 platforms. ARM-based "Windows RT" systems are locked down. I think you're right about this case but I think it's important to remember that some EFI secure boot systems can't be unlocked.
- cooldeal 14y agoOh, please. A Windows RT system is not a Windows 8 certified machine, not even close, the capabilities are vastly different. Might as well point out that the "ARM-Based iOS systems" come with a locked bootloader.
- hp50g 14y agoThat's absolute bollocks. Asus still sell OEMs bare bones laptops with no license as do a fair number of Chinese brands.
- dsr_ 14y agoSystem76 is clearly buying laptops from OEMs and outfitting them appropriately; I imagine ZaReason is doing the same. You get devices of about the same quality as Dell or Compaq, with all the drivers you need already in place.
- narrator 14y agoThey can't find someone on Alibaba to ship them pcs without OSs?
- amalag 14y agoI am guessing they can't get good quality for generic alibaba manufacturers.
- raverbashing 14y agoI really doubt it Some OEM brands are good. Some name brands sell OEM computers /lines. Get some brands, models, test them.
- bmasci 14y agoIs this a secure boot / Microsoft key issue?
- jroseattle 14y agoI'm sympathetic to any small company that finds tough sailing due to competition. It sucks. That said, this really isn't surprising. The major hardware manufacturers are geared to sell Windows computers, not just computers. Make no mistake, the every-computer-has-Windows-8 structure is a decision by the manufacturers to gain discounts toward the cost of the OS. They do the same thing with video cards, hard drives, memory, etc. It's enough so that it makes a huge economic difference to do so. In terms of a business problem, this is a supplier issue relative to the cost of doing business. If the existing set of suppliers have a cost factor that doesn't work in your model, you find another supplier. And if no suppliers meet that criteria, then the market is making decisions for you. From the sounds of it, the major manufacturers don't find the desktop Linux market to be worth it for them to service. However, I've ordered a few systems from ASUS with no OS on it, so I would think there are still suppliers available that could do business.
- Surio 14y agoSigh! For those interested in the nuts and bolts of the issue with UEFI/dual-boot, etc.... http://www.linuxbsdos.com/2012/11/05/dual-boot-windows-8-and-ubuntu-12-10-on-uefi-hardware/ http://www.linuxbsdos.com/2012/11/05/dual-boot-windows-8-and...
- dragonbonheur 14y agoSeriously? If I was doing the same thing I'd be buying from ODMs like Compal, Quanta or Foxconn, not from Dell, Lenovo or HP. http://www.foxconnchannel.com/ http://www.foxconnchannel.com/ http://www.compal.com/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=68&Itemid=1446&lang=en http://www.compal.com/index.php?option=com_content&view=... http://www.quantatw.com/Quanta/english/product/qci_nb.aspx http://www.quantatw.com/Quanta/english/product/qci_nb.aspx
- SeanDav 14y agoI think that if Michael Dell or Steve Jobs were running that shop we wouldn't be seeing this message.
- Nux 14y agoWell, clearly they did not look around enough. How come these people can sell laptops and workstations without OS: http://pcspecialist.co.uk/ http://pcspecialist.co.uk/ (no affiliation) And they're just an example. Europe is full of this kind of small firms. I wonder what their real reason for quitting is.
- lucb1e 14y agoBecause hardware can be bought with another OS installed and then reinstalled with Linux (having checked whether it's fully compatible beforehand, though that's quite okay nowadays). Most others will probably be doing that, but then you're supporting the Microsoft empire, which is what Hettes was trying to avoid.
- CamperBob2 14y agoThe ethics and economics are frustrating to untangle. Without the Microsoft juggernaut, it's certainly true that we as users would have more choices. We could pay Apple $5000 for a Mac, Commodore $5000 for an Amiga, Sun $10000 for a Unix box, or pay steep prices to any number of other vendors selling incompatible boxes. Point being, I'm not sure the economics of buying a Windows box and overwriting the hard drive are really that bad, compared to what might have happened in a world without Microsoft's standardization efforts.
- gizmo686 14y agoStandardization would have happened without Microsoft. The progression of almost every new technology is that it becomes more standardized as it become more mature. Take operating systems as an example. At the beggining, every computer had its own OS and software written for one computer likely would not work on others. This was a problem, so eventually we came up with BIOS, which provided a standard software interface to different hardware. Later we had a similar divergence in operating systems. Eventually Bell Labs created UNIX. Excluding windows, the UNIX specification is the standard of most modern operating systems (OS X, GNU, BSD, Solaris, ETC).
- recoiledsnake 14y ago[Edit: Original HN title was "Linux computer shop closing because of thwarting by large companies."] Narrative about unnamed "large companies" trying to kill Linux? Check. Story about Microsoft Windows 8 killing off a poor Linux company? Check. Lack of any details like the names of companies that stopped shipping machines without OSes? Check. Lack of explanation about how exactly Windows 8 "closed the doors permanently" ? Check. This is just plain FUD designed to garner clicks and sympathy by invoking the bogeyman and it's working very well, just like usual. As an offtopic aside, even RMS is not immune from resorting to unproven FUD. For example from http://www.fsf.org/blogs/rms/ubuntu-spyware-what-to-do http://www.fsf.org/blogs/rms/ubuntu-spyware-what-to-do >This is just like the first surveillance practice I learned about in Windows. My late friend Fravia told me that when he searched for a string in the files of his Windows system, it sent a packet to some server, which was detected by his firewall. Given that first example I paid attention and learned about the propensity of "reputable" proprietary software to be malware I haven't been able to find any reputable reference for Windows sending local search keywords to "some server", maybe someone can point me to one. But the FUD campaign continues unchallenged and unabated, even in a community that prides itself to be technically superior to the unwashed masses.
- bcoates 14y agoThe windows search hitting the internet thing in XP is just a buggy software update mechanism, it doesn't send a search term. Here's a good explanation: http://www.theregister.co.uk/2002/04/11/winxp_search_assistant_silently_downloads/ http://www.theregister.co.uk/2002/04/11/winxp_search_assista...
- cooldeal 14y ago>But when I performed an Internet search, the Assistant sent my search terms to the Microsoft site, and also dropped a session cookie on my machine. OMG, an internet search sends keywords over the internet to an internet server! Stop the presses!
- znowi 14y agoI see your point and it makes sense. However, calling this FUD simply by stating the lack of data is not less of a FUD in itself. And on a grander scale, how many times you have seen a small shop taking a big corp out of business? I don't think immense forces like Microsoft require our zealous defense. They're more than able to defend themselves, unlike these guys. Even at an off chance this Dutch shop is a fraud, give them a benefit of a doubt, before you learn more about the case.
- windexh8er 14y agoI think in 5 years you'll see a resurgence of plain-old-computers. People will still be in the market for tablets, those that never needed a full blown desk/laptop to begin with. However, as more people begin to realize that they're just consumers of these new, handheld "TVs" of the Internet generation my hope is that the demand for boundary-less computing platforms will realize a resurgence. It's sad to see the overall industry being reduced to the world of locked out hardware because of... Software companies. Hypocritical? For sure. But if protecting the business model of a platform by ousting competition is the only way to lock in dominance I feel that's a cheap way to earn your keep. I think some would argue it's just the way things are today. I don't buy that. I tried to buy a Lenovo sans Windows and they informed me it was not possible. Not possible to not write a bloatware image to a hard drive, of which takes time and energy for Lenovo in the manufacturing process. Really? Don't tell me as a savvy consumer that it's not possible since that is an aggregious lie. Instead tell me that it is not something that within your catalog of product options. At least then it's not a lie.
- mbreese 14y agoWith the production lines that these manufacturers run, yes it is more expensive for them to pull a subset of computers and not load their bloatware windows image. That just isn't a situation they are setup for. You can argue about whether or not it should be this way, but that is the reality of the computer manufacturing process. Sure, it's more accurate to say they won't do it, but in all likelihood, they can't do it and keep their profit margin. Now if they were to stay that they were contractually obligated to install windows on every machine, then they'd have a problem.
- windexh8er 14y agoDisagree. If you've ever seen the manufacturing process it would just be a simple bypass. The installation of the images is done far closer to boxing than you likely realize. In all reality the bypass of that process could shave critical time off filling an order, especially when you're talking about made-to-order combinations. Now straight line runs are another story, but that's not the context of the conver
- lucb1e 14y agoI wonder what the alternative is for companies. For users or companies with a few computers, Linux is absolutely no problem once you get used to it. For power users I'd argue it's the only sensible choice. But what if you are running a 2000-employee company, how can you manage all workstations without a Windows domain? Does Mac have any alternatives, or are there open-source alternatives?
- gambiting 14y agoYes you can. There are solutions to move user profiles to a central server and boot from there. Mac can do the same thing with Mac OSX Server edition. An entirely different question is, is it sensible? Our university has two computer clusters accessible by Computer Science students only, one with Windows and other with Linux - 200 computers each. Guess which one is giving more problems? And the reason is that Windows server is a much more refined product. I would say that it's slower,but it makes sure everything is correct, double checks if there is no corruption, if the connection is authenticated, if you are not over your quota, and then it does fantastic job of restoring the machines to ideal state every day and keeping them updated. Linux does the same thing,but only partially. Profiles get corrupted frequently,because it just seems to write what comes from the network, and if it looses connection it takes a while before it realises that it happened. And after that, it proceeds as if nothing had happened, while Windows has procedures to repair user's profile. As a result, our admin is constantly fixing all the weird problems with Linux machines, while our Windows machines keep running most of the time without a fault. I am not saying that it's not possible to run Linux domain systems - but they require(in my experience) a lot more maintenance than Windows systems.
- lucb1e 14y agoOkay, thanks for the info. I thought as much actually, that there was a way for other OSs but that it's not really refined or practical. There should be a company that writes software so that Linux can do the same... hmm, or doesn't Red Hat? They're a paid distribution aren't they?
- 14y ago
- drcube 14y agoI had a little trouble finding a non-Windows laptop last time I bought one (summer 2012), but it wasn't impossible. If these guys are making most of their money from customization or support, why not resell System 76 laptops? Otherwise, buy big orders from Clevo or some other manufacturer. I sincerely hope this shop wasn't buying computers at Best Buy for resale.
- hettes 14y agoHettes has contact System 76, but it was not possible to get a partnership :(
- gambiting 14y agoI am sorry,but to me this entire article and comments below it are just a massive pile of whine. Large companies like Dell get Windows at such discounted prices that the difference between a machine with or without OS would be 10-15 dollars. It's not like having windows installed on a laptop is increasing its cost by $100. And why does a company mentioned in this article have a problem with Windows already pre-installed? Installation of Linux on such a machine is exactly the same as if there was no OS on it in the first place. Heck, they could even leave Windows and install Linux as a second OS,but make it boot by default - and then have it as an extra selling point - Linux computers,but with Windows as an option. Windows 8 is not sealing anything yet. And EFI problems are easy to overcome if you want to - and if your business depends on it, I believe that it would be in your best interest to want to?? To sum it all up - I believe that this entire story is made up and no shop even existed in the first place. If they could sell linux computers 3 or 5 years ago they could still do it today, and it seems like the entire article is constructed to just blame MS for problems that don't exist.
- tracker1 14y agoTo some extent I agree... With the volume discounts from MS, and the fees payed for the shovel-ware, the Windows laptop/desktop probably does cost less than no-OS. Even then, they could probably get a knockoff/blank laptop/desktop direct from mfg from china... for desktops, they can order case/psu/mb/cpu/ram and self-assemble, in the mid-high range machines ($650+) you can even beat the likes of Dell in terms of machine/$$. As much as it probably hurts their workflow, I'm willing to bet there are alternative avenues available.
- cron 14y agoIt's right and proper that microsoft receive a payment for every pc laptop sold?
- gambiting 14y agoSince when do they do that?? It must be new, since as far as I know Microsoft gets payment for their software. If a manufacturer decides to install Windows on their laptops, then Microsoft gets paid per licence. If they don't decide to install Windows,then MS doesn't get a single penny. Unless there is some new law that I missed that says that all new PCs HAVE to come with Windows, I think your question is moot.
- alexvr 14y agoWell that's just messed up. I have no problem with Microsoft's market dominance; I just think they're a problem since they give the finger to our freedom of choice.
- brudgers 14y agoNo supporting evidence makes me skeptical - what were they buying before and how has it changed? Beyond that, a retail computer shop closing isn't surprising - computer shops have been a high risk proposition for...well, forever. But one which limits itself to Linux, what were they competing on? Mostly price, it looks like. Otherwise paying for machines with Windows wouldn't be likely to break sales. And that's the problem with Linux in the mainstream. People expect Linux computers to be cheaper and that means that for the same margin, revenue is lower - it's a race to the bottom and it has to compete with HP. Throw in the much smaller size of the market segment for Linux and it just doesn't make sense as a business model. Don't get me wrong. Running a Linux only computer shop is not wrong. It needs to come about out of love - like a coffee shop, a B and B, or a used book store.
- hettes 14y agoThere are a lot of comments about the closing of the shop Hettes. I'm one of guys that were running the shop and I will explain something. ( in bad English, sorry ) We have search for manufacturers of desktops and laptops to buy without OS and after 3 years, we stop trying. We have spoken with Lenovo, HP and Fujitsu and they say it is not possible, they close the door. Other manufacturers didn't even replay on a e-mail. Okay, we had contact with BTO but the systems they make will not supported for 100% by Ubuntu, because most items have a double videocard or some of chip that is a problem. We believe that Linux systems is much better than Windows for proxily 80% of all desktop and laptop users, so we start a shop with systems includes a Linux OS. BUT! The OS must be easy in use for starters with Linux, that is one of the groundrules by selling hardware. We want to test, we didn't get the change; We want to buy without Windows, forget it; Okay, we want to send the Licence back, don't think about that; We want to work with manufacturers for the best userexperience, dont think about that either. So, that's not making sell laptops any easier. Thank you for all the support.