4 ms·
Chicken Scheme and it's use of Baker's "Cheney on the M.T.A." allocation and GC is intensely neat ... but correct me if my analysis was wrong: isn't it inherent
by hga 14y ago
Chicken Scheme and it's use of Baker's "Cheney on the M.T.A." allocation and GC is intensely neat ... but correct me if my analysis was wrong: isn't it inherently single threaded?
(No problem for a lot of people, but my particular area of interest is making SMP/ccNUMA systems sing. In Lisp. :-)
- cryptonector 14y agoAny time you have closures you have threading issues. Think: if two threads call the same closure concurrently, how do they synchronize access to closed variables? I don't know if Chicken Scheme allows multiple distinct instances of the run-time in one process -that would be very cool, and if anyone knows please do tell here-, but it can't safely support multi-threading any more than any standard Scheme can. To get what you want in a Lisp you need to apply either Erlang concepts (threads with distinct global namespaces, exchanging serialized data via messaging) or Clojure concepts (immutable state + COW techniques + special top-level, mutable variables with synchronization for all mutable state; but I repeat myself, since that's roughly what COW implies).
- rayiner 14y ago> Any time you have closures you have threading issues. Think: if two threads call the same closure concurrently, how do they synchronize access to closed variables? > To get what you want in a Lisp Several Common Lisp implementations expose pthreads-style shared memory threads (SBCL, ECL, Clozure, Allegro, etc). It works just fine. The problem of synchronizing access to the closed-over variables in a closure is precisely the same as the problem of synchronizing access to instance variables of a class, and has the same solution: use a mutex.
- coldtea 14y ago>Think: if two threads call the same closure concurrently, how do they synchronize access to closed variables? Same way you do it in C/C++/Java etc with their threads? Not really a unique to closures problem. >(To get what you want in a Lisp you need to apply either Erlang concepts (...) or Clojure concepts Or this fancy CSP thing? (Is it similar to Erlang? I don't know Erlang).