3 ms·
> Contractors are not employees, and the relationship is well defined, and not just to skirt some obligation. Contracting is a useful economic and social agree
by pron 14y ago
> Contractors are not employees, and the relationship is well defined, and not just to skirt some obligation.
Contracting is a useful economic and social agreement intended to define a more limited mutual responsibility than full employment, just as dating is not the same as marriage. No one would date if it were expected of them to treat their newly acquainted dates with the same responsibilities spouses are supposed to treat each other. On the other hand, what matters (socially and ethically, if not legally) isn't what the relationship or contract is called, but how it's expressed de facto. For example, I'm not too familiar with US laws, but in my country (Israel), courts grant domestic partners the same rights as married couples (when it comes to splitting property, or even when it comes to spouse health insurance), and contractors (or freelancers) are granted the same rights as employees (e.g. severance pay, insurance) if it is shown that they were contractors in name only (for example, if the contractors worked solely or mostly for one employer, or if they were not at liberty to turn down work without expecting immediate termination).
Since Uber's drivers are the very core of its business -- in fact, they are the most crucial "department" in the company -- it seems to me they are actually full employees, and must be treated as such. This is especially true if the drivers work in regular shifts, and are obligated to actually show up to work (I don't know if this is in fact the case; if not, Uber would naturally be less responsible for them).
- 18pfsmt 14y agoThere are no regular work hours, and nobody is obligated to show up. I know of a publicly traded company that has an almost identical model, but for freight. If you are interested, at a recent transportation conference, the CEO walked the audience through how it works. If you are interested, here's the transcript: http://seekingalpha.com/article/1252781-landstar-system-s-ceo-presents-at-jpmorgan-aviation-transportation-and-defense-conference-transcript http://seekingalpha.com/article/1252781-landstar-system-s-ce... N.B. You will have to hand edit HTML in order to avoid having to login.
- pron 14y agoIt may very well be that in this case Uber is right. I just don't like the sentiment, expressed in several comments, that the workers may do as they please -- leave or stay and shut up -- as long as they don't unionize. Just as the company has the power to control wages in order to maximize profit, so too the employees are well within their right to organize and try to use whatever power they have. This does not automatically make them crybabies.