5 ms·
Totally awesome! Too bad if the city ever find out, he'll be in trouble - sometimes government is a little too rule oriented. And this makes we want to put one
by ars 18y ago
Totally awesome! Too bad if the city ever find out, he'll be in trouble - sometimes government is a little too rule oriented.
And this makes we want to put one in my basement - I get water in there anyway, and the concrete floor is all cracked.
- cdr 18y agoYes, damn those governments and their insistence on rationality and safety and all that nonsense.
- deleted 18y ago[deleted]
- jrockway 18y agoYou seem to be being sarcastic. But a guy did this inside his own house. Do you really think the government should come in and save him from himself? Why?
- deleted 18y ago[deleted]
- derf 18y agoThe article didn't give a good description of the area around this guy's house... I, for one, would be concerned if I found out one of my neighbors had 3000 gallons of water in a poorly structured container in his garage. A collapse would most definitely affect me and my neighborhood. Aside from the inconveniences that would be caused, the neighborhood could very well end up stuck with the bill for repairing damage done to infrastructure (street, sewer, underground power lines, ...) For what it's worth, I'd also be concerned if I found out my neighbor was: stockpiling firearms, making meth in his bathtub, keeping pet tigers, storing 3000 gallons of gasoline in a tank in his garage. I'm not trying to make a direct comparison, just hopefully illuminating the fact that it might not all be about the government "[saving] him from himself"
- jrockway 18y agoAside from the inconveniences that would be caused, the neighborhood could very well end up stuck with the bill for repairing damage done to infrastructure (street, sewer, underground power lines, ...) After criminal damage is done, the state can press charges. Everything else is a very slippery slope. As an example, imagine your neighbor has a gas stove and accidentally leaves it on, unlit, all day. A pilot light turns on, and the house explodes, causing hundreds of thousands of dollars of damage. Should the government ban gas stoves? How about electricity? Finally, stockpiling firearms, making meth in the basement, keeping pet tigers, and storing 3000 gallons of highly-flammable liquid is not the same as having a small swimming pool. The things you list are generally illegal in all circumstances, but having a swimming pool is never illegal. Also, water just isn't that dangerous. The pool collapsing would probably not cause any more damage than watering a tree and forgetting you left the hose on. So, as I mentioned earlier, you are heading down a very slippery slope. Individual rights should trump the possibility of "inconvenience" to your neighbors. If anyone should be upset, it's this guy's insurance company.
- mr_justin 18y agoBuilding codes exist for a reason, simple as that.
- unalone 18y agoSo... once somebody creates a code that makes it perfect and right and unquestionable?
- derf 18y agoI don't think the government should ban gas stoves, but I don't want my neighbor running his own gas lines that don't meet the building codes. Can we agree that there is a grey area which covers where lines should be drawn in terms of personal rights vs. infringing the rights of others? It is certainly the crux of our system of government. We obviously disagree where the line is in this particular case, and I totally respect your vigilance. I do take issue with your statement "having a swimming pool is never illegal" -- that is certainly incorrect, at least by definition of the building codes in the jurisdiction I live in. But I agree, we are surrounded by slippery slopes.
- furburger 18y agoyes because someone else coming over to the house may not realize that this is dangerous, craptastic, etc. dude may actually be setting himself up for a huge liability should this ever fail on an unsuspecting guest....his house insurance won't cover it, its non-permitted work in any case he'll have to remove it if the house ever goes up for sale, there's no way that would pass inspection. the first thing an inspector will ask for is the permit for the work
- electromagnetic 18y agoAFIK he didn't modify the garage, so once it's time to sell all he has to do is drain it, disassemble it and no one will be the wiser. House insurance doesn't necessarily extend to a free standing garage, so he might be cleared there too, he just has to hope nothing disastrous happens to it.
- Raplh 18y agoIf the pool collapses with his kids in it, they might be killed. That plus the issue with damage to neighbors seems to provide a valid government interest to me.
- jonknee 18y agoHow would they be killed? It's effectively a large hot tub sitting in his garage. No more dangerous either.
- grouchyOldGuy 18y agoIf it blew out the walls of the garage, then the roof would collapse. That doesn't bode well for anyone under the roof at that time.
- ars 18y agoNotice I said rule oriented, and not intrusive or other similar words. You are right that they should insist on safety etc., and I have no problem with that. But what's the chance that they will evaluate the safety of this, vs. saying - no engineering plans? No inspector? No permit? Fail, big fine, and we'll bill you for demolition. And not even evaluate the specifics.
- furburger 18y agono permit = ripped down at owners expense, pure and simple
- Retric 18y agoI don't want to pay for a government inspection of this type of crap after the fact. It's far less expensive for the public to simply force him to take it down at his own expense if he lacks the proper inspections / permits. However, it's unlikely to become an issue until something bad happens which IMO is a reasonable compromise.