10 ms·
This part is a big WTF: "After the telecom challenged the NSL, the Justice Department took its own extraordinary measure and sued the company, arguing in court
by mmastrac 14y ago
This part is a big WTF: "After the telecom challenged the NSL, the Justice Department took its own extraordinary measure and sued the company, arguing in court documents that the company was violating the law by challenging its authority."
- dreamdu5t 14y agoThat's incredibly alarming. This is Obama's justice department too, headed by people he personally appointed.
- KoulMomo 14y agoObama's justice department has been just as horrible, if not more-so than Bush's justice department.
- Shivetya 14y agoThe real tragedy is the free pass the press gives him, if Bush had pulled this, the drone hits, fast and furious, and more, we would have at least had the press on our side. I can, but don't have to accept, members of his own party turning a blind eye, I will never accept a press which has.
- Cushman 14y agoI don't see it. Bush started a literal war of aggression with press support; we're supposed to expect them to get up in arms over a few assassinations?
- anigbrowl 14y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Drone_attacks_in_Pakistan#Statistics http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Drone_attacks_in_Pakistan#Stati... http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ATF_gunwalking_scandal#2006.E2.80.932008:_Operation_Wide_Receiver_and_other_probes http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ATF_gunwalking_scandal#2006.E2.... Note the dates. In fairness to the press, it's not surprising that the firs 5 years of drone strikes received little press coverage, because we had become involved in a much larger war in Iraq. I'm somewhat tolerant of drone strikes; all told they seem to have killed about 3,200 people at the highest estimate, which sounds bad until you consider lowest estimate for the Iraq war is 110,000 deaths, of which over half are civilians. The median estimate is about double that. Drones are sort of scary for a variety of reasons, but there is at least some basis for fighting that conflict (directly responsive to 9-1--2001 attacks) and the casualties from done warfare are a fraction of those from conventional warfare, by about 2 orders of magnitude.
- belorn 14y agoIt still doesnt make it right, nor is it any sane or logic reasoning behind the drone use. Ever time I hear someone explain the wars as an legit response to the 9/11 attack, it sounds as an "excuse" a kid would make after a school massacre. Oh look he say, there was this evil kid who hit and kicked me that other day, so I took my dads machine gun and extracted my revenged. The other children and teachers sheltered that bully, so they deserved what they got. It was justice, he said. There are no sane reasoning behind such claim. There are also no sane reasoning behind any claimed connection between 9/11 and the current wars or drone usage. I understand that the kid received a great injustice from the bully. I can understand the need for revenge. 9/11 was also a great injustice where people craved for revenge. But sanity left quick after, and we got schools with dead bodies and two wars. That, and drones.
- anigbrowl 14y agoWell, the government is constitutionally obliged to defend the citizenry. Any President that went on TV and said 'you know, we sort of deserved that due to our past foreign policy, so we should take it on the chin' would almost certainly have been impeached. Now I do see whare you're coming from, and somewhat agree, but I'm making n argument about what's legal as opposed to what's right. I think, for example, that once we withdraw our troops from Afghanistan Congress should sunset the AUMF and define the scope of Presidential authority to fight future terrorism much more narrowly.
- rayiner 14y agoAre we talking about the same press that cheer-led us into the Iraq war? And on a macro scale--the same press that has basically deified Ronald Reagan? The American press has never been opposed to blowing up foreigners, because Americans believe it is our god-given right to blow up foreigners. This is true regardless of what party is in power. To the extent that there is opposition, it is rooted solely on the impact of military action on Americans--servicemen killed in action, money spent out of the Treasury, etc. That's why the press finally turned against Bush when Iraq continued to drag on. And that's also why the press doesn't care about drone strikes--the American drone operators aren't getting shot at nor do they cost us a lot of money. That's why they didn't care about cruise missiles under Clinton, either.
- foobarqux 14y agoThe press don't care because of structural reasons not because of a belief system common to Americans. Press reporting is systemically biased in favor of powerful interests that influence them by carrot and by stick.
- rayiner 14y agoHave you spoken to many Americans? I went to college in Atlanta, Georgia (a pretty liberal place as far as the South goes). A year or so after the 9/11 bombing, I remember my classmates talking about how we should turn the Middle East into a glass parking lot. Quite seriously, with zero disagreement from anyone else. This was at a well-regarded engineering school, so these weren't stupid people, and indeed they were all very nice guys. We're just a tribal people--it's "our tribe" versus "their tribe" and the use of force on people outside the tribe is seen dramatically differently than the use of force on people within the tribe. You don't need to reach to "bias" and "powerful interests" to see why the media reports the way it does. The media is a reflection of the beliefs of the American people.
- badgar 14y agoI think that different Americans believe different things. Believe it or not, your paragraph of an anecdote from 11 years ago doesn't do much to convince me otherwise.
- KoulMomo 14y agoI don't think that the press is giving him a pass, so much as what he is doing has the approval of BOTH parties. The press (I'm talking about the one that drives the political discourse, in this case, the major news networks) is divided into three teams: 1) MSNBC aka Team Democrat 2) Fox News aka Team Republican 3) CNN aka Team WE'RE NEUTRAL WE'RE NEUTRAL, PLEASE DON'T CALL US BIASED Team Democrat will almost never say a bad word about Obama because he is a Democrat (and this would anger his base, aka their viewers). Team Republican actually APPROVES of what he is doing so don't attack him on it (instead choosing to focus on attacking a fictional Obama character who is a "Socialist Atheist Muslim Commie Infiltrator born in Kenya"). This leaves CNN, who out of fear of ever being called biased, attempt to be neutral (as opposed to objective) and so take part in "he said, she said" journalism, and right now, both he and she are saying the same thing: "OBAMA NATIONAL SECURITY POLICY GOOD". examples: 1) Democrats say Obama's new healthcare bill will help decrease the deficit, Republicans say it will add to the deficit. What's the reality? The f*ck should I know? It's not like we do any investigative journalism here, let me instead have a split screen of two a$$holes engaged in a shouting match. One representing team Democrat and the other, team Republican. 2) Democrats say that Paul Ryan's budget proposal does not offer any specifics as to how exactly he would lower the deficit and thus is not a serious proposal. Paul Ryan disagrees. Who's telling the truth? I don't know, it's not like I know how to read or anything. I also specifically picked these examples to mention another trend, that of CNN (and other news networks/outlets hoping to earn the moniker of neutral/bi-partisan), fearful of charges of being part of the "liberal media" will over-correct, and usually be harsher on Democrats than Republicans.
- jtc331 14y agoThe irony is that their argumentation in court is identical to that of the Bush DOJ.
- khuey 14y agoIt's almost as if most of the people involved are career bureaucrats and don't change with the party in power.
- sixQuarks 14y agoAs someone who is not affiliated with either party, I really don't get Obama supporters. He was supposed to bring change to the white house, instead, he has expanded Bush-era secrecy and has eroded our civil liberties even further... and not a peep from his support base. In my view, democrats are the lesser of two evils, but I'm just surprised that nothing has been done about this.
- r00fus 14y agoThe depressing part is realizing that Obama is actually the lesser of two evils (two elections running), and that worse could be happening right now in terms of rights erosion and increase in security-state. There is no left-wing remaining in power in this country. You only have corporatists and reactionary extremists corporatists.
- ericd 14y agoIt seems as though you may need to be a corporatist to raise a war chest comparable to the corporatists. It seems like the logical/natural steady state of elections with deregulated campaign finance...
- jtc331 14y agoJust something to chew on: I think you've set up a false dichotomy. It is also possible that the problem is not deregulated campaign finance but rather the increasing shift away from a constitutional republic form of government to a democracy. One of the big benefits of a republican (small "R", not the party) form of government is that it's far more difficult to buy off because at conventions each delegate (which are generally grass-roots involved people who have no financial incentive) has the same influence regardless of which candidate has the most money.
- nwzpaperman 14y agoRegulated campaign finance...who writes the rules? The problem is fundamental to the structure and it is inevitable that, over time, every government becomes tyrannical. Thomas Jefferson made it clear for the ages, "the tree of liberty must be refreshed from time to time with the blood of patriots and tyrants." Governments are of man and man is prone to taking advantage of and abusing his or her peers. "When the people fear their government, there is tyranny; when the government fears the people, there is liberty. I am not a friend to a very energetic government." - Thomas Jefferson "What has been will be again, what has been done will be done again; there is nothing new under the sun."
- anigbrowl 14y agoThis is exactly what's supposed to happen; the DoJ brought the dispute to the judicial branch and asked a court to resolve it, as opposed to arresting people or seizing control of the assets. They didn't seek the breakup of the company or the arrest or ruin of its officers, they asked the court to require compliance with what they believed to be a valid request in the form of the NSL. The court sided with the defendant, and the DoJ is going to have to abide by that unless they win at appeal. This is exactly why we have a judicial branch to begin with. You should be celebrating.
- guelo 14y agoWrong. The telecom's suit is the challenge that you're talking about. The second suit claims that the first lawsuit is illegal. It would mean that you're not allowed to challenge the government in court. It would make your flowery language invalid.
- anigbrowl 14y agoI am not wrong, and you have misunderstood my claim. See the judgment at https://www.eff.org/document/nsl-ruling-march-14-2013 https://www.eff.org/document/nsl-ruling-march-14-2013 Page 2, lines 11-13.
- jholman 14y agoI'm trying to understand your claim here. If I understand correctly, the sequences of events is like this: A) FBI issues NSL to ISP, demanding information, and prohibiting disclosure. B) ISP starts a proceeding challenging constitutionality of gag C) FBI starts a separate proceeding reasserting validing of gag D?) Wired also claims that the FBI claimed that step B violated the law, but I don't see that in the ruling link you posted. Why is step C needed? Not that it seems that bad.... But if D happened, that seems really alarming.
- anigbrowl 14y agoIANAL or a procedural expert, and more importantly I have not read all the filings so far, but my understanding is that the tension between steps B and C goes like this: B) ISP files suit, argues 'this ain't constitutional, we shouldn't have to comply.' DoJ disagrees. C) FBI counter-files, asserting that even if ISP prevails in step B), it should comply in the meantime rather than temporize pending the outcome. I can understand why they would, since they may in good faith consider time to be of the essence in obtaining the information they seek - which is part of their job, after all. I'm not that troubled by D, insofar as undercover operations realistically require a degree of secrecy. What was troubling about the NSL regime was that it asserted this secrecy by default; I expect that in the future the government will still get NSLs but will first go through something like the FISA court and essentially ask a court for a gag order, presenting evidence under seal. This is IMHO how it ought to have been from the start.