4 ms·
That's not the important part here. If two parties go to court to resolve a dispute over the legality or constitutionality of something that's normal. What's qu
by InclinedPlane 14y ago
That's not the important part here. If two parties go to court to resolve a dispute over the legality or constitutionality of something that's normal. What's quite unusual is the DoJ attempting to deny the ability of telcos to use the court system at all.
As an analogy imagine that you've just been arrested by a police officer and you are sitting in a dark, windowless room in handcuffs. The officer comes in and you say very clearly and plainly "I want a lawyer, I know my rights". Then the officer responds "you don't have any rights here, you're not getting a lawyer". Most people would probably be outraged, most people would probably experience a chill running down their spine accompanied by an onrush of fear. But this is not so different from what the DoJ was attempting here.
- ajross 14y agoThe important difference here is that the DoJ made that argument before a court and didn't decide for itself in a "dark, windowless room". You're invoking an image of unfettered power that doesn't match reality. This was a law suit, by definition it was going to be settled by the judiciary, not the DoJ.
- SoftwareMaven 14y agoI think the chilling thing is that, right or wrong, many people believe the JD thinks it ought to have those kinds of powers. Any move it shows that looks like they are trying to actually grab it ("You aren't allowed to contest an NSL that way.") makes people uncomfortable. I do agree that the system, so far, is working as designed, and it is just appearances that are causing discomfort.